Role Differentiation in a Coupled Resource Ecology under Multi-Level Selection

Siddharth Chaturvedi, Ahmed El-Gazzar, Marcel van Gerven · 2026

Read Role Differentiation in a Coupled Resource Ecology under Multi-Level Selection by Siddharth Chaturvedi, Ahmed El-Gazzar, Marcel van Gerven (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00810.txt.

Introduction

Chaturvedi, El-Gazzar, and van Gerven model how role differentiation can emerge when non-cooperating agents share coupled resource channels under multi-level selection. Group-level selection shapes a shared base and mutation rule. Individuals still face their own selection pressure, in an embodied ecology with positive-sum intake and zero-sum redistribution channels. In their learned ecology, both channels stay occupied at colony level, dodging collapse into a single acquisition mode.

Catalog record

CREATORSiddharth Chaturvedi, Ahmed El-Gazzar, Marcel van Gerven
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36642
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00810

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Role Differentiation in a Coupled Resource Ecology under Multi-Level Selection Siddharth Chaturvedi, Ahmed El-Gazzar, Marcel van Gerven Abstract A group of non-cooperating agents can succumb to the tragedy-of-the-commons if all of them seek to maximize the same resource channel to improve their viability. In nature, however, groups often avoid such collapses by differentiating into distinct roles that exploit different resource channels. It remains unclear how such coordination can emerge under continual individual-level selection alone. To address this, we introduce a computational model of multi-level selection, in which group-level selection shapes a common substrate and mutation operator shared by all group members undergoing individual-level selection. We also place this process in an embodied ecology where distinct resource channels are not segregated, but coupled through the same behavioral primitives. These channels are classified as a positive-sum intake channel and a zero-sum redistribution channel. We investigate whether such a setting can give rise to role differentiation under turnover driven by birth and death. We find that in a learned ecology, both channels remain occupied at the colony level, and the collapse into a single acquisition mode is avoided. Zero-sum channel usage increases over generations despite not being directly optimized by group-level selection. Channel occupancy also fluctuates over the lifetime of a boid. Ablation studies suggest that most baseline performance is carried by the inherited behavioral basis, while the learned variation process provides a smaller but systematic improvement prior to saturation. Together, the results suggest that multi-level selection can enable groups in a common-pool setting to circumvent tragedy-of-the-commons through differentiated use of coupled channels under continual turnover. Submission type: Full Paper Data/Code available at: https://abmax.short.gy/multi-level-selection-ecology † † ©2026 [AUTHORS’ NAMES]. Published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license. Introduction Heterogeneity in groups of living systems, such as differentiation of roles, is a common phenomenon that is often important for their survival ( 22 ) . It can be observed at various scales of their existence, from different types of cells in an organ to different roles in a colony of organisms. Such heterogeneity can be inferred from the different functional niches that group members evolve to occupy. For instance, in animal colonies such as ants and bees ( 19 ) , individuals may differ in how they acquire resources and contribute to group maintenance. This creates functional heterogeneity within a shared ecological system and exemplifies division of labour ( 22 ) . If group members reside in a common-pool-resource environment ( 17 ) , such heterogeneity can help them circumvent the tragedy-of-the-commons scenario ( 13 ) . In this scenario, if all individuals seek to optimize a resource via the same channel, the entire group may exhaust it to starvation. However, it seems implausible that individual group members are selected by evolution for their ability to optimize a group-level objective ( 27 ; 28 ) . On the contrary, it is much more plausible that selection at the level of individual members is relative. Members with higher fitness get more opportunities to reproduce. Thus, competition among individuals in a common-pool-resource environment is a natural mode of interaction. On the other hand, uncovering the mechanism responsible for the emergence of coordination, such as heterogeneity or role differentiation, in such settings still remains an open question ( 30 ) . At a deeper level, this question also relates to major evolutionary transitions. These include the emergence of multicellular organization from interacting unicellular units ( 18 ) , or scaling of individual-level goals to group-level objectives in living systems ( 20 ) . One source of diversity can be attributed to the fact that in many natural settings, selection does not strictly follow the survival-of-the-fittest rule but instead operates through a minimal-criteria selection ( 3 ) . Whereby, all individuals who are able to maintain their fitness above a certain minimal threshold remain viable for reproduction, compared to only the elite individuals getting the opportunities. Computational models of such a selection process have already shown the emergence of different foraging modes in populations of similar foragers ( 1 ; 11 ) . However, since the foraging channel for all the foragers in those models was the same, the overall population behavior still remained vulnerable to the tragedy-of-the-commons. At the group-level, from a Darwinian perspective, it can be argued that groups of living systems that can resolve the tragedy-of-the-commons scenario more successfully are better candidates for natural selection than those that can not ( 27 ) . The interplay between individual-level selection and group-level selection is often formulated as a multi-level selection process ( 23 ) . Computational models of such interplay have demonstrated the evolution of altruistic individuals even when altruism was associated with lower fitness at the individual-selection level ( 6 ) . In this work, we present a computational model of a multi-level selection process where we explore a specific type of coupling between the two levels of selection. Namely, the group-level selection acts on a shared controller substrate, together with a mutation-operator, both of which are expressed during individual-level minimal-criteria selection. The shared controller substrate provides the inherited dynamical regime within which individual-level selection unfolds, while the mutation-operator further guides the local generation of variation during reproduction. The aim of the model is to investigate if such a coupling can give rise to role differentiation, via which the group does not succumb to the tragedy-of-the-commons. More specifically, the goal is not merely to obtain role differentiation once, but to investigate whether such differentiation can be continually regenerated under ongoing turnover fueled by the birth and death of agents. The hypothesis is based on the fact that, firstly, in natural multicellular development, multiple functional cellular states can arise from the same genotype through a common underlying dynamical basis ( 25 ) . Secondly, mutation-operators may not only favor the short-term fitness of organisms but also the long-term benefits of future mutations ( 8 ) . In our case, these long-term benefits are evaluated through the group-level fitness. We use an active-particle-based boid model ( 21 ) , where agents can acquire resources from two sources. They can either slow down relative to the global average and graze resources in direct proportion to how slow they move, or they can exchange resources among themselves during close encounters, where resources flow from agents in relative abundance to agents in relative scarcity in proportion to the difference. Such a construction is ecologically meaningful because the same behavioral degrees of freedom can simultaneously shape resource gain, redistribution, and loss, and ecological theory often explains coexistence in common-pool settings through such coupled trade-offs rather than through isolated resource options ( 29 ; 15 ; 17 ) . The goal of the multi-level selection then becomes to discover a shared controller substrate and a mutation-operator that favors producing agents that show both resource-acquisition modes co-existing with each other under constant turnover of agents. In the following section, we describe the model in detail, after which we present the main results and conclusions of the work. Model The model used in this work consists of circular disk-shaped agents of equal diameter, called boids, moving in a two-dimensional Cartesian plane. The boids can pass through each other without a

Read the complete text