Which English Do LLMs Prefer? Triangulating Structural Bias Towards American English in Foundation Models

Mir Tafseer Nayeem, Davood Rafiei · 2026

Read Which English Do LLMs Prefer? Triangulating Structural Bias Towards American English in Foundation Models by Mir Tafseer Nayeem, Davood Rafiei (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-04204.txt.

Introduction

Mir Tafseer Nayeem and Davood Rafiei asked how English (US) became the default in large language models. Using British English as a reference, they built a set of 1,813 matched American and British variants and introduced DiAlign, a training-free method for estimating regional alignment. American English led across 21 post-training datasets and all six audited pretraining corpora, was packed more compactly by tokenizers, and stayed the dominant default under neutral prompting. The authors framed this as structural bias with risks of linguistic homogenization and inequity in global AI deployment.

Catalog record

CREATORMir Tafseer Nayeem, Davood Rafiei
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91661
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.04204

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Which English Do LLMs Prefer? Triangulating Structural Bias Towards American English in Foundation Models Mir Tafseer Nayeem, Davood Rafiei Abstract Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed in high-stakes domains, yet they expose only limited language settings, most notably “English (US),” despite the global diversity and colonial history of English. Through a postcolonial framing to explain the broader significance, we investigate how geopolitical histories of data curation, digital dominance, and linguistic standardization shape the LLM development pipeline. Focusing on two dominant standard varieties, American English (AmE) and British English (BrE), we construct a curated corpus of 1,813 AmE–BrE variants and introduce DiAlign , a dynamic, training-free method for estimating dialectal alignment using distributional evidence. We operationalize structural bias by triangulating evidence across three stages: (i) audits of six major pretraining corpora reveal systematic skew toward AmE, (ii) tokenizer analyses show that BrE forms incur higher segmentation costs, and (iii) generative evaluations show a persistent AmE preference in model outputs. To our knowledge, this is the first systematic and multi-faceted examination of dialectal asymmetries in standard English varieties across the phases of LLM development. We find that contemporary LLMs privilege AmE as the de facto norm, raising concerns about linguistic homogenization, epistemic injustice, and inequity in global AI deployment, while motivating practical steps toward more dialectally inclusive language technologies. 1 Introduction The United Nations recognizes the right to use one’s own language freely and without discrimination ( 82 ) . Modern software systems operationalize this principle through localization ( 77 ) , offering explicit language settings. Large language models (LLMs), now widely deployed in domains such as education ( 75 ) , law ( 41 ) , and public administration ( 37 ) , often lack such flexibility. Widely used platforms such as ChatGPT and Claude expose only ‘‘English (US)’’ as a selectable option. As governments and institutions adopt these models, the privileging of a single variety of English acquires systemic significance. This raises a foundational question: which variety of English do LLMs implicitly prefer? Within the scope of this study, we focus on two dominant standard varieties, American English (AmE) and British English (BrE), because they combine outsized institutional influence with well-documented contrasts, enabling a controlled and high-precision analysis. We examine how AmE functions as the digitally dominant and structurally advantaged default, while BrE remains widely institutionalized yet comparatively marginalized, and how these asymmetries are encoded and propagated across the entire LLM development pipeline. The global dominance of English reflects two historical trajectories : British colonial expansion, which entrenched English in governance and education across Africa, Asia, and other regions, and twentieth-century American hegemony, which spread English through commerce, media, and technology ( 14 ; 64 ) . Sociolinguistic research shows that power and prestige determine which forms are legitimized or marginalized ( 39 ; 40 ) , even as English develops into multiple varieties shaped by local identities ( 81 ) . Divergences between AmE and BrE span spelling, vocabulary, grammar, structure, idioms, style, and pronunciation (see Table 1 ) ( 49 ) . 