Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10 ​ M ⊙ 10\,M_{\odot} peak in the merging black hole mass distribution

Isaac Legred, Jacob Golomb, Katerina Chatziioannou · 2026

Read Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10 ​ M ⊙ 10\,M_{\odot} peak in the merging black hole mass distribution by Isaac Legred, Jacob Golomb, Katerina Chatziioannou (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-01420.txt.

Introduction

Legred, Golomb and Chatziioannou test whether failed supernovae forming black holes by direct collapse near 10 solar masses reinforce the observed overdensity there. Merging rates drop by about 2 orders of magnitude from near 10 solar masses to near 15 solar masses, which progenitor compactness alone cannot fully explain. Using 153 GWTC-4.0 observations, they confirm a strong peak at 10 solar masses. The rate is consistent with zero at the 90 percent level between 12.0 and 16.1 solar masses, then rises above about 16 solar masses. That structure fits a distinct population of failed-supernova black holes.

Catalog record

CREATORIsaac Legred, Jacob Golomb, Katerina Chatziioannou
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71115
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.01420

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10 ​ M ⊙ 10\,M_{\odot} peak in the merging black hole mass distribution Isaac Legred, Jacob Golomb, Katerina Chatziioannou Abstract Gravitational-wave observations reveal that the rate of merging black holes drops by ∼ 2 \sim 2 orders of magnitude from component masses ∼ 10 ​ M ⊙ \sim 10\,M_{\odot} to ∼ 15 ​ M ⊙ \sim 15\,M_{\odot} . The increased compactness of the black hole progenitor cores may contribute to the ∼ 10 ​ M ⊙ \sim 10\,M_{\odot} overdensity, but cannot fully explain the rate difference. In this paper, we consider the possibility that the overdensity is reinforced by supernova processes that result in efficient black hole formation from direct collapse in a narrow range around 10 ​ M ⊙ 10\,M_{\odot} . We extend previous studies by considering a distinct subpopulation of failed-supernovae black holes, possibly separated by a gap in the primary mass distribution from the rest of the population. Using 153 observations from the latest GWTC-4.0 catalog, we confirm a strong peak in the primary mass distribution at 10 ​ M ⊙ 10\,M_{\odot} , with a peak rate density of 7.36 − 3.11 + 6.35 7.36_{-3.11}^{+6.35} M ⊙ − 1 ​ yr − 1 ​ Gpc − 3 M_{\odot}^{-1}\mathrm{yr}^{-1}\mathrm{Gpc}^{-3} . The rate drops sharply and becomes consistent with zero at the 90% level for primary mass m 1 ∈ m_{1}\in ( 12.0 , 16.1 ) ​ M ⊙ {\color[rgb]{1,0,0}(12.0,16.1)}\,M_{\odot} , then rises again to confidently nonzero values above ∼ 16 ​ M ⊙ \sim 16\,M_{\odot} before falling at higher masses. Our results reveal structure in the mass distribution in the 10 − 20 ​ M ⊙ 10-20\,M_{\odot} range, with rate changes of multiple orders of magnitude across a few solar masses, consistent with a distinct population of failed-supernova black holes. I Introduction The \sim 200 gravitational-wave signals from merging binary black holes (BBHs) 7 identified so far by the LIGO 1 , Virgo 14 , and KAGRA 16 detectors inform the distribution of BH masses and spins across cosmic time 6 . The BBH properties carry imprints of both the process through which progenitor stars died to form the observed BHs and the environment in which the binaries formed and evolved. In isolated formation, a BBH system forms from the collapse of two massive stars, with binary interactions shrinking the orbit such that the resulting binary can merge under gravitational radiation 71 ; 73 . In dynamical formation, interactions in dense environments cause existing binaries to tighten or binaries to form by capture 72 ; 77 . Theoretical predictions 61 and observations 21 ; 106 suggest that at least some BBHs form via the isolated channel (though see Ref. 105 ). BBH data can probe stellar evolution and massive star collapse under either formation mechanism, coupled to further binary dynamical or stellar evolution processes. The BBH mass distribution has a global maximum near 10\,M_{\odot} , after which the rate density drops by 1-2 orders of magnitude 10 ; 12 ; 37 ; 