High Volatility and Action Bias Distinguish LLMs from Humans in Group Coordination
Sahaj Singh Maini, Robert L. Goldstone & Zoran Tiganj · 2026
Read High Volatility and Action Bias Distinguish LLMs from Humans in Group Coordination by Sahaj Singh Maini, Robert L. Goldstone & Zoran Tiganj (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-02578.txt.
Introduction
Maini, Goldstone and Tiganj compare language models with people in a group coordination game where players must jointly sum to a hidden target without talking. People adapt and steady their play over time, while models often fail to improve and switch excessively, harming convergence. Richer feedback, such as error size, helps people far more than models, though a training method called GRPO curbs the models' restless switching.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sahaj Singh Maini, Robert L. Goldstone & Zoran Tiganj |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58162 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.02578
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
High Volatility and Action Bias Distinguish LLMs from Humans in Group Coordination Sahaj Singh Maini, Robert L. Goldstone & Zoran Tiganj Abstract Humans exhibit remarkable abilities to coordinate in groups. As large language models (LLMs) become more capable, it remains an open question whether they can demonstrate comparable adaptive coordination and whether they use the same strategies as humans. To investigate this, we compare LLM and human performance on a common-interest game with imperfect monitoring: Group Binary Search. In this n n -player game, participants need to coordinate their actions to achieve a common objective. Players independently submit numerical values in an effort to collectively sum to a randomly assigned target number. Without direct communication, they rely on group feedback to iteratively adjust their submissions until they reach the target number. Our findings show that, unlike humans who adapt and stabilize their behavior over time, LLMs often fail to improve across games and exhibit excessive switching, which impairs group convergence. Moreover, richer feedback (e.g., numerical error magnitude) benefits humans substantially but has small effects on LLMs. Taken together, by grounding the analysis in human baselines and mechanism-level metrics, including reactivity scaling, switching dynamics, and learning across games, we point to differences in human and LLM groups and provide a behaviorally grounded diagnostic for closing the coordination gap. † † footnotetext: https://cogneuroai.github.io/Human-vs-LLM-Group-Coordination 1 Introduction Coordination among agents is critical for effective group behavior in both natural and artificial systems. Humans demonstrate a remarkable capacity for adaptive group coordination, particularly in settings characterized by incomplete information and limited communication ( 7 ) . These capabilities are supported by dynamic strategies such as role differentiation, graded responsiveness to feedback, and self-consistency within groups, mechanisms that collectively enable convergence toward shared goals even without direct communication ( 26 ) . Such adaptive coordination is crucial in numerous real-world scenarios, from team collaborations to organizational decision-making. As large language models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed in multi-agent systems (MAS) to solve complex, collaborative tasks, their capacity to coordinate adaptively is a subject of intense investigation and debate. Recent advances have led to agentic frameworks in which multiple LLM-based agents perceive, learn, reason, and act collaboratively, leveraging collective intelligence to tackle problems beyond the scope of single agents ( 29 ; 9 ) . These MAS are being explored across diverse domains, including software engineering, scientific discovery, and social simulations (e.g., VIRSCI ( 27 ) MetaGPT ( 14 ) , ChatDev ( 22 ) , HyperAgent ( 21 ) , and frameworks like AutoHMA-LLM ( 30 ) ). However, empirical results often show limited gains over single-agent baselines and frequent breakdowns in collaborative performance ( 6 ) . Recent benchmarks and studies using behavioral game theory are beginning to probe the coordination and cooperation abilities of LLMs more directly ( 15 ; 2 ; 11 ; 10 ; 1 ; 28 ) . Findings indicate that LLMs can perform well in certain interactive settings, particularly those aligning with self-interest, like the iterated Prisoner’s Dilemma ( 2 ) . However, they often behave inefficiently in games requiring pure coordination, such as the Battle of the Sexes ( 2 ) , or complex Theory of Mind (ToM) reasoning, like Hanabi ( 4 ; 1 ) . Nonetheless, some studies show LLMs matching or exceeding sophisticated reinforcement learning agents in coordination tasks like Overcooked-AI, which rely more on environmental understanding, and demonstrating robustness when paired with unseen partners (Zero-Shot Coordination) ( 1 ) . The potential for human-AI coordination is also being explored, leveraging the complementary strengths of human flexibility and contextual understanding with AI’s data processing power ( 20 ; 5 ) . To dissect the mechanisms underpinning group coordination in LLMs, we compare human and LLM performance on a common-interest game with imperfect monitoring: Group Binary Search (GBS). In this n -player game, participants must coordinate actions to collectively sum their independent guesses to a hidden target number. Without direct communication, they rely solely on shared group feedback - either directional (too high, too low, or just right) or numerical (e.g., too high by 25), to iteratively refine their choices. While existing research explores structured collaboration and game-theoretic interactions in LLMs, our work studies human and LLM behavior in a pure group coordination setting from a social psychology perspective, where success depends entirely on mutual adjustment and emergent alignment based on incomplete, group-level feedback. These are settings where humans excel at adaptive coordination ( 26 ; 12 ) , readily adjusting strategies, learning from experience, and even developing spontaneous role specializations to manage coordination costs. Recent work on group coordination in an imperfect monitoring setting ( 24 ) found that LLMs struggle with oscillations as group size increases and studied impact of prompt-induced persona differentiation. We focus on establishing direct human baselines to mechanistically diagnose why LLMs often fail to naturally coordinate, isolating specific deficits such as persistent action bias, overreactivity to feedback, and a lack of cross-game adaptation. In contrast to human adaptability, we found systematic limitations in LLM group coordination. Humans significantly benefited from numerical feedback, converging to targets faster than with directional feedback alone; LLM groups, however, showed little to no benefit from richer numerical feedback, performing worse than humans in most cases. Unlike humans who clearly improved across repeated games, LLMs exhibited minimal cross-game learning. These differences persisted across group sizes (2–17 players). Mechanistically, LLMs consistently displayed dramatically higher switching rates than humans, as well as greater overreactivity to feedback, and failed to reduce their adjustments as the group approached the target. Thus even when LLM performance reached human performance, the coordination was fundamentally different. These findings suggest potential obstacles to achieving human-like adaptive coordination in multi-agent AI systems, highlighting the need for architectures capable of integrating feedback history, moderating reactivity, and stabilizing collective behavior. 2 Methods 2.1 Group Binary Search We evaluate LLMs on a common-interest game with imperfect monitoring, GBS. In GBS, each participant makes a guess on each round and the sum of all of the guesses in the group is compared to a hidden mystery number at the end of every round. Participants are not provided the individual guesses of other players, and the mystery number remains fixed within a game. All players receive identical feedback, either directional feedback (too low, too high, or just right) or numerical error-magnitude feedback (too low by k , too high by k , or just right). The common goal of the group is to have the sum of all guesses exactly match the mystery number. The game ends when the group succeeds or reaches the maximum of 15 rounds (see Fig. 1 for a schematic illustrating the game with numerical feedback). In our experiments, we closely follow the experiment structure in ( 26 ) , whose data we use as a human baseline. Each experiment session contains 10 games played sequentially while alternating between directional and numerical feedback. To facilitate comparison with human data, we match the mystery number in each game and the number of players in each session to the human data. Similar to ( 26 ) , the models were evaluated across 18 GBS experiments with varying sizes: six 2-player, three 3-player, three 4-player, one 6-player, one 7-player, one 10-player,