Risk-averse optimization under distributional uncertainty with Rockafellian relaxation
Harbir Antil, Alonso J. Bustos, Sean P. Carney, Benjamín Venegas · 2026
Read Risk-averse optimization under distributional uncertainty with Rockafellian relaxation by Harbir Antil, Alonso J. Bustos, Sean P. Carney, Benjamín Venegas (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00226.txt.
Introduction
Antil and three colleagues build a risk-averse optimization plan tough against ambiguity in the true distribution, for problems with differential equations as limits. The plan joins risk metrics with relaxation methods, with stronger convergence results, new existence results, and first-order optimal rules. It assumes no finite-dimensional noise and covers probability spaces of endless dimensions. The plan blends distributionally robust optimization, which aids out-of-sample results, with optimistic optimization, which handles hostile and outlier data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Harbir Antil, Alonso J. Bustos, Sean P. Carney, Benjamín Venegas |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 126498 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00226
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Risk-averse optimization under distributional uncertainty with Rockafellian relaxation Thanks: This work is partially supported by the Office of Naval Research (ONR) under Award NO: N00014-24- 1-2147, the Air Force Office of Scientific Research (AFOSR) under Award NO: FA9550-25-1-0231, NSF grant DMS-2408877, and SURE-AI Centre grant 357482, Research Council of Norway. Harbir Antil, Alonso J. Bustos, Sean P. Carney, Benjamín Venegas Abstract . A framework for risk-averse optimization problems is introduced that is resilient to ambiguities in the true form of the underlying probability distribution. The focus is on problems with partial differential equations (PDEs) as constraints, although the formulation is more broadly applicable. The framework is based on combining risk measures with problem relaxation techniques, and it builds off of previous advances for risk-neutral problems. This work advances the existing theory with strengthened Γ \Gamma -convergence results, novel existence results and first-order optimality criteria. In particular, the theoretical approach naturally accommodates infinite-dimensional probability spaces; no finite-dimensional noise assumption is needed. The framework blends aspects of both distributionally robust optimization (DRO) and distributionally optimistic optimization (DOO) approaches. The DRO aspect facilitates strong out-of-sample performance, while the DOO aspect takes care of adversarial and outlier data, as illustrated with numerical examples. 1. Introduction In a wide variety of applications in financial planning, operations management, engineering design, and statistical modeling, it is critical to account for uncertainty in a conservative, risk-averse manner. Risk measures are a well-established tool in stochastic optimization to arrive at decisions that minimize exposure to exceptionally poor outcomes [ 55 ] . Given a random variable \xi defined on a probability space (\Xi,{\mathcal{A}},\mathbb{P}) , 1\leq p\leq\infty , and a coherent risk measure [ 56 , Section 6.3] {\mathcal{R}}:L^{p}(\Xi,{\mathcal{A}},\mathbb{P})\to\mathbf{R} , a typical risk-averse stochastic program can be written in the form (1.1) \min_{z\in{\rm Z}_{\mathrm{ad}}}\mathcal{R}[f(\xi,z)]. Here the deterministic control variable z belongs to an admissible subset {\rm Z}_{\mathrm{ad}} of some Banach space Z , and f:\Xi\times Z\to\mathbf{R} is integrable for each z\in Z . In practice, the precise form of the uncertainty itself is often unsettled; i.e. the sample space \Xi and probability measure \mathbb{P} are themselves uncertain. The assumed probability distribution might not accurately reflect the true variability, or extreme outcomes may appear outside the nominal support of the distribution. These inaccuracies could arise from measurement error or adversarial corruption, for example. Ignoring these possibilities can lead to optimization solutions that perform poorly under real-world conditions, particularly in the risk-averse setting [ 35 ] . A common approach to account for such meta-uncertainty is to consider distributionally robust optimization (DRO) formulations, where one minimizes an expected value over a collection \{\mathbb{P}_{i}\}_{i\in{\mathcal{I}}} of plausible measures, which is termed the ambiguity set. In risk-averse approaches, worst-case scenarios are considered, which yields a minimax problem (1.2) \min_{z\in{\rm Z}_{\mathrm{ad}}}\sup_{i\in{\mathcal{I}}}\int_{\Xi}f(\xi,z)d\mathbb{P}_{i}. The literature on DRO is quite vast; we refer to the reviews [ 11 , 45 , 46 , 39 ] and