20 years of monitoring: PKS 2155 − - 304 and PKS 1510 − - 089 in the eyes of Swift and Fermi. II. PKS 1510 − - 089 and comparison Journal: Journal of High Energy Astrophysics
Michael Zacharias, Alicja Wierzcholska · 2026
Read 20 years of monitoring: PKS 2155 − - 304 and PKS 1510 − - 089 in the eyes of Swift and Fermi. II. PKS 1510 − - 089 and comparison Journal: Journal of High Energy Astrophysics by Michael Zacharias, Alicja Wierzcholska (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00884.txt.
Introduction
Zacharias and Wierzcholska present the companion two-decade multiwavelength study of the blazar PKS 1510-089, comparing it with PKS 2155-304 studied with the same techniques. High-energy gamma-ray and X-ray flux distributions are log-normal, while optical distributions fit double-log-normal functions, possibly from accretion-disk contributions. Unlike its companion, PKS 1510-089 shows no harder-when-brighter behavior. Both sources show orphan flares in any band, with variability patterns that keep changing unpredictably.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael Zacharias, Alicja Wierzcholska |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53122 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00884
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
20 years of monitoring: PKS 2155 − - 304 and PKS 1510 − - 089 in the eyes of Swift and Fermi. II. PKS 1510 − - 089 and comparison Journal: Journal of High Energy Astrophysics Michael Zacharias, Alicja Wierzcholska Abstract We present a comprehensive, two-decade, multiwavelength variability study of the blazar PKS 1510 − - 089, one of the most prominent and extensively monitored flat-spectrum radio quasars. Using Fermi -LAT γ \gamma -ray data together with Swift -XRT and UVOT observations spanning 2005–2024, we trace the long-term evolution of its flux, interband correlations, and spectral behaviour across the optical, X-ray, and γ \gamma -ray bands. We find that the HE γ \gamma -ray and X-ray flux distributions are log-normal, while the optical distributions are compatible with double-log-normal functions. The latter may be due to contributions from the accretion disk. The range of fluxes in a given band, as well as the fractional variability values are in-line with the expectations that high-energy parts of a given spectral component are more variable than low-energy parts. No obvious cross-correlations exist between the bands over the 20 years of observations. The X-ray and γ \gamma -ray spectra are variable, but do not show any trend with flux. These results are suggestive of different zones being active in the jet of PKS 1510 − - 089 at any given time. In a previous paper, we used the same techniques to study the high-frequency-peaked BL Lac object PKS 2155 − - 304. Both sources follow the aforementioned trend on the energy-dependent variability of the spectral components, as well as the lack of significant cross-correlations between the studied bands. While PKS 2155 − - 304 exhibits a harder-when-brighter behaviour in its high-energy part of the synchrotron component, no such behaviour could be found in PKS 1510 − - 089. Both sources show orphan flares, which can seemingly happen in any band. In summary, the long-term studies of these two sources reveal that the underlying physics is similar in these apparently different source classes, even though variability patterns keep changing and remain unpredictable. 1 Introduction PKS 1510 - 089 is a peculiar blazar. As a member of this source class, its relativistic jet emanating from the vicinity of the central supermassive black hole, points towards Earth. The accretion disk is visible as a big blue bump ( 24 ) in the spectral energy distribution (SED), and the broad optical emission lines lead to PKS 1510 - 089’s classification as a flat-spectrum radio quasar (FSRQ). Partially owing to its moderate redshift of z=0.361 , it was the second FSRQ to be detected at very-high-energy (VHE, E>100\, GeV) \gamma rays ( 17 ) , but is at time of writing the only FSRQ with persistent VHE emission ( 23 ) . Apart from the accretion disk and the emission lines, the multiwavelength (MWL) SED shows the two common broad-band non-thermal emission components. The low-energy one peaks in the far-infrared domain and is attributed to synchrotron emission of relativistic electrons. The high-energy component peaks in the MeV domain and is normally assumed to be inverse-Compton emission of the same electrons. Relativistic protons may also directly or indirectly contribute to the high-energy component (see 9 , for a review) . However, the SED of PKS 1510 - 089 has always shown complications, which have led to a considerable debate about the nature of its components. While a standard leptonic one-zone model can be made to work, it requires contributions from both the broad-line region (BLR) and the dusty torus (DT) for the seed photon field of the inverse-Compton component ( 5 ; 22 , e.g.,) . Other authors have argued that the SED along with other constraints requires at least a two-zone approach ( 25 ; 7 ; 30 ; 11 , e.g.,) . PKS 1510 - 089 used to be one of the most active blazars exhibiting strong variability in the optical continuum and the lines ( 20 ; 31 ; 3 ) , as well as the high-energy (HE, E>100\, MeV) \gamma -ray, and VHE \gamma -ray domains ( 32 ; 2 ; 15 , e.g.,) . Remarkably, there was no evidence for significant correlations between the HE and VHE bands ( 48 ) . Probably, one of the most surprising events took place in July 2021 ( 1 ) , when after a relatively strong optical flare (and some variability in the \gamma -ray band) all activity ceased and the optical and HE bands exhibited a severe flux drop. Additionally, the optical polarization also disappeared after reaching a level of up to 20\% during the preceding flare ( 26 ) . On the contrary, the X-ray and VHE \gamma -ray fluxes barely changed. 1 interpreted these observations as strong evidence for at least two emission regions with the variable one having vanished. Here, we analyse the long-term behaviour of PKS 1510 - 089 by studying 20 years of data from Swift and Fermi . This unprecedented data set allows us to obtain an overall picture of this blazar instead of the more common individual-events-focused approach. The variability aspects will be studied following the approach of 44 , where we studied the long-term properties of the high-frequency peaked BL Lac object (HBL) PKS 2155 - 304. This allows us to compare the timing properties of these two objects, which are archetypical members of their respective blazar categories. This is important, as the observational appearance – like SED peak positions, presence of thermal radiation fields, FSRQs being considered FRII galaxies, while BL Lac objects are supposedly FRI galaxies, etc. – suggests significant differences between these objects. However, while flares are common in both source categories, it is not obvious whether the timing properties are comparable or different. Given that variability is a common feature in most blazars – and, hence, jets – the timing information can tell us if the jet-intrinsic physics governing the radiation production are similar. Hence, the comparison of these sources allows us to gain a more fundamental view of blazar jets and their variability. The paper is organized as follows. The data analysis procedures are described in Sec. 2 , while the variability studies are conducted in Sec. 3 . In Sec. 4 , we discuss the results of PKS 1510 - 089, and compare them to PKS 2155 - 304. We summarize our findings in Sec. 5 . 2 Data analyis 2.1 Fermi-LAT The high-energy (HE) \gamma -ray observations of PKS 1510 - 089 obtained with the Large Area Telescope (LAT) onboard the Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope span the period from August 4, 2008, to August 8, 2024, corresponding to 16 years of continuous monitoring of the blazar. The data analysis was conducted using the Fermi Science Tools (version 2.2.0), the fermipy package (version 1.2.2), and the instrument response functions P8R3_SOURCE_V3 . Events were selected within a 15^{\circ} radius around the source position, applying standard quality criteria, including a zenith angle cut of <90^{\circ} and the DATA_QUAL >0 filter to exclude intervals of poor data quality. The analysis was restricted to the 100 MeV–500 GeV energy range. The background model included all sources from the 4FGL-DR3 catalogue within 12^{\circ} of the target. For sources located