Neumann’s nodal line may be closed on doubly-connected planar domains
Pedro Freitas, Roméo Leylekian · 2026
Read Neumann’s nodal line may be closed on doubly-connected planar domains by Pedro Freitas, Roméo Leylekian (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-03169.txt.
Introduction
Freitas and Leylekian prove that a planar region with one hole can host a first non-trivial Neumann eigenfunction whose nodal line closes fully inside the region. That is the best possible outcome, since a 1956 result bars closed nodal lines on simply connected regions. Part of the argument tracks eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of graph-like regions converging toward metric graphs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pedro Freitas, Roméo Leylekian |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88042 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.03169
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Neumann’s nodal line may be closed on doubly-connected planar domains Pedro Freitas, Roméo Leylekian Abstract . We show the existence of planar domains with one hole for which the first non-trivial Neumann eigenfunction has a closed nodal line fully contained inside the domain. This is optimal, as it is known since Pleijel’s 1956 result that the nodal line cannot be closed on simply-connected planar domains. A part of the proof is based on the study of convergence of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of graph-like domains towards metric graphs. We improve the known results of convergence of eigenfunctions, by showing a strong transversal convergence. 1. Introduction Consider the Neumann eigenvalue problem \left\{\begin{array}[]{lll}\Delta u+\mu u=0&\text{in }V,\\ \partial_{n}u=0&\text{on }\partial V,\end{array}\right. where V is a bounded connected regular (say Lipschitz) planar domain and \partial_{n} denotes the normal derivative. Under these conditions, it follows that the spectrum consists of a sequence of eigenvalues 0=\mu_{1}<\mu_{2}\leq\mu_{3}\dots\to+\infty with the corresponding eigenfunctions forming a complete orthonormal system of L^{2}(V) . By connectedness, Courant’s nodal domain theorem applies and stipulates that any n -th eigenfunction has at most n nodal domains. We recall that, for a given function, the nodal domains are the connected components of the set where the function does not vanish, while the nodal line is the closure of its zero set. In particular, Courant’s result and the orthogonality of the eigenfunctions imply that the nodal line of a second eigenfunction splits V in exactly two nodal domains. In a 1956 paper on Courant’s theorem [ 35 ] , Åke Pleijel stated that the nodal line of any second Neumann eigenfunction had to “consist of a transverse cutting V into two simply connected regions.” His argument also used the fact, which had been proven by Pólya four years earlier, that the first non-trivial Neumann eigenvalue is strictly smaller than the first Dirichlet eigenvalue of the same domain. Pleijel then argued that if the Neumann eigenfunction encircled a subdomain N_{2} of V without touching the boundary \partial V , the Neumann and Dirichlet eigenvalues of V and N_{2} , respectively, would be equal. Using the fact that Dirichlet eigenvalues are monotone by inclusion, this would then lead to a contradiction. Although not mentioned explicitly in either the argument or the conditions on V , it is assumed implicitly in Pleijel’s reasoning that the original domain V is itself simply-connected. Otherwise, if the nodal domain N_{2} encircles one of the holes in V , then it is no longer possible to reach a contradiction from Pólya’s comparison result due to the presence of Neumann boundary conditions on parts of \partial N_{2} . More precisely, the comparison result between the first Dirichlet and the first non-trivial Neumann eigenvalues used in the last step in Pleijel’s argument now becomes a comparison between the first Neumann-Dirichlet and the first non-trivial Neumann eigenvalues, and it does no longer necessarilly hold that the former is larger than or equal to the latter. We note, however, that this argument ensures that any closed nodal line of a second Neumann eigenfunction must encircle a portion of the boundary of the domain. Probably as a result of this absence of explicitly stated conditions on V for the argument in [ 35 ] to hold, the question of whether the Neumann nodal line can be closed has either been ignored in the literature or it has even been stated that in the Neumann case the nodal line associated with a second eigenfunction cannot be closed. An example of the latter may already be found in [ 33 , p. 466] , where Payne states that in [ 35 ] Pleijel used the inequality between Dirichlet and Neumann eigenvalues mentioned above, together with the “monotone behaviour of \lambda_{1} ” to point out that the first non-trivial Neumann eigenfunction “can have no closed nodal line.” It is also given as an exercise in [ 4 , Problem 3, p. 128] . Note further that this imprecision has percolated in other contexts, e.g. the Steklov problem [ 28 ] , for which the issue was corrected only recently [ 11 ] . Thus most of the work on the Neumann nodal line has focused on its localisation [ 3 , 23 ] , with exceptions being [ 18 ] , where it was shown that closed nodal lines in both the Dirichlet and Neumann case do exist on 2- manifolds, even in the simply-connected case, and [ 26 ] where a problem related to certain symmetries of Neumann eigenfunctions was considered. All of this is in sharp contrast with what happened for the Dirichlet problem, for which not only is the result far from being straightforward even in the simply-connected case where it remains open but, following a conjecture formulated by Payne in 1967 [ 33 , Conjecture 5] stating that the second Dirichlet eigenfunction “cannot have a closed nodal line for any domain”, there appeared a string of partial results [ 34 , 29 , 38 , 30 , 10 , 16 , 27 , 32 ] and counterexamples [ 21 , 14 , 15 , 25 , 9 ] . Recently, we have shown that in the Dirichlet case, the number of holes necessary to have a closed nodal line may be brought down to one, that is, there are doubly-connected domains such that the nodal line encircles the hole while not touching the boundary of the domain [ 17 ] . The intuitive idea behind this construction is based on the fact that having a hole implies the boundary is formed by two disjoint components, say \Gamma_{1} and \Gamma_{2} . Because of this, it is then possible to find a one-parameter family of such domains for which there is a transition between nodal lines that touch only \Gamma_{1} to those that touch only \Gamma_{2} . By continuity, and provided certain conditions are satisfied (such as simplicity of the second eigenvalue and symmetry of the eigenfunction), it is to be expected that there will exist a value of the parameter in this transition for which the nodal line does not touch either \Gamma_{1} or \Gamma_{2} – see below for a more complete description, and [ 17 ] for the result and details. Although the Neumann problem turns out to be more complicated, it is possible to start from the same idea to show that there will also exist domains in this case for which the nodal line can be closed. Theorem 1.1 . There exists a doubly-connected bounded open subset of \mathbb{R}^{2} with a second Neumann eigenfunction whose nodal line is closed and does not touch the boundary. Figure 1 . Schematic representation of a domain with a second Neumann eigenfunction whose nodal line (in blue) is expected to remain closed. A schematic representation of a domain for which this phenomenon occurs is shown in Figure 1 . Note that by stability of Neumann eigenfunctions with respect to the excision of small balls [ 13 ] we also conclude that there exist planar domains with an arbitrary number of holes for which the Neumann nodal line is closed. Corollary 1.2 . For any integer N\geq 2 , there exists a bounded connected open subset of \mathbb{R}^{2} whose boundary is made