Counting Frobenius extensions over local function fields

Jürgen Klüners, Raphael Müller · 2026

Read Counting Frobenius extensions over local function fields by Jürgen Klüners, Raphael Müller (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-02152.txt.

Introduction

Klüners and Müller count extensions of local function fields by discriminant where the Galois group sits inside the affine group AGL 1(p). More broadly they solve the counting problem for all groups in a tower of a cyclic extension of order p over a cyclic extension of degree d coprime to p. The answers cover certain non abelian groups, including S 3, dihedral groups of order 2p, and many Frobenius groups.

Catalog record

CREATORJürgen Klüners, Raphael Müller
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66373
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.02152

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Counting Frobenius extensions over local function fields Jürgen Klüners, Raphael Müller Abstract . We determine the asymptotic growth of extensions of local function fields of characteristic p p counted by discriminant, where the Galois group is a subgroup of the affine group AGL 1 ⁡ ( p ) \operatorname{AGL}_{1}(p) . More general, we solve the corresponding counting problems for all groups which arise in a tower of a cyclic extension of order p p over a cyclic extension of degree d d coprime to p p . This in particular give answers for certain non-abelian groups including S 3 S_{3} , dihedral groups of order 2 ​ p 2p , and many Frobenius groups. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 11S20; Secondary 11S31, 11R45 1. Introduction There is a lot of interest to ask how many extensions with a given Galois group and bounded discriminant exist, and what is the asymptotic behaviour when this bound goes to infinity. We would like to count non-normal extensions as well, and therefore we define by abuse of notation a Galois group for non-normal extensions. For this, let G\leq S_{n} be a finite transitive permutation group on n points and let k be a field. We will write \operatorname{Gal}(K/k)=G if K/k is a field extension such that the Galois group of the Galois closure \hat{K}/k viewed as permutation group on the set of embeddings of K into \hat{K} is permutation-isomorphic to G . For example when we consider S_{3}\leq S_{3} we count degree 3-extensions, and by looking at S_{3}(6)\leq S_{6} we count Galois S_{3} -extensions. For number fields k and transitive permutation groups G\leq S_{n} , the classical case is to count by the norm of the relative discriminant. Z(k,G;X):=\#\{K/k~:~\operatorname{Gal}(K/k)=G,\quad N_{k/\mathbb{Q}}(\operatorname{D}(K/k))\leq X\}. For a given X\in\mathbb{R} , we have Z(k,G;X)<\infty . When k is a p -adic field, the total number of extensions is bounded. The same is true when k is a local function field of characteristic p , and when p is coprime to |G| . In all other cases, it is interesting to study the behaviour of Z(k,G;X) for X\to\infty . Gunter Malle proposed in [ 12 ] , [ 13 ] a conjecture for the asymptotic behaviour of Z(k,G;X) for number fields and finite transitive permutation groups. The Malle conjecture predicts explicit constants a(G),b(k,G) such that (1) Z(k,G;X)\sim c(k,G)\cdot X^{a(G)}\log(X)^{b(k,G)-1} for some constant c(k,G)>0 . In this work, we focus on the discriminant distribution over local function fields of characteristic p of some non-abelian groups G satisfying p\mid|G| . Let F be a local function field of characteristic p , i.e., a Laurent series ring over a finite field \mathbb{F}_{q} with q=p^{r} elements. For p\nmid d let L/F be a C_{d} -extension, where C_{d} denotes the cyclic group of order d . Note that there are only finitely many such L . Now we study the case that \operatorname{Gal}(M/L)=C_{p} . Consider the factorisation X^{d}-1=f_{1}(X)\cdots f_{r}(X)\in\mathbb{F}_{p}[X], and let I\subseteq\{1,\ldots,r\} , and denote by \ell(I):=\deg(\prod_{i\in I}f_{i}). We describe all potential Galois groups \operatorname{Gal}(M/F) arising in those towers. We denote those groups (see ( 16 )) of order dp^{\ell(I)} by G_{p}(d,I) . We study the corresponding discriminant counting functions, and