UNIONS-3500 Weak Lensing: II. B B -mode validation for cosmic shear

C. Daley, A. Guinot, S. Guerrini, F. Hervas-Peters, L. W. K. Goh, C. Murray, M. Kilbinger, A. Wittje, H. Hildebrandt, M. J. Hudson, L. van Waerbeke, A. W. McConnachie · 2026

Read UNIONS-3500 Weak Lensing: II. B B -mode validation for cosmic shear by C. Daley, A. Guinot, S. Guerrini, F. Hervas-Peters, L. W. K. Goh, C. Murray, M. Kilbinger, A. Wittje, H. Hildebrandt, M. J. Hudson, L. van Waerbeke, A. W. McConnachie (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-03227.txt.

Introduction

Daley and colleagues validate cosmic shear B-modes for the UNIONS-3500 survey, which covers 2,894 square degrees, as a check for systematic contamination. They apply three separable statistics across grids of scale cuts, tracing early catalog flaws to galaxy size cuts and stellar halo masking. Following those cuts, all three statistics pass null tests, though the strictest validation demands cuts that pass across all frameworks at once.

Catalog record

CREATORC. Daley, A. Guinot, S. Guerrini, F. Hervas-Peters, L. W. K. Goh, C. Murray, M. Kilbinger, A. Wittje, H. Hildebrandt, M. J. Hudson, L. van Waerbeke, A. W. McConnachie
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52076
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.03227

