Artificial Intelligence and Systemic Risk: A Unified Model of Performative Prediction, Algorithmic Herding, and Cognitive Dependency in Financial Markets
Shuchen Meng, Xupeng Chen · 2026
Read Artificial Intelligence and Systemic Risk: A Unified Model of Performative Prediction, Algorithmic Herding, and Cognitive Dependency in Financial Markets by Shuchen Meng, Xupeng Chen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-03272.txt.
Introduction
Meng and Chen model how AI use in financial markets breeds systemic risk through performative prediction, algorithmic herding, and cognitive dependency. As use rises, market depth falls and the risk link turns convex, pushing the system toward an algorithmic monoculture. Tested on 99.5 million SEC holdings from 2013 to 2024, the model implies tail losses amplified 18 to 54 percent.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shuchen Meng, Xupeng Chen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 100802 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.03272
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Artificial Intelligence and Systemic Risk: A Unified Model of Performative Prediction, Algorithmic Herding, and Cognitive Dependency in Financial Markets Shuchen Meng, Xupeng Chen Abstract We develop a unified model in which AI adoption in financial markets generates systemic risk through three mutually reinforcing channels: performative prediction, algorithmic herding, and cognitive dependency. Within an extended rational expectations framework with endogenous adoption, we derive an equilibrium systemic risk coupling r ( ϕ ) = ϕ ρ β / λ ′ ( ϕ ) r(\phi)=\phi\rho\beta/\lambda^{\prime}(\phi) , where ϕ \phi is the AI adoption share, ρ \rho the algorithmic signal correlation, β \beta the performative feedback intensity, and λ ′ ( ϕ ) \lambda^{\prime}(\phi) the endogenous effective price impact. Because λ ′ ( ϕ ) \lambda^{\prime}(\phi) is decreasing in ϕ \phi , the coupling is convex in adoption, implying that the systemic risk multiplier ℳ = ( 1 − r ) − 1 \mathcal{M}=(1-r)^{-1} grows superlinearly as AI penetration increases. The model is developed in three layers. First, endogenous fragility: market depth is decreasing and convex in AI adoption. Second, embedding the convex coupling within a supermodular adoption game produces a saddle-node bifurcation into an algorithmic monoculture. Third, cognitive dependency as an endogenous state variable yields an impossibility theorem (hysteresis requires dynamics beyond static frameworks) and a channel necessity theorem (each channel is individually necessary). Empirical validation uses the complete universe of SEC Form 13F filings (99.5 million holdings, 10,957 institutional managers, 2013–2024) with a Bartik shift-share instrument (first-stage F = 22.7 F=22.7 ). The model implies tail-loss amplification of 18–54%, economically significant relative to Basel III countercyclical buffers. 1 Introduction This paper studies how AI adoption endogenously erodes market depth and amplifies systemic risk. We build a correlated-signal Kyle economy in which AI-driven traders share a common signal component, market makers price adverse selection endogenously, and AI-generated predictions feed back into the fundamentals they forecast. The central equilibrium object is the systemic risk coupling r(\phi)\;=\;\frac{\phi\,\rho\,\beta}{\lambda^{\prime}(\phi)}, (1) where \phi is the AI adoption share, \rho the algorithmic signal correlation, \beta the performative feedback intensity, and \lambda^{\prime}(\phi) the endogenous effective price impact. Because \lambda^{\prime}(\phi) is decreasing in \phi —more correlated informed trading reduces the market maker’s adverse selection problem—the coupling r is convex in adoption. The systemic risk multiplier \mathcal{M}(\phi)=(1-r(\phi))^{-1} therefore grows superlinearly: tail-event losses under the monoculture are amplified by a factor that accelerates as AI penetration increases. Three questions. We organize the analysis around three questions that a referee would ask of any amplification mechanism. (i) What is the new equilibrium object? The coupling r(\phi) combines standard Kyle adverse selection with performative feedback in an interaction absent from the existing correlated-signal literature ( Foster and Viswanathan 1996 ; Cont 2013 ) . Without performative feedback ( \beta=0 ), the coupling is identically zero and the multiplier is unity—correlated signals alone produce excess volatility but no systemic amplification (Lemma 3.4 ). Without endogenous market depth ( \lambda fixed), r is linear in \phi —the superlinear acceleration disappears (Lemma 3.3 (iii)). Neither channel alone produces the convex coupling; their interaction does. This object is algebraically natural from the Kyle information structure; the contribution is in the qualitative phenomena it enables. (ii) What would the world