How to Forage for a Mate? Preprint: APS/123-QED
Daniel T. Bernstein, Ahmed El Hady · 2026
Read How to Forage for a Mate? Preprint: APS/123-QED by Daniel T. Bernstein, Ahmed El Hady (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00393.txt.
Introduction
Bernstein and El Hady recast mate choice as a foraging problem. Foraging secures the energy animals need to survive, while mating secures offspring and continuity, yet past models of mate choice stayed coarse and skipped how animals actually weigh personal and environmental signals. The authors build a tractable theory, inspired by optimal foraging, for the decisions behind choosing a mate. It treats partner search as the same kind of problem as food search, with signals guiding each choice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel T. Bernstein, Ahmed El Hady |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20528 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00393
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
How to Forage for a Mate? Preprint: APS/123-QED Daniel T. Bernstein, Ahmed El Hady Abstract Foraging is a central decision-making behavior performed by all animals, essential to garnishing enough energy for an organism to survive. Similarly, mating is crucial for evolutionary continuity and offspring production. Mate choice is one of the central tenets of sexual selection, driving major evolutionary processes, and can be regarded as a decision-making process between potential mating partners. Often researchers have used coarse-grained models to describe macroscopic phenomenology pertaining to mate choice without detailed quantitative mechanisms of how animals use individual and environmental signals to guide their mating decisions. In this letter, we show that mate choice can be cast as a foraging problem, and we present an analytically tractable optimal foraging-inspired mechanistic theory of decision-making underlying mate choice. We begin from the premise that deciding upon which partner with which to mate is at its core a stochastic decision-making process. Agents adopt a variety of decision strategies, tuned by decision thresholds for leaving or committing to a mate. We find that sensitive leaving thresholds are favored independently of signal availability in the population. By contrast, optimal thresholds for committing to a mate depend upon signal availability in the population, with signal-rich populations generally favoring less eager strategies compared to signal-poor populations. I Introduction For sexually reproducing organisms with significant social or biophysical constraints on how many offspring they can have, and on the number of mates with which they can have them, choosing a mate becomes a salient problem 1 . Any given organism has mating preferences, but determining the presence and abundance of preferred traits in a potential mate takes time––time which is precious to an organism under the pressures of social competition and survival threats 4 ; 19 . Such a picture of the mate choice problem exhibits strong parallels to the patch foraging problem. In patch foraging models, animals search for food in discrete patches, and have the option to move between patches if the energetic cost of staying in a low-yield patch exceeds the cost of travelling to a new patch 7 ; 2 ; 13 ; 16 . Agents in these models, depending on environmental statistics, can adopt a variety of decision strategies: for example, minimizing the time it takes to arrive at a high-yielding patch, or maximizing the long term reward rate, spending more time in a high-yielding patch. In this paper, we develop a simple, mechanistic theory of mate choice in the case of an agent choosing between two potential mates. Our theory frames mate choice as a foraging problem: agents accumulate evidence about how well a potential mate aligns with its preferences via discrete signals, and choose to stay with or leave said mate based on the frequency of these signals. Our model differs from traditional foraging theory and similar exploration-exploitation frameworks in that agents must explicitly choose to commit to a single mate 20 ; 7 . In this sense, unlike traditional foraging behaviors, evidence accumulation and reward-seeking are decoupled, and agents who stay indefinitely with a preferred mate without committing to that mate receive no reward. As we will show, although both the commitment threshold and leaving threshold of a strategy determine the average reward incurred, the optimality conditions for the leaving threshold are largely independent of signaling rate in the population, unlike conditions for the