prove the asymptotic behaviour of such functions. The main results of this paper are described in the following theorem (see Theorems 4.5 and 5.1 ), where we count by bounded discriminant exponent. The first function counts fields of degree pd , and the second function counts fields of degree dp^{\ell(I)} , i.e. Galois extensions. A precise definition of Z_{pd} and Z_{dp^{\ell(I)}} is given in ( 28 ). Theorem 1.1 . There exist a (p-1)pd -periodic function \beta_{I}(x) and a (p^{\ell(I)}-1)pd -periodic function \tilde{\beta}_{I}(x) such that (1) considered as a permutation group over pd points, we get for x\rightarrow\infty : Z_{pd}\left(F,G_{p}(d,I);x\right)\sim\beta_{I}(x)q^{ax}\text{, where }a:=\frac{\ell(I)}{pd}. (2) considered as a permutation group over dp^{\ell(I)} points, we get for x\rightarrow\infty : Z_{dp^{\ell(I)}}\left(F,G_{p}(d,I)\right);x)\sim\tilde{\beta}_{I}(x)q^{\tilde{a}x}\text{, where }\tilde{a}=\frac{p-1}{pd}\frac{\ell(I)}{p^{\ell(I)}-1}. The first part of this theorem was already proved in the PhD thesis [ 14 ] of the second author. The second part was only proved in the special case that |I|=1 . When \ell(I)=1 , some special cases are the dihedral groups of order 2p , or more general Frobenius groups C_{p}\rtimes C_{d} for d\mid(p-1) . Other groups in this list for p=2 are A_{4}\cong C_{2}^{2}\rtimes C_{3} or C_{2}^{3}\rtimes C_{7} . We see that the asymptotic behaviour is only depending on the group order dp^{\ell{(I)}} . The oscillating function is additionally depending on the chosen I . This means that the subgroups of \operatorname{AGL}(1,p)\cong C_{p}\rtimes C_{d} have the same asymptotic behaviour as C_{p} on p points or C_{p}\times C_{d} on pd points. 1.1. History For Malle’s conjecture, there has been a lot of activity in the number field situation, and in the case of global function fields when the characteristic is coprime to the group order. Let us focus on the case of positive characteristic. Wright [ 18 ] proved equation ( 1 ) for every finite abelian group A and over every global field k such that \operatorname{char}(k)\nmid|A| , prior to the works of Malle. Ellenberg and Venkatesh [ 1 ] gave a heuristic why Malle‘s conjecture should be true in the global function field situation when the group order is coprime to p (tame case). In recent works of Landesman and Levy [ 11 , Theorem 10.1.10] and Santens [ 17 ] the conjecture in the tame case is proved over rational function fields assuming that the constant field size is large enough. However, the exponent a(G) in ( 1 ) is incorrect if the characteristic p divides the group order. Lagemann [ 9 , Prop. 2.4] proved lower bounds for all elementary-abelian p -extensions. For non-cyclic groups, those lower bounds (except possibly for the group C_{2}\times C_{2} ) grow larger than ( 1 ) indicates. Potthast [ 16 ] proved the discriminant counting for all elementary abelian p -groups in characteristic p . The asymptotics of C_{2}\times C_{2} has one log-factor more than a corresponding Malle conjecture would predict. Other interesting results are given in [ 3 , 2 ] , where the counting (for rational global function fields) is done by the last jump in the upper numbering of the higher ramification groups. In [ 3 ] , the surprising result is that the counting function over rational function fields is a rational function. In [ 2 ] Gundlach and Seguin, deal with some cases of non-abelian p -groups over rational global function fields. Already Lagemann [ 9 , 10 ] proved the corresponding asymptotics for counting abelian p -groups by conductor over global function fields of characteristic p . It is well known that there are infinitely many extensions for a given p -group G over a local function field of characteristic p . Therefore, it is an interesting problem to ask for the asymptotic behaviour of the number of such extensions. Lagemann solved the case of counting abelian p -groups over local function fields by discriminant in [ 8 ] . The corresponding count over local function fields by conductor is given in [ 7 ] . In the PhD-thesis [ 14 ] of the second author there are asymptotic results for (generalized) Heisenberg groups of p -power

Read the complete text