Pions reloaded
M.N. Ferreira A.S. Miramontes, J.M. Morgado, J. Papavassiliou J.M. Pawlowski · 2026
Read Pions reloaded by M.N. Ferreira A.S. Miramontes, J.M. Morgado, J. Papavassiliou J.M. Pawlowski (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00996.txt.
Introduction
Ferreira and colleagues offer a new take on the chiral-limit pion Bethe-Salpeter equation, solved using state-of-the-art QCD correlation functions as ingredients. The constraints from axial Ward-Takahashi identities hold exactly, both formally and numerically. Bethe-Salpeter equations describe quark binding into mesons, and the chiral limit is the case where light quarks count as massless.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M.N. Ferreira A.S. Miramontes, J.M. Morgado, J. Papavassiliou J.M. Pawlowski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 7900 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00996
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Pions reloaded Thanks: Presented by J.P. at the Excited QCD Workshop 2026, Granada, Spain
M.N. Ferreira A.S. Miramontes, J.M. Morgado, J. Papavassiliou J.M. Pawlowski
Abstract
We present a novel version of the pion Bethe-Salpeter equation in the chiral limit, solved using as ingredients state-of-the-art QCD correlation functions. The constraints imposed by the axial Ward-Takahashi identities are exactly fulfilled, both formally and numerically.
1
Introduction
The
wealth of information
on the structure of the QCD correlation functions,
amassed by functional
methods and lattice simulations
[
12
,
21
,
14
,
16
]
,
may be profitably utilized
in the physics of hadrons
only within sophisticated frameworks
that respect the constraints imposed
by chiral symmetry.
Recently, a theoretical approach was developed
in
[
19
]
,
which allows for the
self-consistent inclusion of
dressed correlation functions in the dynamical equations describing the physics of mesons.
This approach was judiciously simplified in
[
10
]
, leading to a rather tractable set of dynamical equations.
In particular, the quark-gap
and the pion Bethe Salpeter equation (BSE)
admit fully-dressed quark-gluon vertices, denoted by
\Gamma_{\mu}(q,r,-p)
,
containing all possible tensorial structures.
In this presentation we showcase the application of this
method in the study of massless pions.
2
Main ingredients
Figure 1
:
Panel A:
The exact SDE for the axial-vector
\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}
.
Panel B:
The SDE for the vertex
G_{5}^{\mu\nu}
, after implementing the SV approximation.
Our starting point is the axial-vector
vertex
\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}(P,p_{2},-p_{1})
, which satisfies
the Ward-Takahashi identity (WTI)
[
20
,
15
]
-P_{\mu}\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}(P,p_{2},-p_{1})=S^{-1}(p_{1})\gamma_{5}+\gamma_{5}S^{-1}(p_{2})\,,
(1)
where
S^{-1}(p)=A(p^{2})\not{p}-B(p^{2})
is the inverse quark propagator.
The dynamical breaking of the chiral symmetry gives rise to a non-vanishing
B(p^{2})
, and from Eq. (
1
) one obtains:
\lim_{P\to 0}P_{\mu}\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}(P,p_{2},-p_{2})=2B(p^{2})\gamma_{5}
.
This, in turn, forces
\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}(P,p_{2},-p_{1})
to contain a
longitudinally coupled
massless pole,
(P^{\mu}/P^{2})\,\chi(P,p_{2},-p_{1})\gamma_{5}
,
associated with the
corresponding
massless Goldstone boson (pion).
In the limit
P\to 0
, we have that
\chi(0,p,-p)=\chi_{1}(p^{2})+\chi_{3}(p^{2})\not{p}=2B(p^{2})\,,
(2)
from which we get two key constraints
for the components of the pion BS amplitude, namely
[
20
]
\displaystyle\chi_{1}(p^{2})
\displaystyle=2B(p^{2})\,,
\displaystyle\chi_{3}(p^{2})
\displaystyle=0\,.
(3)
The SDE governing
\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}(P,p_{2},-p_{1})
is shown in
Fig.
1
A
[
5
]
. The
element crucial for effectuating
the transition beyond the RL is the
axial-vector-gluon vertex,
G_{5}^{\mu\nu}(P,q,p_{2},-q_{1})
, denoted by a yellow circle;
it is composed of
“one-loop-dressed” diagrams, which, at the
level of
\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}(P,p_{2},-p_{1})
, correspond
to “two-loop dressed” contributions.
G_{5}^{\mu\nu}(P,q,p_{2},-q_{1})
obeys the WTI
[
6
]
\displaystyle-iP_{\mu}G_{5}^{\mu\nu}(P,q,p_{2},-q_{1})=\Gamma^{\nu}(q,p_{1},-q_{1})\gamma_{5}+\gamma_{5}\Gamma^{\nu}(q,p_{2},-q_{2})\,,
(4)
where
q_{i}:=p_{i}+q
,
which guarantees that the diagrammatic representation of
\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}(P,p_{2},-p_{1})
, given by
Fig.
