A Comprehensive Framework for Long-Term Resiliency Investment Planning under Extreme Weather Uncertainty for Electric Utilities

Emma Benjaminson · 2026

Read A Comprehensive Framework for Long-Term Resiliency Investment Planning under Extreme Weather Uncertainty for Electric Utilities by Emma Benjaminson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-02504.txt.

Introduction

Benjaminson offers a four-part plan to help power firms pick long-term grid upgrades when extreme weather is hard to predict. It treats storms as a source of doubt, uses a digital twin of the grid, runs Monte Carlo runs to capture spread, and weighs competing goals to pick a mix of projects. Surprisingly, a plain ranking by net present value beat the complex grid-aware methods in her tests.

Catalog record

CREATOREmma Benjaminson
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37674
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.02504

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Comprehensive Framework for Long-Term Resiliency Investment Planning under Extreme Weather Uncertainty for Electric Utilities Emma Benjaminson Abstract Electric utilities must make massive capital investments in the coming years to respond to explosive growth in demand, aging assets and rising threats from extreme weather. Utilities today already have rigorous frameworks for capital planning, and there are opportunities to extend this capability to solve multi-objective optimization problems in the face of uncertainty. This work presents a four-part framework that 1) incorporates extreme weather as a source of uncertainty, 2) leverages a digital twin of the grid, 3) uses Monte Carlo simulation to capture variability and 4) applies a multi-objective optimization method for finding the optimal investment portfolio. We use this framework to investigate whether grid-aware optimization methods outperform model-free approaches. We find that, in fact, given the computational complexity of model-based metaheuristic optimization methods, the simpler net present value ranking method was able to find more optimal portfolios with only limited knowledge of the grid. I Introduction A paradigm shift is currently underway in the design and operation of electric utility grids worldwide. Utility operators must commit to massive investments in growth, modernization and resilience efforts in the next few years in response to a rapidly changing natural and economic environment - in the US alone, utilities are collectively expected to invest over $1 trillion dollars between 2025 and 2029 [ 17 ] . Broadly, there are 3 key factors driving this shift: 1) an exponential increase in demand driven by data centers and the electrification of industry and transportation; 2) aging infrastructure in need of replacement, and 3) shifting extreme weather patterns increasing in frequency and severity, necessitating grid hardening activities to improve grid resilience [ 17 , 18 ] . In the face of these mounting pressures, utilities must respond proactively while still providing electricity safely, reliably, and equitably. With regards to planning long-term investments for improving grid resilience - an essential activity for utilities in this moment - utilities already have a robust, multi-step process, for example as detailed in NREL’s reports on resilience planning [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . These reports identified a central framework for resilience investment planning, beginning with identifying hazards, defining key metrics for evaluating investment plans, then quantifying risks posed by hazards as well as the potential benefits from improvements under consideration, before finally developing an optimal portfolio and schedule of investments. The NREL reports, as well as researchers like Baker [ 1 ] and Parker et al. [ 14 ] , also emphasize that resilience efforts must not cement inequitable systems for the future. Recent approaches for optimizing capital investments for resilience, ranging from prioritization frameworks like TOPSIS [ 13 ] to MILP formulations [ 21 , 20 ] to evolutionary algorithms [ 22 , 19 ] tend to cover a subset of the steps described in the NREL process, but do not yet present a comprehensive end-to-end solution. We also noted that some methods in the literature use a model of the grid, while others are more model-free, primarily focused on the financial or operational benefits of different investments. This presents an interesting question: is there a measurable benefit to leveraging a detailed model of the grid while optimizing capital investments for resilience? In addition to studying the value of a model-aware investment optimization approach, the NREL studies also identified a need for utilities to use advanced methods for multi-objective optimization under uncertainty [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . Guided by this recommendation, we propose a novel framework for end-to-end capital investment optimization for resilience, and use it to investigate the potential benefits of grid-aware optimization as compared to model-free methods. The framework includes: 1. A probabilistic approach for modeling extreme weather 2. A digital twin of the grid, including all generators, power lines and loads, as well as a simulator capable of solving the AC power flow problem at steady state 3. A method for capturing uncertainty in grid performance 4. A multi-objective optimization approach capable of finding an optimal combination of resilience improvements We demonstrate an implementation of this framework, and use it to test our hypothesis that a grid-aware approach for optimizing a portfolio of investments will find synergistic network effects in the grid that cannot be identified using a model-free approach. We test our hypothesis by applying both a model-free net present value ranking method and a grid-aware metaheuristic multi-objective optimization approach to define an optimal portfolio of investments. We use the digital twin of the grid to evaluate both optimized investment plans, and compare them across several key performance metrics to identify the benefits and drawbacks of each method. II Literature Review Prior art has explored a range of optimization approaches to prioritize capital investments, starting with interpretable ranking approaches that score projects across criteria. Nematshahi et al. ranked projects according to probability-weighted wildfire damage costs [ 12 ] and Niu et al. used the Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) method for ranking projects according to a weighted score of operational, social and economic criteria [ 13 ] . Another group of papers used mixed integer linear programming (MILP) approaches. Yang et al. used a MILP formulation to perform multi-objective optimization given constraints regarding project sequencing, complementarity and mutual exclusivity [ 21 ] . Xue et al. also derived a MILP formulation for a problem that was originally defined as a two-stage optimization problem, starting with siting and sizing for grid-level energy storage, and then solving the day-ahead clearing problem for power markets. They collapsed the two-stage problem to one layer by using the KKT conditions and the linearized DistFlow model [ 20 , 16 ] . Several approaches used an evolutionary algorithm, like Yankson et al. who used the Improved Grey Wolf Optimizer to find optimal groupings of resources to form microgrid structures [ 22 ] . Wu et al. introduced a new evolutionary algorithm, super-efficient hyperplane projection transformation (which is based on NSGA-III), to define a Pareto frontier [ 19 ] . Fig. 1: This work compares a model-free and a model-based approach to solving a two-stage capital prioritization problem for electric utilities. Model-free approach: The potential investments are ranked by NPV, which is calculated using a baseline simulation from the digital twin to estimate operational costs and benefits, and then scheduled on a FIFO basis. Model-based approach: The NSGA-II algorithm [ 4 ] finds the Pareto frontier of optimized portfolios over two objectives, using the digital twin as an evaluation function. An ILP method is used to optimize the schedule of implementing the investments. Digital twin of the grid: The digital twin computes power flows over the grid layout given known generation, load and extreme weather events. Multiple simulations can be run to obtain summary statistics and confidence intervals for KPIs across different categories including resilience, growth and affordability. Several papers also accounted for sources of uncertainty, such as weather and load growth, in their solution. Nematshahi et al. used a fire spread simulator to model the spread and intensity of a fire over time under varying conditions. The results were used to compute a weighted average of the damage cost given

Read the complete text