references therein. It is well known that minimizing a coherent measure of risk {\mathcal{R}} is itself an example of a distributionally robust optimization problem. For example, if one takes {\mathcal{R}}=\operatorname{CVaR}_{\beta} , i.e. the Conditional Value-at-Risk at level \beta\in(0,1) [ 50 , 49 ] , then ( 1.1 ) becomes (1.3) \min_{z\in{\rm Z}_{\mathrm{ad}}}\operatorname{CVaR}_{\beta}(f(\xi,z))=\min_{z\in{\rm Z}_{\mathrm{ad}}}\inf_{\gamma\in\mathbf{R}}\Big(\gamma+\frac{1}{1-\beta}\int_{\Xi}(f(\xi,z)-\gamma)_{+}\,d\mathbb{P}\Big). By the Fenchel-Moreau theorem [ 8 , Theorem 9.3.5] , ( 1.3 ) is equivalent to (1.4) \min_{z\in{\rm Z}_{\mathrm{ad}}}\sup_{\theta\in\Theta_{\beta}}\int_{\Xi}\theta(\xi)f(\xi,z)\,d\mathbb{P}, where the so-called risk envelope \Theta_{\beta}=\Big\{\vartheta\in L^{\infty}(\Xi,{\mathcal{A}},\mathbb{P})\,\Big|\,\int_{\Xi}\vartheta(\xi)\,d\mathbb{P}=1,\,0\leq\vartheta\leq(1-\beta)^{-1}\,\mathbb{P}\text{ a.s.}\Big\} plays the role of the ambiguity set. For more general coherent risk measures, an analogous result can be found in [ 56 , Theorem 6.7] . In the context of statistical estimation, DRO is known to exhibit strong out-of-sample performance; it allows one to hedge against common issues such as overfitting and “distributional shifts”—deviations between the distributions observed in the model training and model deployment environments. We refer to the comprehensive discussion in [ 14 ] for more details. On the other hand, DRO can be ill-suited for problems with contaminated or outlier data. At scenarios \xi that cause the function f(\xi,z) to be exceptionally large (or possibly unbounded) at certain control values z (termed “endogenous” outliers by Jiang and Xie [ 31 ] ) the DRO approach necessarily leads to higher objective function values, owing to the supremum in ( 1.2 ). An alternative approach for problems with data corruption is distributionally optimistic optimization (DOO). Generally speaking, DOO seeks best-case scenarios, for example, by replacing the supremum in ( 1.2 ) with an infimum. Although the literature is not as vast as for DRO, optimistic approaches are also well-studied; see [ 12 , 27 , 1 , 24 ] , for example. They are also closely connected to techniques from robust statistics [ 29 , 40 ] , such as using a trimmed loss [ 6 ] , as recently pointed out by the authors in [ 31 ] and [ 15 ] . This connection can help explain the success of these approaches in the presence of outlier data. The work in [ 3 ] was the first example of an optimistic approach to stochastic optimization problems with partial differential equations (PDEs) as constraints. An interesting and relatively unexplored approach to stochastic optimization is to combine DOO with DRO to simultaneously improve both resilience to corrupted data and out-of-sample performance. A recent example is from [ 31 ] , who proposed combining a “favorable \operatorname{CVaR}_{\beta} ” with a DRO approach based on measuring ambiguity sets with the Wasserstein \infty -distance. Similar approaches can be found in [ 44 , 42 , 58 , 15 ] . Distributionally robust chance constrained programs [ 26 , 19 , 57 ] can also be classified in this way. The current work presents a novel approach to combining robust and optimistic frameworks. The approach is based on employing both risk measures and Rockafellian relaxation techniques. Although the framework is more general, our focus is on problems that are constrained by PDEs. In this setting, the generic stochastic optimization problem ( 1.1 ) is modified to include the composition of a (random-valued) control-to-state map s(\xi,z) with a quantity-of-interest map g , as well as an additional control penalty term. In particular, this work uses the coherent risk measure {\mathcal{R}}=\operatorname{CVaR}_{\beta} (Eq. ( 1.3 )), which originated in financial mathematics and portfolio optimization [ 50 , 49 ] . The authors in [ 34 ] were the first to use {\mathcal{R}}=\operatorname{CVaR}_{\beta} in the context of PDE constrained optimization (PDECO). Analysis and optimization algorithms can be found in [ 36 ] and [ 37 , 22 , 10 ] , respectively. Risk measures for PDECO have also been used in conjunction with reduced order models [ 61 , 28 ] and tensor-train decompositions [ 4 ] . Application areas include building and shape design [ 33 , 16 , 32 ] , noise reduction [ 61 ] , and digital twins [ 2 ] . These lists are far from exhaustive, however, and risk-averse PDECO is a continually evolving field. Rockafellian relaxation is an optimistic approach to stochastic optimization based on ideas originating in [ 47 , 48 ] . Rather than replacing the supremum in ( 1.2 ) with an infimum (or suitable reformulation thereof), the approach seeks best-case scenarios by not only optimizing over the control variable