commitment threshold. This theoretical model can be used to generate hypotheses about mechanistic underpinnings of mate choice across a variety of animal species. Figure 1: Schematic of mate choice model . The agent must choose between its current partner and the population (one-mate case, upper panel) or between its current partner and another potential mate (two-mate case, lower panel). II Model Framework We consider an agent-based model in which potential mates are characterized by a fitness parameter \lambda indicating alignment to the agent’s preferences. This fitness is the mean of a Poisson process: while an agent is spending time with a potential mate of fitness \lambda , it receives Poisson-distributed positive signals from that mate with mean frequency \lambda . Suppose our agent is currently courting a potential mate of fitness \lambda , drawn from a population of fitness distribution p(\lambda_{0}) . In order to compare the current mate to the population, we track the following log-likelihood: \rho(t)=\int_{0}^{\infty}p(\lambda_{0})\log[\frac{P(\lambda>\lambda_{0}|x(t))}{P(\lambda<\lambda_{0}|x(t))}]d\lambda_{0} (1) Such a likelihood is typical of Bayesian approaches to foraging and decision-theoretic models 12 ; 3 ; 21 The agent’s mating strategy is defined by two thresholds, \vec{\theta}=(\theta_{l} , \theta_{s} ), which determine thresholds for leaving and staying with a potential mate, respectively. The leaving threshold determines conditions for which the agent will decide to leave the mate whom they have been courting. The staying threshold determines conditions for which the agent decides to commit to the mate whom they have been courting. More precisely, if \rho(t)\geq\theta_{s} at any time, the agent commits to the current mate, whereas if \rho(t)\leq\theta_{l} , the agent leaves the current mate. As such, \theta_{\ell} serves as a sort of measure of a strategy’s “fickleness”: the smaller the value of |\theta_{\ell}| , the more readily will the agent leave a mate who is not signalling with sufficient frequency. Likewise, \theta_{s} measures “eagerness”: low values of |\theta_{s}| correspond to strategies for which an agent will more readily commit to a mate which is putting out plentiful signals. Additionally, we consider a signal at which time mating no longer becomes available, whether due to death, competition, et cetera. We choose this signal to be Poisson with scale \eta , inspired by the exponentially distributed mortality rate of many prey animals. The utility of choosing a mate with fitness \lambda is given by the reward function R(\lambda) . We start by taking R(\lambda)=c_{2}(\frac{e^{c_{1}\lambda}-e^{-c_{1}\lambda}}{e^{c_{1}\lambda}+e^{-c_{1}\lambda}}) . II.1 One-Mate Case Consider the case in which the agent is presented with a potential mate and must decide between staying with this mate and leaving to explore the rest of the population. To determine an optimal strategy for a given fitness distribution P(\lambda) , we consider the objective function V(\vec{\theta})=\int^{\infty}_{0}{d\lambda P(\lambda)\left[P_{s}(\lambda|\vec{\theta})R(\lambda)+P_{l}(\lambda|\vec{\theta})R_{l}(\vec{\theta})\right]} (2) where P_{s} and P_{l} are staying and leaving probabilities, given the strategy, the fitness value, and the mortality rate, and R_{l} is a reward assigned to the leaving choice. If we consider a Poisson-distributed (and thus memoryless) mortality rate, then we can impose the self-consistency requirement that R_{l}(\vec{\theta})=V(\vec{\theta}) Rearranging, we get V(\vec{\theta})=\frac{\int_{0}^{\infty}P(\lambda)P_{s}(\lambda|\vec{\theta})R(\lambda)d\lambda}{1-\int_{0}^{\infty}P(\lambda)P_{l}(\lambda|\vec{\theta})d\lambda} (3) II.2 Two-Mate Case Consider the case where the agent must choose between two different mates drawn from the same population, whose true fitnesses are \lambda and \lambda^{\star} . Each time the agent makes a leaving decision, it switches which mate it is observing. When the agent decides to leave a partner, it updates its prior on its fitness according to the accumulated evidence. We start with the prior p_{0}(\lambda_{0})=f(\alpha_{0}=1,\beta_{0}) on the distribution of fitness in the population, where f(\alpha,\beta) is a gamma distribution with shape \alpha and rate \beta : in other words, we start with an exponential prior. So, if the agent receives n positive signals over an interval of time T before deciding to leave a mate whose original prior was p_{old}=f(\alpha,\beta) , then the update rule for the prior is: p_{new}(\lambda)=\frac{p_{old}(\lambda)p_{old}(x(t)|\lambda)}{p(x(t))}=f(\alpha+n,\beta+T) What becomes of the