1 1 1 wiki/Comparison_of_American_and_British_English , accessed February 06, 2026. BrE retains normative prestige in many former colonies (Figure 1 ), including South Asia, Nigeria, and Singapore, where it remains embedded in governance, education, and law. 2 2 2 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_English , see Appendix A for a brief historical background. It is also the standard of EU institutions and underpins “Commonwealth English” ( 12 ) , while AmE dominates global culture and digital communication through Hollywood, music, mass media, and technological platforms ( 27 ) , positioning it as a de facto global norm. The authority of these standards derives not from linguistic merit but from sociopolitical power ( 53 ; 47 ) . Central to the success of LLMs is their training on massive internet-derived corpora, where English accounts for roughly 50 – 60 % of global web content ( 17 ; 67 ) . Although dataset compositions are often undisclosed, available evidence suggests that English constitutes about 92.65 % of GPT-3’s training data, 3 3 3 OpenAI GPT-3 Dataset Language Statistics (GitHub, accessed February 06, 2026) 89.7 % of Llama 2’s ( 80 ) , and nearly 90 % of Claude 2’s ( 6 ) . The critical question, then, is which forms of English these models preferentially learn, encode, and propagate. While reliance on English-heavy corpora reflects the language’s global dominance, it also foregrounds an underexplored issue: whether LLMs reproduce asymmetries between AmE and BrE rooted in distinct historical and sociopolitical trajectories. We investigate how these dynamics manifest across the LLM development pipeline by asking whether and how models exhibit preferences, what those preferences reveal about broader socio-technical biases, and what consequences such preferences may carry. Level British English ( ) American English ( ) Orthography colour, centre, organise, travelling, favourite, cheque, jewellery, programme, catalogue, defence color, center, organize, traveling, favorite, check, jewelry, program, catalog, defense Vocabulary mobile phone, zebra crossing, city centre, railway station, car park, postcode, holiday, flat, lift, queue, pavement, torch, fizzy drink, ice lolly cell phone, crosswalk, downtown, train station, parking lot, ZIP code, vacation, apartment, elevator, line, sidewalk, flashlight, soda, popsicle Grammar/usage I’ve just eaten ; at the weekend ; Have you got a pen? ; The team are winning ; different from I just ate ; on the weekend ; Do you have a pen? ; The team is winning ; different than Conventions single quotes; punctuation outside quotes; 31 December 2024 ; ground floor ; 11.15 pm ; 20^{\circ} C double quotes; punctuation inside quotes; December 31, 2024 ; first floor ; 11:15 PM ; 68^{\circ} F Table 1: Representative distinctions between British English ( ) and American English ( ) across orthography, vocabulary, grammar, and writing conventions. Examples reflect common majority-preference usage and are illustrative rather than exhaustive (more in Table 9 and Table 10 of Appendix). We seek to identify a root cause: structural bias , an under-studied form of linguistic bias whereby language technologies, by design, may favor certain languages, dialects, or sociolects over others ( 8 ) . To our knowledge, this is the first systematic and multi-faceted examination of its impact on standard English varieties. Such biases can produce epistemic injustice ( 25 ) , whereby marginalized linguistic communities are underrepresented in algorithmic systems ( 30 ) . If LLMs implicitly treat AmE as the default or normative form, the consequences extend beyond stylistic preference to concerns of linguistic homogenization and degraded user experience. Rather than documenting task performance disparities solely as downstream failures ( 87 ; 22 ; 45 ; 42 ) , we trace how such asymmetries, interpreted through geopolitical histories of data curation, digital dominance, and linguistic standardization, emerge across pretraining corpora, tokenizers, and generative behaviors of modern LLMs. Methodologically, we ground this analysis in two core components (§ 3 ). First, we construct a curated corpus of 1,813 parallel AmE–BrE lexical variants, manually compiled from authentic linguistic sources and web-based lexicons, to support consistent and high-precision analysis across the paper. Second, we introduce DiAlign , a simple, dynamic, and training-free method for estimating dialectal alignment of a text by leveraging distributional evidence (§ 3.1 ), designed to capture lexical, grammatical, structural, stylistic, and multi-word contrasts. Using these components,

Read the complete text