A Classification of Order Convergence via a Transfinite Fatou Hierarchy
A. Avilés, C. Rosendal, M. A. Taylor, P. Tradacete · 2026
Read A Classification of Order Convergence via a Transfinite Fatou Hierarchy by A. Avilés, C. Rosendal, M. A. Taylor, P. Tradacete (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-02588.txt.
Introduction
Avilés and three colleagues sort out order convergence in separable Banach lattices. They build a transfinite hierarchy of weakenings of the Fatou property over countable ordinals, showing it gives a full classification. A key sequence set being Borel, sigma-order convergence being analytic, and the lattice meeting some level of the hierarchy all turn out to mean the same thing. The hierarchy has no top rung, so complexity can climb as high as one likes below the first uncountable ordinal.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. Avilés, C. Rosendal, M. A. Taylor, P. Tradacete |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37359 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.02588
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Classification of Order Convergence via a Transfinite Fatou Hierarchy Thanks: C. Rosendal was partially supported by the U.S. National Science Foundation under Award Numbers DMS-2246986 and DMS-2204849. A. Avilés was supported by MICIU/AEI /10.13039/501100011033/ and ERDF-A way of making Europe (project PID2021-122126NB-C32). A. Avilés and P. Tradacete were supported by Fundación Séneca - ACyT Región de Murcia. P. Tradacete was partially supported by grants PID2020-116398GB-I00, PID2024-162214NB-I00 and CEX2023-001347-S funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, as well as by a 2022 Leonardo Grant for Researchers and Cultural Creators, BBVA Foundation. A. Avilés, C. Rosendal, M. A. Taylor, P. Tradacete Abstract . We investigate the descriptive complexity of order convergence in separable Banach lattices. While uniform convergence is Borel and σ \sigma -order convergence is known to be 𝚫 2 1 {\bf\Delta}^{1}_{2} , it is unclear in general when σ \sigma -order convergence is analytic. We introduce a transfinite hierarchy of weakenings of the classical Fatou property, indexed by countable ordinals, and show that it provides a complete structural classification of this definability problem. For a separable Banach lattice X X , we prove that the following are equivalent: (i) the set of decreasing positive sequences with infimum zero is Borel; (ii) σ \sigma -order convergence is analytic; and (iii) X X satisfies the α \alpha -Fatou property for some countable ordinal α \alpha . We further establish that the hierarchy is proper: for every countable ordinal α \alpha there exists a separable Banach lattice with a countable π \pi -basis that fails to be α \alpha -Fatou, but is β \beta -Fatou for some β > α \beta>\alpha . Thus the Borel definability of order convergence is governed by a canonical ordinal invariant intrinsic to the lattice, and the descriptive complexity can be arbitrarily high below ω 1 \omega_{1} . These results identify projective complexity as a genuine structural invariant in Banach lattice theory. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 46B42, 46B15, Secondary: 03E15, 46H40, 54A20 1. Introduction The present paper develops a descriptive set theoretic classification of order convergence in separable Banach lattices. Our goal is to measure, in a precise and intrinsic way, the definability complexity of the most natural order-theoretic convergence relations and to identify the structural lattice properties governing this complexity. A Banach lattice is a Banach space X equipped with a lattice ordering \leqslant that is compatible with both the linear and norm structure on X . Specifically, for all x,y,z\in X and \lambda>0 , x\leqslant y\;\Rightarrow\;\lambda x+z\leqslant\lambda y+z\qquad\&\qquad|x|\leqslant|y|\;\Rightarrow\;\lVert x\rVert\leqslant\lVert y\rVert, where |x|=x\vee-x . These axioms imply that the order relation \leqslant is norm closed in X^{2} . However, many other natural order-theoretic constructions exhibit dramatically higher descriptive complexity. For example, the sets X^{\uparrow\infty}=\big\{\,{(x_{n})\in X^{\mathbb{N}}}\;\big|\;{0\leqslant x_{1}\leqslant x_{2}\leqslant\ldots\text{ and $(x_{n})$ is order-unbounded in }X}\,\big\} and X_{\downarrow 0}=\big\{\,{(x_{n})\in X^{\mathbb{N}}}\;\big|\;{x_{1}\geqslant x_{2}\geqslant\ldots\geqslant 0=\inf_{n}x_{n}}\,\big\} can easily be seen to be coanalytic, i.e., {\bf\Pi}^{1}_{1} , but do not appear to be Borel in X^{\mathbb{N}} . This observation raises a fundamental structural question: How complicated, in the projective hierarchy, are the natural order convergence relations in a separable Banach lattice? Our interest in this question stems in part from the study of coordinate systems and bases in Banach lattices [ 1 , 8 , 4 ] , where definability properties of order convergence play a decisive role. Every Banach lattice supports several distinct notions of sequential convergence. • A sequence (x_{n})_{n=1}^{\infty} converges uniformly to x , denoted x_{n}\mathop{\overset{\sf