CO and N 2 Produced from H 2 O, CO 2 , and NH 3 Cometary Ice Analogs

Alexandra McKinnon, Alexia Simon, Michelle R. Brann, Elettra L. Piacentino, Karin I. Öberg, Mahesh Rajappan · 2026

Read CO and N 2 Produced from H 2 O, CO 2 , and NH 3 Cometary Ice Analogs by Alexandra McKinnon, Alexia Simon, Michelle R. Brann, Elettra L. Piacentino, Karin I. Öberg, Mahesh Rajappan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-03207.txt.

Introduction

McKinnon and colleagues test whether comet hypervolatiles form when light splits other ices, rather than by trapping at formation. They shine ultraviolet light and fire electrons at ice analogs made from carbon dioxide, ammonia, and water mixes, and find carbon monoxide and nitrogen in every treated ice. Almost all observed cometary nitrogen fits this light-driven route, while most carbon monoxide still points to low-temperature trapping.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexandra McKinnon, Alexia Simon, Michelle R. Brann, Elettra L. Piacentino, Karin I. Öberg, Mahesh Rajappan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE64429
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.03207

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

CO and N 2 Produced from H 2 O, CO 2 , and NH 3 Cometary Ice Analogs Alexandra McKinnon, Alexia Simon, Michelle R. Brann, Elettra L. Piacentino, Karin I. Öberg, Mahesh Rajappan Abstract Hypervolatile species such as carbon monoxide (CO) and molecular nitrogen (N 2 ) have been detected in comets, and could be used to constrain comet formation temperature conditions if their presence is due to freeze-out and/or entrapment. Here we instead explore another plausible origin of cometary hypervolatiles: photodissociation of less volatile species. We characterize CO and N 2 formation following ultraviolet (UV) irradiation and electron bombardment of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ), ammonia (NH 3 ), H 2 O:CO 2 , H 2 O:NH 3 , and H 2 O:CO 2 :NH 3 cometary ice analogs. We find that CO and N 2 form in all photoprocessed ices at temperatures between 10 K and 100 K, resulting in 0.4-0.9 % \% CO and 0.03-0.7 % \% N 2 relative to water, and CO/CO 2 and N 2 /NH 3 mixing ratios of 2.5-62 % \% and 0.7-9 % \% , respectively, across the experiments. Because our initial ices are reasonably well-matched to interstellar ices and we use UV exposure similar to a dark cloud, we can compare the resulting ratios directly to cometary abundances. Such a comparison shows that while only a few of CO observations in comets are readily explained by photodissociation, almost all observed cometary N 2 can be accounted for by photodissociation of NH 3 embedded in water ice. The latter result is also consistent with observed similarly elevated isotopic ratios of N 2 and NH 3 in 67P. Taken together, our results suggest that N 2 /H 2 O ratios < < 1 % should be used cautiously when inferring a comet’s formation location, while the more substantial CO abundances seen in many comets do likely imply entrapment at low ice temperatures. I Introduction The distribution of volatiles in planet-forming disks ultimately determines the compositions of planets. Our own planet-forming disk is largely gone today, but the composition of the outer disk can still be inferred from comet abundances, since most models and observations suggest that comets largely preserve the chemical compositions present at their formation ( 62 ; 93 ; 3 ) . A combination of remote observations and missions have determined that comets often contain hypervolatiles like carbon monoxide (CO) and molecular nitrogen (N 2 ) ( 42 ; 24 ; 47 ; 76 ; 78 ; 59 ) . Hypervolatiles only freeze out from the gas-phase at low temperatures (see below), and their presence therefore indicates that the comet building blocks (icy dust grains) assembled at correspondingly low temperatures, entrapping the hypervolatiles in the icy grain mantles ( 76 ) . Entrapment is the phenomenon in which volatile molecules are trapped in less volatile molecules, such as amorphous water. When entrapped, highly volatile molecules are prevented from desorbing off of the ice films ( 26 ) . The entrapment of hypervolatiles from the gas-phase has been found to be very efficient at low temperatures, ( 6 ; 7 ; 64 ; 26 ; 86 ; 38 ; 44 ) but drops off rapidly above 30 K ( 8 ; 96 ) . Entrapment of hypervolatiles formed in the gas-phase is not the only possible explanation for the presence of hypervolatiles in comets, however. Previous studies have proposed that substantial amounts of cometary O 2 could originate from photodissociation chemistry inside of icy grains, using less volatile ice constituents as precursors ( 19 ) . While the plausibility of this O 2 formation mechanism is under debate ( 61 ; 14 ; 89 ; 3 ) , it suggests that we should consider whether (some) cometary CO and N 2 could be explained by the decomposition of less volatile species in the icy grain precursors to comets, relaxing constraints on the formation conditions of CO and N 2 -containing comet material. Such photolysis would have to take place in small enough grains that their icy mantles are transparent to UV, \sim\mu m-sized grains, and hence be limited to the earliest stages of planetesimal formation in protoplanetary disks. We further note that for the produced CO and N 2 to remain in the ice during subsequent collisional growth and pebble drift into warmer disk regions will require a kind of entrapment; the complete question is then whether (1) sufficient hypervolatiles can plausibly form through photolysis, and (2) whether hypervolatiles formed from irradiation can become ‘entrapped’ into icy grain mantles at higher temperatures, compared to the entrapment of hypervolatiles from the gas-phase. With the exception of CO-dominated comets such as C/2016 R2 and 2I/Borisov ( ( 59 ) and references therein), the CO abundances in comets with respect to water range between < 1 \% and 32 \% ( 47 ; 76 ) . The most well-studied comet, Comet 67P, falls towards the lower portion of the CO abundance range, having an abundance of 3 \% with respect to water ( 46 ) . Before the Rosetta mission to Comet 67P, N 2 abundances with respect to water had only been reported a handful of times in comets, based on N 2 + optical measurements ( 23 ; 25 ; 24 ) , and ranged between < 0.0016 \% and 0.7 \% with respect to water ( 42 ; 4 ) . Comet 67P has an N 2 bulk abundance of 0.089 \pm 0.024 \% ( 78 ) , consistent with N 2 + measurements towards other comets. As for many other comets, the substantial abundances of CO and N 2 in the coma of 67P have been used to infer a cold origin of the 67P building blocks, assuming that the CO and N 2 were entrapped in water ice ( 76 ) . However, as mentioned above, hypervolatile comet constituents may also be produced through energetic processes in interstellar and/or disk ice grains ( 22 ) . Icy grains are first formed in the interstellar medium, before the onset of star formation. These grains are observed to be rich in CO 2 and NH 3 , which may act as precursors of CO and N 2 . Based on observations with Spitzer and JWST of ice compositions in clouds, and protostellar envelopes, and disks, ( 16 ; 58 ) CO 2 and NH 3 are present at abundances relative to water of 12%-50% and 3%-10%, respectively. The average low-mass protostellar H 2 O:CO 2 :NH 3 mixing ratio is 100:28:6 ( 16 ) , with all NH 3 and \sim 2/3 of the CO 2 likely residing together with water ( 71 ) . Both CO 2 and NH 3 have also recently been detected in a protoplanetary disk, albeit at somewhat lower abundances of 15% for CO 2 and 1.7% for NH 3 , respectively ( 58 ; 88 ) . When embedded in water ice, these mid-volatility species are likely to survive disk formation when only considering thermal effects ( 92 ; 33 ) . CO 2 and NH 3 are also detected in comets, but at lower abundances than would be expected from unperturbed inheritance; in comet

Read the complete text