Managing the Mismatch: The Role of Flexibility on the Path to a Carbon-Neutral Energy System

Julian Geis, Michael Lindner, Tom Brown · 2026

Read Managing the Mismatch: The Role of Flexibility on the Path to a Carbon-Neutral Energy System by Julian Geis, Michael Lindner, Tom Brown (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00674.txt.

Introduction

Geis and colleagues study flexibility for carbon-neutral energy. Growth in flexibility is vital to absorb rising renewable shares, yet demand for flexibility and technology inputs stay poorly measured in models. Current methods are narrow, leaving open which matter for carbon-neutral power and what other plans cost. With a link-based flexibility gauge on a fine model of Germany's energy system, the team tracks its shift to neutral. By default, daily needs grow 3.7-fold from 2025 to 2045, driven by solar PV.

Catalog record

CREATORJulian Geis, Michael Lindner, Tom Brown
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE107802
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00674

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Managing the Mismatch: The Role of Flexibility on the Path to a Carbon-Neutral Energy System Julian Geis, Michael Lindner, Tom Brown Abstract A rapid expansion of system flexibility is essential to integrate increasing shares of renewable energy into future energy systems. However, flexibility needs and technology-specific contributions to flexibility remain poorly quantified in energy system modelling. Existing methods are not widely applied, leaving key questions unanswered: which flexibility technologies are critical for climate neutrality, and what are the cost implications of alternative deployment strategies? To address this gap, we apply a correlation-based flexibility metric to a high-resolution, sector-coupled model of the German energy system, covering its transformation towards climate neutrality. For our default scenario, we find that daily flexibility needs increase by a factor of 3.7 between 2025 and 2045, driven primarily by the expansion of solar PV. By 2045, stationary batteries provide 38% of daily flexibility, while flexible electric vehicle charging contributes 30%. Systems with constrained flexibility increase system costs by 6.9%, electricity prices by 14 €/MWh and trigger 47% higher hydrogen and e-fuel imports compared to an unconstrained system in 2045. In contrast, scenarios with high shares of flexible electric vehicle charging, vehicle-to-grid, and industrial demand-side management achieve system cost reductions of 3.3%, while also reducing import dependence. Higher flexibility also reduces electricity price ranges, decreases average electricity prices by 3 €/MWh, and reduces backup capacity by 22% (22 GW). Overall, our results highlight the decisive role of specific flexibility technologies in achieving cost-efficient and energy-secure climate-neutral energy systems, providing quantitative guidance for policy and investment decisions. 1 Introduction 1.1 Motivation The targets are set, and key elements of the path are clear: achieving climate-neutral energy systems within the coming decades requires a massive expansion of variable renewable energy sources (VRES), most importantly, wind and solar power. These technologies offer the most cost-effective route to decarbonisation and reduce dependence on fossil fuel imports in increasingly volatile geopolitical contexts. At the same time, their inherent variability and intermittency pose significant challenges for grid stability and security of supply. As the share of VRES increases, so does the need for flexibility to balance supply and demand efficiently. The nature of this flexibility need, and the question of how it should be provided, has become one of the central yet least well-defined aspects of energy system transformation. Despite its importance, coherent strategies for achieving adequate flexibility remain largely absent across many energy systems. The reasons are manifold and lie in the complexity of flexibility itself. There is substantial uncertainty regarding the future cost of flexibility, including potential cost reductions and performance improvements driven by technological learning, market design, and policy support, which complicates investment decisions. Moreover, flexibility needs are difficult to quantify precisely, as they depend on weather variability, demand patterns, and the pace of technological progress. Additionally, while sector coupling offers new opportunities to provide flexibility, it requires careful coordination of flexibility across sectors to ensure optimal performance and cost-effectiveness. The wide range of technologies that can provide flexibility across different timescales adds complexity to the task of identifying the most suitable options for a given energy system and quantifying their contributions to overall flexibility needs. 