The Democratic Ontology Deficit: How AI Systems Fail to Represent What Democracy Requires Volume: 1 1 4

Robert M. Ceresa, Juan E. Ceresa · 2026

Read The Democratic Ontology Deficit: How AI Systems Fail to Represent What Democracy Requires Volume: 1 1 4 by Robert M. Ceresa, Juan E. Ceresa (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-03865.txt.

Introduction

Robert Ceresa and Juan Ceresa identified a democratic ontology deficit in AI systems: the gap between what democratic life requires and what models learn to represent. Democratic life needs roles, duties, ties, and shared aims to stay visible as lived guides. Probing three instruction-tuned models with contrastive stimuli, they found the default picture organized around independence, not civic structure. The deepest gap sat in role, where models defaulted to individual over communal identity. The pattern held across model designs and training generations, opening a program for civic alignment.

Catalog record

CREATORRobert M. Ceresa, Juan E. Ceresa
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77506
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.03865

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Democratic Ontology Deficit: How AI Systems Fail to Represent What Democracy Requires Volume: 1 1 4 Robert M. Ceresa, Juan E. Ceresa Abstract . Background: Democratic public life depends on institutions that make roles, responsibilities, relationships, and purposes intelligible as lived orientation. Contemporary AI systems are trained on web-scale corpora and aligned for helpfulness, harmlessness, and honesty, but the representational structure of democratic institutional life has not been treated as an alignment target. Objectives: This paper identifies and tests the democratic ontology deficit : the structural mismatch between the representational conditions democratic agency requires and the ontology contemporary AI systems are built to learn and reproduce. We define four civic primitives—role, responsibility, relationship, and purpose—as the minimal representational structure required to interpret public action as institutionally situated, and ask whether these primitives are present in the model’s default orientation. Methods: We apply representation engineering ( Zou et al. 2023 ) to three instruction-tuned models (Llama-2-13b-chat, Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2, and Meta-Llama-3-8B-Instruct), extracting reading vectors for civic reasoning and its four component primitives using contrastive stimuli. We measure default orientation by projecting unframed judgment-call scenarios onto each reading vector. As a benchmark, we replicate the honesty reading vector on the same model using the same method. Results: The model’s default ontology is organized under independence rather than civic structure. The deepest deficit is in role: the model’s representation of what a person is defaults almost entirely to individual rather than communal. Against the model’s dominant default frame of independence, every civic primitive except relationship collapses. Honesty, measured on the same model at the same layer using the same method, scores 0.707; civic role scores − - 0.047. The pattern replicates across architectures and training generations—Llama 3’s improved alignment training raises honesty from 0.707 to 0.905 while civic structure does not improve. Conclusions: The difference between honesty and civic role reflects not a technical limitation but a gap in the alignment research agenda. We define civic architecture as the design response: the structured representational distinctions that must be built into a model’s core to make democratic institutional life legible within machine reasoning. These findings open a concrete research program for civic alignment using the tools the field already possesses. \JAIRAE \JAIRTrack 1. Introduction Artificial intelligence (AI) is entering the public world at a moment when democracy is struggling to hold its own form. Schools, governments, workplaces, and civic organizations continue to function, but they no longer provide the structure through which people interpret responsibility, locate themselves in a shared moral world, and build collective power. Public life has thinned. The institutions that once carried judgment and meaning have become harder to inhabit. People still feel the weight of responsibility, but they lack the scaffolding that once helped them understand how their actions mattered to others as well as the larger society. This is not only a political crisis. It is a crisis of form. A democratic society depends on institutions that make public life intelligible. When those institutions weaken, democracy loses the architecture that sustains it. The condition is dangerous. Polarization and cynicism grow in a society that no longer generates a sense of common purpose, much less a sense of collective power. Powerlessness turns the disappointments people experience every day into alienation. Conflicts become spectacle. Trust in institutions and eventually faith in self-government itself erodes. AI systems are being built and deployed within this erosion. They shape not only how people search for information, but how they interpret choices, understand the actions of others and the relationships that connect people together. Yet the dominant forms of AI do not recognize the structure of democratic life. They treat language as data, public action as behavior, and institutions as administrative containers. They provide answers but not civic orientation. They offer prediction without interpretation. They generate information without making responsibility and the opportunities to build a common life visible. AI systems are built on an ontology that doesn’t represent what democratic life requires. They inherit the thin, individualized, and decontextualized view of public life that marks modern politics, culture, and society. This paper argues that the alignment of AI models should be grounded in the representational structure of democratic institutional life. Democratic public philosophy—from Dewey through Boyte ( Boyte 2004 ) , March and Olsen, Allen, and Young—locates citizenship not in abstract status but in the institutional roles and everyday practices through which people exercise judgment, bear responsibility, build collective power, and act with others toward shared purposes. These are not peripheral features of democracy. They are its operating structure. If AI systems are to support democratic agency rather than erode it, that structure must be legible within the model’s representational core. We call the representational conditions that democratic life requires civic infrastructure —the scaffolding of roles, responsibilities, relationships, and institutional purposes through which public action becomes intelligible. The term is deliberate. Infrastructure, in the material sense (roads, grids, water systems, communication networks), is what makes complex coordination possible without requiring every participant to rebuild the conditions of action from scratch. Civic infrastructure does analogous work at the level of meaning: it provides the representational ground through which people can interpret their situation, recognize what they owe, understand what they are working toward, and act with others to build a shared world. When civic infrastructure thins and institutions no longer carry these distinctions as lived orientation, democratic agency loses its foundation. Civic architecture is the design response. It names what must be built into an AI model to supply the representational structure that civic infrastructure provides in institutional life: the structured distinctions of role, responsibility, relationship, and purpose that make democratic action legible within machine reasoning. A civically aligned AI is one whose representational architecture can make the institutional conditions of democratic life visible, not only to public agencies, but to anyone whose actions carry public consequence, which in a democracy is everyone. In a democracy, every role has a public dimension. Teachers, nurses, engineers, service workers, supervisors, caregivers, neighbors, all participate in the ongoing labor of building and sustaining public life. A civic architecture model supports that participation. It helps people see the responsibilities they hold and the relationships that give responsibilities meaning and impact. This paper treats contemporary AI not primarily as a tool that produces outputs, but as a representational infrastructure that reorganizes what can be seen, said, and held responsible in public life. The question is not only whether AI systems are accurate, fair, or transparent, but what kind of world AI systems’ representational logic makes available to democratic agency. The core problem is what this paper calls the democratic ontology deficit . The problem is the mismatch between the institutional conditions democratic agency requires and the representational ontology contemporary AI systems are built to learn and reproduce. The deficit describes a gap with three linked elements: (1) The prior thinning of institutional life that once made roles, responsibilities, and shared consequences intelligible (2) The inheritance of that thinning in AI systems trained on web-scale language corpora where institutional roles, responsibilities, and purposes are rarely encoded as structured distinctions (3) The amplification that occurs when such systems are deployed as public infrastructure The democratic ontology deficit is not reducible to familiar critiques

Read the complete text