Descending into the Modular Bootstrap Preprint: MIT-CTP/6023
Nathan Benjamin, A. Liam Fitzpatrick, Wei Li, and Jesse Thaler · 2026
Read Descending into the Modular Bootstrap Preprint: MIT-CTP/6023 by Nathan Benjamin, A. Liam Fitzpatrick, Wei Li, and Jesse Thaler (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-01275.txt.
Introduction
Benjamin, Fitzpatrick, Li and Thaler search for two-dimensional conformal field theories by turning modular invariance into a loss to minimize. They add an error gauge for cutting the spectrum short. They also use a new singular-value optimizer, Sven, that beats gradient descent on the layered landscape. The search yields candidate partition functions with central charges from 1 to 8 over 7, a range with no known examples, and points to a tighter gap limit near central charge 1.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nathan Benjamin, A. Liam Fitzpatrick, Wei Li, and Jesse Thaler |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 119447 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.01275
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Descending into the Modular Bootstrap Preprint: MIT-CTP/6023 Nathan Benjamin, A. Liam Fitzpatrick, Wei Li, and Jesse Thaler Abstract In this paper, we attempt to explore the landscape of two-dimensional conformal field theories (2d CFTs) by efficiently searching for numerical solutions to the modular bootstrap equation using machine-learning-style optimization. The torus partition function of a 2d CFT is fixed by the spectrum of its primary operators and its chiral algebra, which we take to be the Virasoro algebra with c > 1 c>1 . We translate the requirement that this partition function is modular invariant into a loss function, which we then minimize to identify possible primary spectra. Our approach involves two technical innovations that facilitate finding reliable candidate CFTs. The first is a strategy to estimate the uncertainty associated with truncating the spectrum to the lowest dimension operators. The second is the use of a new singular-value-based optimizer ( Sven ) that is more effective than gradient descent at navigating the hierarchical structure of the loss landscape. We numerically construct candidate truncated CFT partition functions with central charges between 1 and 8 7 \frac{8}{7} , a range devoid of known examples, and argue that these candidates likely come from a continuous space of modular bootstrap solutions. We also provide evidence for a more stringent constraint on the spectral gap near c = 1 c=1 than the existing bound of Δ gap ≤ c 6 + 1 3 \Delta_{\rm gap}\leq\frac{c}{6}+\frac{1}{3} . 1 Introduction Are consistent quantum field theories (QFTs) rare or abundant? If they are rare, then it makes sense to exhaustively catalog them. If they are abundant, though, any individual QFT tells you little about the space of consistent QFTs, and it makes more sense to establish broad properties of and constraints on such systems. At least within perturbation theory, Lagrangians provide a systematic and practical way to explore such questions. More generally, though, we are still far from any kind of explicit catalog of all QFTs at strong coupling. The case of two-dimensional conformal field theories (2d CFTs) offers at least a clear mathematical framework for constructing such a catalog. CFTs are defined by a discrete countable set of data, namely the spectrum of conformal weights and operator product expansion (OPE) coefficients of primary operators, together with a chiral algebra. 1 1 1 More generally, non-compact CFTs like Liouville CFT can have continuous spectra and lack an \text{SL}(2,\mathbb{R}) invariant vacuum state. We will only consider compact CFTs in this work, by insisting there is a vacuum in the spectrum. Moreover, there is a complete set of axioms that 2d CFTs have to satisfy, most important of which are modular invariance of the torus partition function, crossing symmetry of the sphere four-point correlators, and modular covariance of the torus one-point functions. Thus, the space of 2d CFTs can concretely be considered the space of sets of CFT data that satisfy the equations imposed by these constraints. Finding such solutions is still an extremely challenging problem, but it is at least possible to explore the space of such solutions and their properties numerically. This is in fact what the conformal bootstrap and modular bootstrap equations do, by finding general constraints imposed by these conditions. In this paper, we take a complementary approach, sometimes called the “primal” approach, to these constraints, where we attempt to explore the space of possible 2d CFTs by explicitly constructing solutions to a subset of the full set of constraints. We only consider the constraint of modular invariance of the torus partition function, and therefore it is more accurate to say that we are exploring the space of 2d CFT partitions functions rather than the space of 2d CFTs. Because modular invariance imposes an effectively infinite number of constraints, we will at best be able to construct approximate solutions. The exact definition of “approximate” that we use will be one of the main features of this paper, and we present evidence that key features of the space of approximate solutions we find is robust to improving the approximation. A grand (and perhaps quixotic) long-term goal of our approach would be to ultimately find approximate solutions to all the 2d CFT constraints and thereby construct new, fully-fledged 2d CFTs. At c=1 , there is an exhaustive catalog of unitary 2d CFTs, 2 2 2 It is still unproven that the known c=1 CFTs are exhaustive, though they are widely believed to be. including a moduli space of compactified boson theories, their orbifolds, and a discrete set of exceptional cases 27 ; 28 . For c>1 , no exhaustive catalog is known, though a number of properties and constraints have already been established, including the celebrated Cardy formula on the asymptotic density of states 14 , various operator bounds derived through the modular bootstrap 15 ; 35 ; 23 ; 17 ; 34 , and holographic relations at very large c 55 ; 33 ; 21 . There are several infinite classes of constructions of 2d CFTs at c>1 . The Wess-Zumino-Witten (WZW) coset models (which include the minimal series CFTs as special cases) are rational CFTs, meaning that they have a finite number of (chiral) primary operators, and have simple, explicit formulas for their operator spectrum. Additionally, there are continuous families from Narain moduli space and Calabi-Yau moduli space, based on a geometric ‘‘target space’’ interpretation. Nevertheless, despite this large set of known 2d CFTs, they are all ‘‘non-generic” in the sense that they all are either rational (have a finite number of primary operators under the theory’s chiral algebra) or are marginal deformations of rational theories. Indeed, although the standard lore is that ‘‘most’’ 2d CFTs should be irrational, 3 3 3 As far as we know, this lore is not based on any rigorous result but rather reflects the idea that solvable theories are special and chaotic theories are more generic; the fact that all known 2d CFTs are rational theories (or marginal deformations thereof) is likely a lamppost effect. Moreover, the conformal algebra forces unitary CFTs to be rational at sufficiently small central charge (e.g. c<1 for non-supersymmetric CFTs, c<\frac{3}{2} for {\cal N}=1 superconformal CFTs, etc.), but not at larger central charge. with an infinite number of (Virasoro) primaries and no conserved currents beyond the stress tensor, there are no completely explicit examples. 4 4 4 There are some very interesting recent attempts. See, for example Refs. 3 ; 4 ; 6 , which looked at short renormalization group flows from coupled minimal models using perturbation theory, and Ref. 5 , which constructed a lattice model that conjecturally flows to an irrational CFT with c=2.10\pm 0.03 . See also Ref. 45 for another possible strategy of discovering new 2d CFTs. Without any confirmed examples of irrational compact 2d CFTs with only Virasoro symmetry, though, we have little to guide our intuition about whether such systems should be abundant, rare, or non-existent. (a) (b) Figure 1: Space of (a) established 2d CFTs compared to (b) the results of this study, in the (c,\Delta_{\rm gap}) plane of central charge versus spectral gap. The dashed black lines corresponds to the unitary bound \Delta_{\rm gap}\geq 0 and the known dual bound \Delta_{\rm gap}\leq\frac{c}{6}+\frac{1}{3} 35 ; 23 ; 17 ,