A comparison of pendulum models for large-amplitude longitudinal prominence oscillations
Iñigo Arregui · 2026
Read A comparison of pendulum models for large-amplitude longitudinal prominence oscillations by Iñigo Arregui (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00654.txt.
Introduction
Arregui compares pendulum models for large-amplitude longitudinal prominence oscillations. Such swings carry clues about magnetic and plasma structure on the Sun. Reliable seismology needs reliable models. The model has proven robust against data and sim runs. Recent work extended it to non-uniform gravity, yielding fixes that affect guesses of field strength. Arregui measures how forecasts from the first and newer models change the derived minimum field strength from seen swing periods.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Iñigo Arregui |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34580 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00654
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A comparison of pendulum models for large-amplitude longitudinal prominence oscillations Iñigo Arregui Abstract Large-amplitude prominence oscillations offer diagnostic information relevant to understanding the magnetic and plasma structure of solar prominences. Accurate prominence seismology requires the use of reliable models. The so-called pendulum model for large-amplitude longitudinal prominence oscillations has demonstrated robustness against observations and numerical simulations. Recent improvements have extended the model to situations with non-uniform gravity, thus leading to corrections that have implications for the inference of the magnetic field strength. In this study we quantify how the different model predictions given by the original and extended pendulum models impact the inference of the minimum magnetic field strength derived from the observed periods of large-amplitude longitudinal prominence oscillations. The analysis we conducted follows a Bayesian approach to solve the inference problem and assess the absolute and relative plausibilities of the two considered models in explaining the observed data, with their uncertainty. We find that the Bayesian solution to the inference problem provides well-constrained posteriors for the minimum magnetic field strength. However, the solutions from each adopted model differ, with differences increasing with the oscillation period. A model comparison analysis results in the extended model being more plausible in the full range of observed periods. However, the magnitude of the Bayes factor is not large enough to determine whether there is positive evidence supporting any of the models. We suggest computing model-averaged posteriors as the most reasonable solution to the inference problem. 1 Introduction Solar prominences are highly dynamic structures, and ground- and space-based observations obtained in the past five decades have shown clear evidence of their oscillatory dynamics ( Arregui et al. 2018 ) . The oscillations are commonly interpreted in terms of standing or propagating magnetohydrodynamic waves. Based on their velocity amplitude, prominence oscillations are classified into small and large amplitude events ( Oliver 1999 ; Oliver & Ballester 2002 ) . Large amplitude oscillations involve a significant part of the prominence structure and display velocity amplitudes greater than 20 km s -1 . They are excited by episodic energetic disturbances, such as Moreton or EIT waves ( Eto et al. 2002 ; Okamoto et al. 2004 ) , shock waves ( Shen et al. 2014 ) , nearby jets, and subflares or flares ( Jing et al. 2003 ; Li & Zhang 2012 ) . A particular class of large-amplitude prominence oscillations are those in which the prominence material undergoes periodic motions along the longitudinal axis of the structure ( Jing et al. 2003 ; Jing et al. 2006 ; Vršnak et al. 2007 ; Zhang et al. 2012 ; Luna et al. 2014 ; Zhang et al. 2017 ; Luna et al. 2018 ) . These so-called large-amplitude longitudinal oscillations (LALOs) have periods between 50 and 160 min, damping times of 120 to 600 min, and velocity amplitudes in the range of 30 – 100 km s -1 . A number of theoretical models have been proposed in order to explain the observed properties of LALOs in prominences ( Kleczek & Kuperus 1969 ; Vršnak et al. 2007 ; Jing et al. 2006 ; Luna & Karpen 2012 , see e.g.) . Among them, the so-called pendulum model by Luna & Karpen 2012 has been successful in explaining the oscillations in terms of a restoring force due to the projected gravity in the tube where the threads oscillate and their damping as being a consequence of the steady accretion of mass onto the threads by thermal non-equilibrium processes. The validity of the pendulum model was tested by Zhang et al. 2012 using Hinode observations and numerical simulations and by Luna et al. 2016 , who performed 2D non-linear time-dependent simulations of large-amplitude longitudinal oscillations in a dipped magnetic structure and found good agreement between the numerical results and the Luna & Karpen 2012 theoretical model. Model predictions were observationally tested for events in the GONG catalogue of filament oscillations by Luna et al. 2018 . The robustness of the model provides a diagnostic tool to perform prominence seismology in order to infer the curvature radius of the magnetic field lines and the magnetic field strength. The Luna & Karpen 2012 pendulum model makes two main simplifying assumptions: the consideration of uniform gravity and the semi-circular geometry of the supporting flux tubes. Luna et al. 2022 relaxed these assumptions and extended the model to situations with non-uniform gravity and different flux-tube geometries, with semi-circular, semi-elliptical, and sinusoidal dips. Luna et al. 2022 find that the spatial variation of the solar gravity introduces a correction in the equations governing longitudinal oscillations and modifies the pendulum-model approximation. The correction becomes significant for oscillation periods above 60 min, which has implications for the inference of the magnetic field strength. The gravity correction has the interesting effect of introducing a cut-off period such that longitudinal oscillations must have a period below 167 min. On the other hand, the pendulum model turns out to be quite robust and valid for non-circular dips, and the corrected pendulum model provides a good estimate of the radius of curvature at the bottom of the dips for any flux-tube geometry. In this study, we quantify how the differences in the predictions by the original ( Luna & Karpen 2012 ) and the extended ( Luna et al. 2022 ) pendulum models impact the corresponding inferences of the minimum magnetic field strength in prominences. We adopted a Bayesian approach to solve the inference problems and to quantify the level of evidence in favour of each of these models in view of the observed data and their uncertainty. 2 Analytical pendulum models In the original pendulum model by Luna & Karpen 2012 , the gravity projected along the magnetic field provides the restoring force of longitudinal oscillations. The oscillation period, P_{0} , is given by P_{0}=2\pi\sqrt{\frac{R}{g_{0}}}, (1) with R as the radius of curvature of the dipped portion of the field lines and g_{0}=274 m s -2 as the solar gravitational acceleration, which is assumed to be uniform. Because the magnetic structure is self-supporting, the magnetic tension of the dipped part of the tubes must be larger than the weight of the threads, leading to the condition \frac{B^{2}}{\mu_{0}R}\geq mng_{0}, (2) where B is the magnetic field strength at the bottom of the dip, \mu_{0} is the magnetic permeability of free space, n is the particle number density, and m=1.27\,m_{\rm p} is the mean particle mass, with m p as the proton mass. The combination of Equation ( 1 ) with the condition ( 2 ) leads to a constraint for the minimum magnetic field strength at the bottom of the dip ( Luna & Karpen 2012 ) : B\,\mbox{[G]}\geq 26\left(\frac{n}{10^{11}\mathrm{cm}^{-3}}\right)^{1/2}P_{0}\,\mbox{[hr]}. (3) Considering the condition of equality in Equation ( 2 ) enables us to formulate our model M_{1} for the period of longitudinal oscillations as a function of the two-parameter vector \mbox{\boldmath$\theta$}=\{B,n\} proposed to explain observed data D=\{P\} as P_{M_{1}}(n,B)=\frac{B}{f(n)},\,\,\mbox{with}\,\,f(n)=26\left(\frac{n}{10^{11}\mathrm{cm}^{-3}}\right)^{1/2}. (4) For magnetic field strength values in the range B\in[1,100] G and particle density values in the range n\in[10^{9},10^{11}] cm -3 , f(n)\in[2.6,26] , the model M_{1} predicts periods in the range P\in[2.3,2307] min. The robustness of this simple model has been assessed against numerical non-linear time-dependent simulations