Pupil Design for Computational Wavefront Estimation

Ali Almuallem, Nicholas Chimitt, Bole Ma, Qi Guo, Stanley H. Chan · 2026

Read Pupil Design for Computational Wavefront Estimation by Ali Almuallem, Nicholas Chimitt, Bole Ma, Qi Guo, Stanley H. Chan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00225.txt.

Introduction

Almuallem and four colleagues propose an asymmetry score for pupil design, linking imaged intensity to the inbound wavefront. Earlier work showed that breaking pupil symmetries allows wavefront recovery from one image, but gave little guidance on making better pupils. Their study shows that greater asymmetry improves recoverability. They also map trade-offs in pupil design, including light throughput under noise, backed by large simulations and bench experiments.

Catalog record

CREATORAli Almuallem, Nicholas Chimitt, Bole Ma, Qi Guo, Stanley H. Chan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39282
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00225

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pupil Design for Computational Wavefront Estimation Ali Almuallem, Nicholas Chimitt, Bole Ma, Qi Guo, Stanley H. Chan Abstract Establishing a precise connection between imaged intensity and the incident wavefront is essential for emerging applications in adaptive optics, holography, computational microscopy, and non-line-of-sight imaging. While prior work has shown that breaking symmetries in pupil design enables wavefront recovery from a single intensity measurement, there is little guidance on how to design a pupil that improves wavefront estimation. In this work we introduce a quantitative asymmetry metric to bridge this gap and, through an extensive empirical study and supporting analysis, demonstrate that increasing asymmetry enhances wavefront recoverability. We analyze the trade-offs in pupil design, and the impact on light throughput along with performance in noise. Both large-scale simulations and optical bench experiments are carried out to support our findings. 1 Introduction As computer vision increasingly integrates with wave-optics-based systems, a precise connection between imaged intensity and the incident wavefront becomes necessary. Many modern applications, such as holographic displays [ 23 , 5 ] , computational microscopy [ 50 ] , adaptive optics [ 26 ] , ptychographic methods [ 51 , 44 ] , and non-line-of-sight imaging [ 28 , 37 ] rely on image formation models that incorporate the wave behavior of light. However, conventional sensors only capture intensity, losing critical phase information. Recovering the lost phase information is fundamental to the success of computer vision systems in these domains that go beyond purely intensity-based models [ 43 ] . The central challenge in this domain is the recovery of a complex wavefront from its Fourier magnitude, known as Fourier phase retrieval [ 13 , 9 ] . Historically, solutions to this ill-posed problem include strong priors for specialized domains, multiple measurements by optical methods [ 17 , 11 ] , or specialized optical hardware such as lenslet arrays [ 45 ] . The fundamental bottleneck for machine learning remains the lack of uniqueness given a single intensity measurement. As a result, any learning-based solution would require a similarly complicated optical design or modeling, making the problem highly specialized. Figure 1 : Our work investigates the role of pupil design in wavefront estimation, proposes an asymmetry metric to gauge pupil performance, and provides thorough empirical evidence to support our findings. It directly impacts fields like adaptive optics and microscopy, where accurate wavefront estimation is crucial. Recently, it was shown that machine learning can recover a wavefront from a single intensity measurement by symmetry breaking in camera pupil design [ 8 ] . This is possible for problems related to adaptive optics, microscopy, and other imaging problems where the pupil may be modified to be asymmetric, similar to coded apertures that have been used in numerous computer vision applications [ 27 , 2 , 1 ] . However, despite this theoretical guarantee, it does not offer guidance on how to design the pupil. In this work, we provide an extensive empirical study aimed at addressing the trade-off in pupil design for wavefront recovery and analyze the performance in the presence of noise. We illustrate the context of this paper in Figure 1 and summarize our contributions as follows: 1. Problem definition. We define the pupil design problem and introduce an asymmetry metric to characterize a pupil’s capacity to resolve ambiguities. This metric serves as the basis of both analytic and empirical results. 