41 ; 28 ; 95 ; 46 ; 22 . This conclusion is supported both by low-dimensional “parametric” models (powerlaws, Gaussian peaks, dips, etc.) 12 ; 6 and more flexible “nonparametric” models (Gaussian processes, splines, etc.) 36 ; 28 ; 41 . Compared to more massive binaries, BBHs whose primary component falls in this range are characterized by a broad mass-ratio distribution and low spins 59 ; 48 ; 45 ; 6 ; 20 ; 93 . Furthermore, observations show a “gap” in the distribution of the better-constrained binary chirp mass 89 ; 91 ; 92 near 10-12\,M_{\odot} . This does not automatically imply a gap in the primary mass, which will depend on the details of currently poorly-constrained binary mass ratio distribution 91 . The potential sharp peak and subsequent gap would imply a separate astrophysical population that does not bleed over into the 12-16\,M_{\odot} range and a high mass population that does not extend below \sim 16\,M_{\odot} . While data decisively favor a peak at 10\,M_{\odot} distinct from the global power-law 6 , evidence for a gap in the primary mass distribution is elusive. Since the feature under discussion involves a rate reduction by 1-2 orders of magnitude within a few solar masses, modeling choices are important. Nonparametric models attempt to dispense with modeling assumptions in favor of flexibility. Nonetheless, they still inevitably impose correlation lengths on the mass distribution, for example via smoothing priors 54 . With the caveat that nonparametric models may not identify features sharper than their (explicit or implicit) correlation scale, multiple studies have found no compelling evidence of a gap 36 ; 28 ; 41 ; 6 in the primary mass distribution. Parametric models, on the other hand, use functional forms to model the population, which is justified by a priori expectations about the overall population. In this context, explicit parametric gap-like features were confidently identified in the chirp mass 91 , but not the primary mass distribution 15 . A more detailed discussion of these works and comparison with our results is given in Sec. IV . A potential explanation for the peak at 10\,M_{\odot} is linked to the properties of the BH progenitors, and specifically, the increased compactness of progenitor stellar cores which is related to their explodability (and hence the difficulty of forming BHs). Stars with carbon-oxygen (CO) core mass M_{\rm CO}\sim 6.5\,M_{\odot} have anomalously large core compactness which in turn may lead to direct collapse to BHs 81 , a fact also established in phenomenological 1D simulations 68 (see also Ref. 57 and references therein). Such a mechanism would naturally explain peaks at \sim 9\,M_{\odot} and 16\,M_{\odot} , and a gap from 9-13\,M_{\odot} 81 . Moreover, BHs formed from direct collapse of overcompact massive stars should have lower kicks 26 , increasing the chances of binary survival. A model directly based on this scenario is explored in Ref. 45 , which however did not allow for an arbitrarily low-rate gap in the mass distribution. However, more detailed population synthesis estimates suggest a rate enhancement of only a factor of \sim 3 at \sim 9-10\,M_{\odot} 81 ; 100 ; 101 , far below the observed drop. Instead, it is possible that failure of stars to launch a supernova (SNe) and instead collapse directly to BHs depends also on other details of the progenitor stars 35 . 3D simulations of dying massive stars have achieved successful explosions across a range of progenitor masses 63 ; 97 ; 82 ; 67 ; 74 ; 56 ; 69 ; 25 ; 27 , even with no tunable macroscopic calibration parameters. However, expectations that explodability is primarily driven by the stellar core compactness 68 (which in turn is determined primarily by the ZAMS mass) have not been confirmed, with factors such as the compositional and entropy profiles coming into play 24 . Among the solar-metallicity progenitors of Ref. 26 , only the ones with ZAMS mass 11-14\,M_{\odot} formed BHs due to failed SNe. This is characteristic of a trend seen in Refs. 33 ; 85 in which progenitors in this mass range are prone to fail to launch SNe. Varying the progenitor ZAMS mass, 27 found progenitors near 12\,M_{\odot} to be the only ones failing

Read the complete text