1.2 Literature The challenge begins with the definition of flexibility itself. The literature presents diverse conceptual approaches, ranging from flexibility as the capacity to integrate high shares of renewable energy papaefthymiou_power_2018 , IRENA_2018 to the “ability of the aggregated set of generators to respond to variations and uncertainty in net load” denholm_grid_2011 . More general definitions characterize flexibility as “the power system’s ability to cope with variability and uncertainty” heggarty_quantifying_2020 . This conceptual diversity extends to measurement approaches, as metrics for quantifying flexibility “may be ambiguous to different definitions” lund_review_2015 , leading some researchers to conclude that a single indicator is insufficient to capture flexibility’s multi-dimensional nature, spanning temporal (short-term vs long-term), spatial (local vs system-wide), and technological (supply-side vs demand-side) aspects emmanuel_review_2020 . Several methodologies have emerged to quantify flexibility requirements and provision, typically through analysis of the residual load which is the difference between inflexible electricity demand and non-dispatchable generation. Flexibility metrics can be distinguished by four facets: (1) how much flexibility is required, (2) how flexible is the flexibility solution, (3) how flexible is the power system, and (4) who is providing the flexibility heggarty_quantifying_2020 . This study primarily addresses questions (1) and (4), while also providing insights into (2) and (3). Statistical approaches define flexibility requirements through residual load characteristics. Brunner et al. brunner_future_2020 use three metrics - residual load range, surplus energy, and surplus time - to optimize renewable energy mixes. Other approaches focus on ramping capabilities such as ramping times huber_integration_2014 , deetjen_impacts_2017 , on the volatility of residual load or VRES output lannoye_power_2012 , epri_metrics_2014 , or on a combination of both aspects dvorkin_assessing_2014 . Storage requirements can also serve as a proxy for flexibility needs zerrahn_long-run_2017 , oh_energy-storage_2018 . Frequency-based methods decompose residual load into temporal components. Heggarty et al. heggarty_multi-temporal_2019 isolate daily, weekly and annual signals with discrete Fourier transform (DFT) to quantify flexibility requirements. This methodology is later used in heggarty_quantifying_2020 to decompose flexibility provision per technology into different timescales. Their approach yields two metrics: a stacked area chart showing each technology’s generation deviations from average, and percentage flexibility contributions per technology. While powerful, these methods rely on band-pass filters to assign variability to predefined frequency ranges. The choice of filter specifications (e.g., cutoff frequencies and bandwidths) is not unique, and results can be sensitive to these assumptions, leading to shifts in attributed flexibility across timescales and technologies huclin_methodological_2023 . In addition, their complexity reduces transparency and makes the results less intuitive and harder to interpret. A simpler, correlation-based approach, adopted by Artelys, IEA, and others artelys_mainstreaming_2017 , iea_managing_2023 , trinomics_power_2023 , solarpower_europe_mission_2024 , defines flexibility needs as the energy that must be shifted to achieve a flat residual load. Originally proposed by the French TSO RTE rte_bilan_2015 , Artelys extended this framework to assess technology contributions by subtracting individual generation profiles from the residual load and recalculating flexibility needs artelys_mainstreaming_2017 . However, the methodology used to attribute flexibility provision to individual technologies is only sparsely documented in the literature and relies primarily on project reports rather than peer-reviewed methodological descriptions. Moreover, the subtraction-based attribution approach is not mathematically additive and can therefore lead to inconsistent allocation of total flexibility needs across technologies. A detailed methodological discussion is provided in Section 2.1.2 . At the European level, several studies apply flexibility quantification to energy system models. The METIS project european_commission_metis_2015 finds that EU flexibility needs increase by 26% daily, 27% weekly, and 14% annually between 2020 and 2030 artelys_mainstreaming_2017 , intensifying to 80%, 60%, and 50% increases respectively between 2030 and 2050 artelys_optimal_2018 . Interconnectors emerge as dominant flexibility providers across all timescales, while batteries handle daily variations, pumped hydro storage (PHS) balances weekly patterns, and thermal units manage annual fluctuations. A Penta region study trinomics_power_2023 estimates that in Germany’s 2050 climate-neutral system, daily flexibility is provided by electrolyzers (27%), interconnectors (20%), electric vehicles (20%), and PHS (10%), while weekly and annual flexibility is dominated by electrolyzers (35-40%) and interconnectors (20-30%). ENTSO-E entso-e_system_2024 applies Fourier transform and Artelys-style time decomposition, finding that flexibility needs

Read the complete text