Perceptual Gaps: ASCII Art and Overlapping Audio as CAPTCHAs

Chong Choon-Hou Rafael · 2026

Read Perceptual Gaps: ASCII Art and Overlapping Audio as CAPTCHAs by Chong Choon-Hou Rafael (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-03612.txt.

Introduction

Chong tests whether tasks humans evolved built-in neural wiring for can serve as CAPTCHAs now that multi-mode large language models defeat old ones. He offers two CAPTCHA classes: a vision CAPTCHA drawing letter-digit strings as ASCII art, and an audio CAPTCHA asking questions over layered or noisy audio. No tested large language model solves a single ASCII CAPTCHA. The best guesses at most one or two symbols, and audio models perform only slightly better than random.

Catalog record

CREATORChong Choon-Hou Rafael
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36258
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.03612

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Perceptual Gaps: ASCII Art and Overlapping Audio as CAPTCHAs Chong Choon-Hou Rafael Abstract . As multimodal large language models (LLMs) advance, traditional CAPTCHAs have become obsolete at distinguishing humans from bots. To address this shift, this paper aims to investigate the possibility of using tasks for which humans have evolved highly specialised neural processing. We introduce two CAPTCHA classes: a vision-based CAPTCHA, which renders alphanumeric strings as ASCII art, and an audio-based CAPTCHA, which is a question-answering task with overlapping or noise-corrupted audio context. We evaluate our vision-based CAPTCHA both as text and image input with multiple frontier LLMs (GPT 5.2, Gemini 3, etc.), and assess our audio-based CAPTCHAs by applying augmentations like background noise, Gaussian noise, and overlapping speech. We determined that none of the LLMs were able to solve a single ASCII-based CAPTCHA, with the best performing model only being able to infer at most one or two characters. Additionally, all models that supported audio performed only modestly better than random when solving audio CAPTCHAs. Our results suggest that these CAPTCHAs are exceptionally effective today, but it is unclear whether it can withstand the fast-evolving landscape of artificial intelligence. Subsequent research is needed to determine whether these tasks are temporary vulnerabilities or represent a more durable method of distinguishing humans from bots. 1. Introduction Adoption of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools and agentic systems have seen a meteoric rise in the last few years. With the increasing advancement of specialised tools like AI Agents and advanced multimodal models like the frontier models of ChatGPT-5, Gemini 3 and Claude Opus 4.5, LLM-based models already have the capacity to match or even exceed human performance. As these systems become more integrated into our daily lives, two key questions arise: • How can online resources provide their services to actual humans rather than allow bots to consume all of their resources? • How can content sharing platforms ensure that the material procured is authored by humans rather than generated by AI? The first question aims to lower operational costs and protect copyright materials. With AI agents gaining the ability to perform web-scraping completely without human intervention, original content can be copied and republished without the permission of the creators. By ensuring that only human users can access these websites, the service owners can deter plagiarism attempts ( 11 ) . Additionally, cybersecurity concerns necessitate the ability to distinguish between humans and agentic AI, since brute-force attacks and distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) can be enacted through the use of bots ( 20 ) . The second question strives to prevent misinformation, spam, and coordinated automated attacks. For example, on social media platforms, bot accounts are often the main reason behind the spread of misinformation and manipulative content, contributing to polarising our fragile media landscape today ( 10 ) . In the past, both of these concerns could be (at least partially) addressed through the use of CAPTCHAs. However, as prior works by Wang et. al. ( 21 ) and our experiments in Section 2.2 have shown, the capabilities of recent large language models are more than enough to beat existing CAPTCHAs. This gives rise to three possible solutions: (1) Requiring user accounts and tracking users ; (2) Requiring payment for accessing content ; (3) Create new CAPTCHAs that humans can solve with ease, while state of the art agents have trouble solving economically . The first option is not sustainable, since the additional step of registration and verification ruins the experience for the usage of online services, especially menial ones like browsing content. Additionally, with a little more effort, bots and agents can create fake accounts at scale and bypass these defences. The second option is also fraught with challenges, as seemingly trivial services become inaccessible for those without disposable income or online payment services. The final option is the subject of interest in this work. We want to investigate the possibility of novel CAPTCHAs which are simple for humans, but computationally difficult or financially unsustainable for bots and agents to solve. 1.1. Problem Designing a reliable and robust method to differentiate whether an agent is human or robot has been fraught with difficulty. For instance, the advanced multimodal large language models (LLMs) that have permeated the digital sphere have become comparable to regular people in solving automated Turing tests. Some tasks which are potentially challenging for AI are also unsuitable in generalising to all groups of people, especially the young, elderly, and disabled. Moreover, it is necessary for these tasks to be easily and automatically generated in large quantities at low cost, ensuring cost effectiveness and diversity. If only a small set of challenges is available, they can be memorised or defeated through training, rendering the system ineffective over time. Thus, there is a vital need for a novel automated Turing test system that ameliorates these problems ( 9 ) . 1.2. CAPTCHAs and Alternatives CAPTCHAs—Completely Automated Public Turing Test to tell Computers and Humans Apart—have been the norm for separating legitimate users from bots for the past two decades, serving as a lightweight, scalable defence mechanism across numerous applications and websites. Generally, CAPTCHAs are part of a layered network defence system. Typically, CAPTCHAs are enacted as a secondary mechanism after a behavioural detection flags a user agent as suspicious. There have been many proposed ideas which stray away from traditional CAPTCHAs, but they all have various trade-offs. One approach is verifying user authenticity based on account behaviour over time, such as tracking and identifying suspicious patterns and requests which are physically impossible ( 13 ) . However, this method requires a sufficient time period and is ineffective against one-time attacks. It also does not work for services where users do not have long-term accounts. Another approach involves the use of Privacy Pass, which authenticates users through anonymous cryptographic tokens. These tokens verify human behaviour without revealing identity or enabling tracking across websites ( 4 ) . Despite this, these passes can be shared with AI agents, which undermines their effectiveness. To counter this, some may think to make the passes non-anonymous, but this comes with the added risk of cross-site activity tracking which threatens user privacy. Balancing privacy, accountability and the ability to deter or even ban malicious actors remains an unsolved challenge in this space. 1.3. Prior Works The baseline for differentiating humans and AI—the CAPTCHA system by L. von Ahn et al. ( 18 ) —have been used to deter online bots. However, with the rapid advancement of developments into LLMs and Agentic AI, the capabilities of LLMs have surpassed the assumptions that the original CAPTCHA designers had of computers, and have thus rendered these CAPTCHAs obsolete. In order to challenge the capabilities of these advanced multimodal LLMs, there have been numerous proposals for automated Turing tests with unique qualities and interesting results. As mentioned by Wang et al. ( 21 ) , there have been many innovations made towards cracking text-based captchas, which include segmentation, one-stage CAPTCHA recognition models, and transfer learning on pretrained models. ( 22 ) These three methods have not only yielded impressive results, it has also become relatively simple to generate training data to improve model performance through fine tuning ( 12 ) . In

Read the complete text