u}{\longrightarrow}}x , if there is some z\in X so that \forall m\;\forall^{\infty}n\;|x_{n}-x|\leqslant\tfrac{z}{m}, • a sequence (x_{n})_{n=1}^{\infty} \sigma -order converges to x , denoted x_{n}\mathop{\overset{\sf\sigma\sf o}{\longrightarrow}}x , if there is some sequence z_{m}\downarrow 0 in X so that \forall m\;\forall^{\infty}n\;|x_{n}-x|\leqslant z_{m}, • a sequence (x_{n})_{n=1}^{\infty} order converges to x , denoted x_{n}\mathop{\overset{\sf o}{\longrightarrow}}x , if there is some net z_{\mu}\downarrow 0 in X so that \forall\mu\;\forall^{\infty}n\;|x_{n}-x|\leqslant z_{\mu}. Here the notations z_{m}\downarrow 0 and z_{\mu}\downarrow 0 mean that (z_{m}) is a decreasing sequence, respectively decreasing net, with infimum 0 , while the notation \forall^{\infty}n means for all but finitely many n . Figure 1 lists the relationships holding between these sequential convergence notions and it should be noted that no other implications hold in general Banach lattices. {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\sf uniform}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\sigma-{\text{}\sf order}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\sf norm}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\text{}\sf order}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\sf weak}} Figure 1. Implications between convergence types. Remark 1.1 . It is a classical fact (see [ 9 , Remark 1.3] ) that, if X is a Banach lattice of measurable functions (i.e. an ideal in the space of measurable functions L_{0}(\Omega,\Sigma,\mu) for some semi-finite measure space (\Omega,\Sigma,\mu) ), we have f_{n}\mathop{\underset{n}{\overset{\sf o}{\longrightarrow}}}f if and only if f_{n}\mathop{\underset{n}{\overset{a.e.}{\longrightarrow}}}f and, moreover, there exists a g\in X_{+} satisfying |f_{n}|\leqslant g for all n (i.e., the sequence (f_{n}) is order bounded). Therefore, order convergence can be viewed as a generalization of dominated almost everywhere convergence to vector lattices. On the other hand, if e\in X^{+} , then we may equip the order ideal I_{e}=\big\{\,{x\in X}\;\big|\;{\exists\lambda\in\mathbb{R}\ |x|\leq\lambda e}\,\big\} with the norm \|\cdot\|_{e} where for each x\in I_{e}, \|x\|_{e} is the smallest \lambda=\lambda(x) which makes the definition of I_{e} valid. It is well-known that (I_{e},\|\cdot\|_{e}) is lattice isometric to C(K_{e}) for some compact Hausdorff space K_{e} . Moreover, in C(K_{e}) , f_{n}\mathop{\underset{n}{\overset{\sf u}{\longrightarrow}}}f if and only if f_{n}\mathop{\underset{n}{\overset{\|\cdot\|_{\infty}}{\longrightarrow}}}f , so uniform convergence bonds the local norm convergences in C(K_{e}) to a convergence in all of X . These convergences have numerous applications, and have been studied extensively in recent years [ 2 , 3 , 5 ] . At first glance, the above convergences appear to have high descriptive complexity. For example, \sigma -order convergence is naturally expressible as a {\bf\Sigma}^{1}_{2} , meaning that the corresponding subset of X^{\mathbb{N}}\times X is the continuous image of a {\bf\Pi}^{1}_{1} subset of a Polish space. On the other hand, it is unclear whether the relation x_{n}\mathop{\overset{\sf o}{\longrightarrow}}x is even projective, i.e., {\bf\Sigma}^{1}_{k} for some k . Yet, as shown in [ 1 ] , in separable Banach lattices order and \sigma -order convergence coincide and the resulting relation is {\bf\Delta}^{1}_{2} , that is, both {\bf\Sigma}^{1}_{2} and {\bf\Pi}^{1}_{2} . In contrast, uniform convergence is Borel rather than the prima facie value {\bf\Sigma}^{1}_{1} . The fact that x_{n}\mathop{\overset{\sigma\sf o}{\longrightarrow}}x is {\bf\Delta}^{1}_{2} but not known to be {\bf\Sigma}^{1}_{1} is a cause of some difficulties in [ 1 ] . Namely, to show that every \sigma -order basis (e_{n}) for a Banach lattice X=[e_{n}] is also a Schauder basis, additional set theoretical assumptions are needed. However, this need vanishes once the relation x_{n}\mathop{\overset{\sigma\sf o}{\longrightarrow}}x can be shown to be {\bf\Sigma}^{1}_{1} . We will here define a transfinite hierarchy of successive weakenings of the Fatou property for Banach lattices, that is, the property that whenever we have elements 0\leqslant x_{1}\leqslant x_{2}\leqslant\ldots\leqslant x with x=\sup_{n}x_{n} , then \lVert x\rVert=\sup_{n}\lVert x_{n}\rVert . In turn, our first main result shows that this hierarchy exhausts the class of separable Banach lattices in which the set X_{\downarrow 0} is Borel or equivalently the relation x_{n}\mathop{\overset{\sigma\sf o}{\longrightarrow}}x is analytic. Theorem 1.2 . The following are equivalent for a separable Banach lattice X . (1) The set X_{\downarrow 0}=\Big\{(x_{n})_{n=1}^{\infty}\in X^{\mathbb{N}}\;\Big|\;x_{1}\geqslant x_{2}\geqslant\ldots\geqslant 0=\inf_{n}x_{n}\Big\} is Borel, (2) the set \Big\{\big((x_{n})_{n=1}^{\infty},x\big)\in X^{\mathbb{N}}\times X\;\Big|\;x_{n}\mathop{\underset{n}{\overset{\sigma\sf o}{\longrightarrow}}}x\Big\} is analytic, (3) X is \alpha -Fatou for some \alpha<\omega_{1} . The ordinal invariant introduced here plays a role analogous to classical indices