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

UNIONS-3500 Weak Lensing: II. B B -mode validation for cosmic shear C. Daley, A. Guinot, S. Guerrini, F. Hervas-Peters, L. W. K. Goh, C. Murray, M. Kilbinger, A. Wittje, H. Hildebrandt, M. J. Hudson, L. van Waerbeke, A. W. McConnachie Abstract At Stage-III sensitivities, cosmic shear B B modes unambiguously indicate systematic contamination and are often used to inform data selection and scale cuts for cosmological inference. We validate B B modes for the Ultraviolet Near-Infrared Optical Northern Survey (UNIONS)-3500 ( 2894 2 2894\text{\,}{\mathrm{}}^{2} , n eff ≈ 5.0 arcmin − 2 n_{\mathrm{eff}}\approx$5.0\text{\,}\mathrm{a}\mathrm{r}\mathrm{c}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{i}\mathrm{n}^{-2}$ ) using three E E / B B -separable statistics: pure-mode correlation functions ξ ± B ​ ( θ ) \xi_{\pm}^{\mathrm{B}}(\theta) , Complete Orthogonal Sets of E E / B B -mode Integrals (COSEBI) B B -mode amplitudes B n B_{n} , and harmonic-space power spectra C ℓ B ​ B C_{\ell}^{BB} . For each statistic, we compute probability-to-exceed (PTE) values over a two-dimensional grid of scale-cut boundaries; our adopted cuts lie in broad stable regions of acceptable PTE. B B -mode detections and PTE failures on initial catalog versions led us to investigate galaxy size cuts and stellar halo masking. After cuts, all three statistics pass the null test (minimum PTE = 0.18 =$0.18$ ). Before scale cuts, we measure an oscillatory COSEBI B B -mode pattern consistent with repeating additive shear bias, a detector-level effect seen across multiple Stage-III surveys including CFHTLenS, which used the same MegaCam camera; scale cuts that exclude the charge-coupled device (CCD) angular scale suppress it. Although these statistics probe the same two-point shear field, scale cuts in one do not map exactly onto cuts in another, because their respective filter functions weight angular scales differently. The most conservative validation therefore requires scale and sample selections that pass null tests across all frameworks simultaneously, an approach that applies directly to Stage-IV surveys where systematic errors dominate. † † idline: UNIONS-3500 WL Paper II, 1 Introduction Weak gravitational lensing distorts the observed shapes of distant galaxies, encoding information about the intervening matter distribution along the line of sight ( 8 ; 36 ; 32 ) . First detections came in 2000 ( 6 ; 31 ; 48 ; 49 ) . The scalar gravitational potential produces a shear field that is curl-free to leading order and can be decomposed into gradient-like E modes and curl-like B modes; under the Born approximation, scalar density perturbations source only E -mode power ( 46 ; 33 ) . Higher-order effects (lens-lens coupling, source clustering, and intrinsic alignments) can produce B modes ( 25 ; 41 ; 10 ) , but these are orders of magnitude below current sensitivity ( 9 ) . They are likely only accessible to future ultra-high-precision measurements, potentially through cross-correlation techniques involving CMB lensing rotation reconstructions and large-scale-structure tracers ( 39 ) . For galaxy shear measurements at current sensitivity, detected B -mode power indicates residual observational systematic effects rather than cosmological signal, though the absence of B modes does not rule out systematic contamination. Stage-III cosmic shear surveys have measured the structure growth parameter S_{8}\equiv\sigma_{8}\sqrt{\Omega_{\mathrm{m}}/0.3} at percent-level precision, with some reporting up to {\sim}3\,\sigma tension with Planck ( 5 ; 1 ; 35 ; 37 ) . The Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS)-Legacy ( 51 ) found S_{8}=0.815^{+0.016}_{-0.021} ( 0.73 \sigma from Planck ) and the Dark Energy Survey (DES) Y6 ( 12 ) found S_{8}=0.798^{+0.014}_{-0.015} ( 1.1\,\sigma ); both achieved 2\% precision on S_{8} , comparable to CMB constraints from Planck alone. Stage-IV surveys will reduce statistical uncertainties further, shifting the error budget toward systematic effects; current data offer the opportunity to validate these methods before that transition. Several methods separate E - and B -mode contributions in shear two-point statistics. Aperture mass dispersion ( 44 ; 43 ) is the foundational real-space method for E / B separation. In practice, however, its evaluation requires knowledge of the shear correlation functions down to zero separation, which is unavailable on a finite observed interval and leads to E / B mixing ( 40 ; 42 ) . Complete Orthogonal Sets of E / B -mode Integrals (COSEBIs; 40 ; 3 ) generalize this approach, compressing all E / B -separable information from \xi_{\pm}(\theta) on a finite angular interval into discrete orthogonal modes. A small number of modes captures the cosmological signal; by construction, the COSEBI basis excludes the ambiguous modes that cannot be assigned pure E or B character on a finite interval. Pure-mode correlation functions \xi_{\pm}^{\mathrm{E/B}}(\theta) ( 42 ) are an alternative real-space representation that decomposes \xi_{\pm} into E -mode, B -mode, and ambiguous components through integral transforms derived from the COSEBI basis functions. Harmonic-space estimators measure C_{\ell}^{EE} and C_{\ell}^{BB} directly but require careful treatment of mask-induced E / B mixing; catalog-based methods that evaluate spherical harmonic transforms at source positions ( 50 ) avoid the pixelization artifacts that complicate standard implementations. The HybridEB Fourier band-power estimator ( 7 ) constructs \ell -space band-powers from linear combinations of binned \xi_{\pm} , projecting out ambiguous modes to minimize E / B mixing. DES Y6 adopted this estimator ( 12 ) , although COSEBIs are more widely used in the Stage-III literature, where they have traced systematic signatures across multiple surveys ( 4 ) . These statistics represent B -mode power in complementary bases, and the mapping between them is not one-to-one, so contamination excluded by scale cuts in one basis may remain visible in another. Comparing across bases can expose systematics that any single framework would absorb. Stage-III analyses have found B -mode contamination from a range of systematic effects. COSEBI analyses of the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope Lensing Survey (CFHTLenS), KiDS-450, and DES-SV detected significant B modes at 2–5 \sigma , linked to repeating additive shear bias, PSF leakage, and photometric selection effects ( 4 ) . Repeating additive shear biases can arise from detector-level defects that imprint a constant ellipticity offset on each CCD, varying across the focal plane; because this pattern is fixed in instrument coordinates, it repeats with every pointing. The bias is constant within each CCD but jumps at chip boundaries; these discontinuities carry curl, generating B -mode power at CCD angular scales. Hyper Suprime-Cam (HSC) Y3 used harmonic-space power spectra and found significant large-scale B modes ( 35 ; 11 ) . A dedicated PSF-systematics study identified PSF fourth-moment leakage as a leading additive contaminant in the affected region ( 52 ) . KiDS-Legacy tested with COSEBIs, traced an initial failure to astrometric systematics, and applied conservative masking with negligible impact on S_{8} ( 51 ) . DES Y3 reported null detections using pseudo- C_{\ell} and COSEBIs ( 1 ) . However, 30 applied the HybridEB estimator uniformly to DES-Y3 and HSC-Y3 data and found B -mode failures in specific tomographic bins not seen with the estimators originally used. DES Y6 subsequently adopted the HybridEB estimator and passed ( 12 ) . Because each estimator weights angular scales differently and deprojects ambiguous modes differently, the same data can pass one null test and fail another. The most informative validation requires consistent passage across multiple statistics. The Ultraviolet Near-Infrared Optical Northern Survey (UNIONS; 20 ) is surveying 6250\text{\,}{\mathrm{}}^{2} of northern sky with multi-band imaging from telescopes in Hawai’i: the

Read the complete text