2. Empirical study of design. We study the impact of asymmetry by utilizing a dataset of 7500 pupils and 6000 phase aberrations, along with two baseline networks to understand the gap in training and testing performance across network architectures. 3. Real experiments. We offer prototype-level real experiments that support the findings of our simulations. 2 Related Work Phase retrieval is concerned with the recovery of a vector \mathbf{x}\in\mathbb{C}^{N} from a measurement \absolutevalue{\mA\vx}^{2} . When \mathbf{A}\in\mathbb{C}^{N\times N} is the discrete Fourier transform matrix, the problem is Fourier phase retrieval [ 13 , 12 , 25 ] . Although oversampling can help alleviate issues in uniqueness [ 21 , 22 ] , there remain ambiguities that can not be eliminated by sampling alone. Wavefront estimation requires eliminating some of these ambiguities [ 8 ] . Because of the similarity of these two problems, we discuss them both to comment on their domains of application and differences. Phase retrieval Phase retrieval has been studied for many decades [ 41 , 16 , 13 , 21 , 25 , 9 ] and arises in a number of problems such as crystallography [ 34 , 42 ] , holography [ 23 ] , and Fourier ptychography [ 51 , 44 ] . Long-standing non-convex algorithms such as the Gerchberg-Saxton [ 16 ] and Hybrid Input-Output [ 13 ] are still popular today, while alternatives [ 3 , 29 , 39 ] are designed for random coded measurements. More recently, phase retrieval algorithms have been developed using machine learning techniques. These range from iterative techniques [ 33 ] , better initializations [ 38 ] , and having an added reference signal to overcome ambiguous solutions [ 24 ] . Dataset preprocessing has also been shown to help overcome issues related to non-uniqueness [ 30 , 49 ] . For generic phase retrieval problems and machine learning solutions, we refer the interested reader to Wang et al. [ 46 ] for a thorough review. Wavefront estimation Wavefront estimation is critical for adaptive optics for imaging through scattering [ 45 , 6 ] , calibration [ 15 , 14 ] , and microscopy with many methods using multiple diverse measurements [ 18 , 17 ] . More recently, neural representations have been shown to be a viable alternative, enabling new capabilities such as passive wavefront estimation and correction [ 11 , 48 ] . All methods described here require multiple measurements. For real-time applications such as adaptive optics, hardware solutions are often utilized [ 45 ] . Examples of hardware solutions range from Shack-Hartmann sensors, pyramid wavefront sensors, and interferometric methods [ 47 ] . While oftentimes the optical hardware increases in complexity, the measurements avoid the need to solve the Fourier phase retrieval problem. Recent single measurement methods have high potential to impact real-time applications and inverse problems. Pre-conditioning optics [ 35 ] is one example, though asymmetry in support pupils has long been known to improve recovery [ 4 , 31 ] . Recently, it was shown to enable a unique solution for the wavefront estimation problem [ 8 , 7 ] , though there is little understanding of how to define asymmetry for this problem or how best to design an asymmetric pupil. 3 Pupil Design for Wavefront Estimation This section is aimed at defining the pupil design problem, how we measure the amount of asymmetry present in a pupil, and providing analytic results that support our later empirical findings. 3.1 Problem definition The point spread function (PSF) of an imaging system with a pupil support \mathbf{P}\in\mathbb{R}^{N\times N} represented as a diagonal matrix and incident wave \mathbf{x} is defined as [ 19 ] \mathbf{y}=\absolutevalue{\mF\mP\vx}^{2}+\mathbf{n}, (1) where \mathbf{F} is the Fourier transform matrix, \mathbf{n}\sim\mathcal{N}(\mathbf{0},\sigma^{2}\mathbf{I}) and \absolutevalue{\cdot} denotes the elementwise absolute value of a vector. The recovery of \mathbf{P}\mathbf{x} from \mathbf{y} is non-unique; although oversampling can eliminate

Read the complete text