1
A
,
satisfies the WTI of Eq. (
1
) exactly.
3
The symmetric-vertex approximation
Figure 2
:
Panel A:
The SDE for the quark-gluon vertex in the SV approximation.
Panel B:
The corresponding gap equation.
Panel C:
The final pion BSE, after renormalization. The index “1”
indicates the part of the cyan vertex that
contains an odd number of Dirac
\gamma
matrices, while the square vertex stands for its “quantum” part, namely the sum of the graphs
c_{1}
and
c_{2}
.
As demonstrated in
[
19
]
,
the dynamical equation that determines
G_{5}^{\mu\nu}
comprises two classes of diagrams: those
that contain
G_{5}^{\mu\nu}
, and those
where the
G_{5}^{\mu\nu}
is replaced by
\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}
.
It turns out that a symmetry-preserving truncation may be implemented at this point,
by keeping only the terms involving the
\Gamma_{\!5}^{\mu}
, provided that
a compensating modification takes place at the
level of the quark-gluon vertex.
Specifically, in the diagrams retained, shown in
Fig.
1
B
,
one must implement the replacement
\Gamma_{\mu}(q,r,-p)\to V_{\mu}(q)=\gamma_{\mu}V(q)
,
see
Fig.
3
.
This same replacement must be carried out
in the defining diagrams of the SDE
for
\Gamma_{\mu}(q,r,-p)
[
4
,
23
,
13
]
, which acquires the form
shown in
Fig.
2
A
.
Note that the
WTIs are preserved provided that
V(q)
be function of
a single kinematic variable,
namely the momentum carried by the gluon.
In practice, the
V(q)
chosen coincides
with the “symmetric limit”,
q^{2}=r^{2}=p^{2}
,
of the form factor
\lambda_{1}
associated with the
classical tensor
\gamma_{\mu}
. Because
of this particular characteristic, we coin this
truncation as the “
symmetric-vertex
“ (SV) approximation.
We emphasize that
the output of the SDE in
Fig.
2
A
,
represented by the cyan circle,
displays the
full
kinematic
structure associated with a quark-gluon vertex,
namely eight tensorial structures (Landau gauge).
The corresponding form factors,
\lambda_{i}
,
depend on three kinematic variables,
e.g.
,
q^{2}
,
r^{2}
and
q\cdot r
.
The new pion BSE consists of three
diagrams, shown in
Fig.
2
C
. The first corresponds to the
dressed version of the standard rainbow-ladder (RL)
contribution
[
17
,
18
,
8
]
,
while the remaining two guarantee the
symmetry-preserving nature of the approach.
Figure 3
:
Left panel
:
Schematic representation of the SV approximation.
Right panel:
The classical form factor
\lambda_{1}
obtained in
[
3
]
; the orange line indicates the symmetric configuration
r^{2}=p^{2}=q^{2}
, used for
V(q)
.
4
Numerical analysis
The system of coupled equations shown in
Fig.
2
(quark-gluon vertex SDE, quark gap equation, and pion BSE) is solved using state-of-the-art
ingredients for the correlation functions entering
in the corresponding kernels. In particular, we
use the gluon propagator obtained from the lattice
simulation of
[
1
]
. As explained in
[
9
,
11
]
, the key dynamics associated
with the emergence of a gluon mass gap
are due to the operation of the
Schwinger mechanism in QCD.
For the
the three-gluon vertex,
\Gamma_{\alpha\beta\gamma}(q,r,p)
, entering in graph
c_{2}
of
Fig.
2
A
, we capitalize on the key
property of the
“planar-degeneracy”
[
7
,
22
]
: the tranversely projected
\Gamma_{\alpha\beta\gamma}(q,r,p)
is very accurately described
by the tree-level structure, multiplied by a special form factor
L_{sg}(s)
.
An accurate fit for
L_{sg}(s)
is given in Eq. (A1) of
[
2
]
.
The two main highlights of the numerical analysis are presented in
Fig.
4
. On the left panel,
we show the individual contribution of each of the three
BSE diagrams to the eigenvalue
\lambda(P^{2})
of the BSE,
for which, at
P^{2}=0
(massless pion) we have
\lambda(0)=1
. On the right panel
we demonstrate that the pion BS amplitude,
\chi_{1}(p)
,
satisfies at a high degree of accuracy (better than
1\%
) the symmetry-induced relation
given in Eq. (
3
).
This result constitutes a clear
numerical confirmation of the
symmetry-preserving nature of the
entire approach.
Figure 4
:
Left panel
: Contributions to the eigenvalue of the pion BSE,
from each of the three diagrams shown in
Fig.
2
C
.
Right panel
: Numerical confirmation of the WTI-imposed relation
\chi_{1}(p)=2B(p)
.
5
Conclusions
We have presented a brief review of the
symmetric vertex approximation,
which allows the symmetry-preserving
treatment of the pion dynamics
using fully-dressed QCD correlation functions,
and, in particular, fully-dressed quark-gluon
vertices, with all form-factors dynamically