look like if the mechanism were false? Our model generates a sharp cross-sectional signature that distinguishes it from leverage-cycle and crowded-trade alternatives. If systemic risk amplification operates through correlated signals (our mechanism), within-AI-group return dispersion should be approximately regime-invariant: AI institutions err together in calm and in stress, so the dispersion ratio \Delta_{AI}^{stress/calm}\approx 1 (Corollary 3.8 ). If instead amplification operates through heterogeneous leverage ( Brunnermeier 2009 ) , within-group dispersion should spike during stress as institutions deleverage at different speeds, giving \Delta_{AI}^{stress/calm}>1 . In our 13F sample, \Delta_{AI}^{stress/calm}=1.08 ( p=0.34 , not significantly different from 1), while \Delta_{H}^{stress/calm}=1.41 ( p<0.05 ). This is consistent with our mechanism and inconsistent with the leverage alternative, though the quarterly frequency and limited crisis episodes constrain the power of this test. (iii) What parameters can be estimated from data? The coupling r depends on three estimable parameters. We identify \rho\approx 0.60 from within-AI-group return dispersion, \beta\approx 0.28 from the AR(1) persistence of the price-fundamental gap (a reduced-form estimate; direct causal identification requires exogenous disruption of AI predictions), and \phi\approx 0.70 from 13F convergence trends. Together these yield r\in[0.15,0.35] and \mathcal{M}\in[1.18,1.54] —tail-loss amplification of 18–54%, economically significant relative to the Basel III countercyclical buffer of 0–2.5%. Main results. We establish three theoretical results in a layered structure—each extending the model with one additional element. Layer 1: Endogenous fragility. In the minimal correlated-signal economy with performative feedback, market depth \lambda(\phi) is decreasing and convex in AI adoption. The coupling r(\phi) is therefore strictly convex, and the multiplier \mathcal{M} is increasing, convex, and superlinear in \phi\rho\beta (Lemma 3.3 ). This result uses only the Kyle pricing structure and performative feedback; it does not require career concerns, skill degradation, or multiple equilibria. Layer 2: Adoption game and phase transition. Embedding the convex coupling within a supermodular adoption game with heterogeneous switching costs, we show that the transition from a diversified to a monoculture equilibrium is a saddle-node bifurcation : a gradual increase in career pressure triggers a discontinuous jump in both \phi and \mathcal{M} (Proposition 3.11 ). The jump in the multiplier—not just in adoption—distinguishes this from standard technology-adoption bifurcations, where welfare consequences are typically smooth. Layer 3: Dynamic state accumulation and irreversibility. Introducing cognitive dependency—an endogenous state variable \sigma_{H}(t) that degrades human signal precision during the monoculture phase—we prove two results. The impossibility theorem (Theorem 3.15 ) shows that hysteresis does not arise within the class of static correlated-signal frameworks satisfying standard assumptions (S1)–(S4), encompassing, to our knowledge, the existing literature. The channel necessity theorem (Theorem 3.12 ) proves that each channel is necessary for a qualitatively distinct equilibrium feature: signal correlation for the trap’s existence, performative feedback for its danger ( \mathcal{M}>1 ), and cognitive dependency for its irreversibility ( c^{**}<c^{*} ). Motivation. The empirical relevance is immediate. Approximately 91% of hedge funds report using or planning to use AI tools ( Alternative Investment Management Association 2025 ) ; algorithmic systems account for an estimated 60–80% of equity trading volume ( Hendershott et al. 2011 ; Brogaard et al. 2014 ) . The Bank of England, the ECB, the FSB, and the IMF have each identified AI-driven convergence as an emerging systemic concern ( Bank of England 2019 ; European Central Bank 2024 ; Financial Stability Board 2024 ; International Monetary Fund 2024 ) . Episodes such as the August 2024 Nikkei collapse—a 12.4% single-day decline triggered by a modest rate change—and the near-instantaneous 67% Lyft after-hours surge from a typographical error illustrate how correlated algorithmic response can transform small shocks into large price dislocations ( Brogaard et al. 2014 ; Kirilenko et al. 2017 ) . Figure 1 : Conceptual framework: Three mutually reinforcing risk channels. The systemic risk multiplier \mathcal{M}=(1-\phi\rho\beta/\lambda^{\prime})^{-1} is superlinear in the product of channel intensities. The bottom panel illustrates the diversified equilibrium (left) and monoculture equilibrium (right), with hysteresis barriers creating path-dependent transitions. We do not argue that AI necessarily increases systemic risk in all configurations—under low homogeneity, weak feedback, or moderate adoption, AI