Predictions of the LSST Solar System (non-)Yield
Joseph Murtagh, Ian Chow · 2026
Read Predictions of the LSST Solar System (non-)Yield by Joseph Murtagh, Ian Chow (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00206.txt.
Introduction
Murtagh and Chow predict which solar system objects the Rubin survey will miss over ten years. Using synthetic populations and the Sorcha simulator, they sort misses by failure mode: geometric, photometric, kinematic, temporal, and computational. Cases include downtime-only bright objects, chip-gap losses, and arcs expiring before linking jobs leave the queue. The paper also treats the Death Star, at most 27.5 astronomical units out, whose absence reads as confirmation of its Endor destruction. It warns that missing the Sun should alarm the community about cataloguing by mass.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joseph Murtagh, Ian Chow |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21695 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00206
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Predictions of the LSST Solar System (non-)Yield Joseph Murtagh, Ian Chow Abstract We present predictions for solar system objects the Vera C. Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) will not detect over its ten-year baseline survey. Employing state-of-the-art synthetic population models and the Sorcha survey simulator, we identify non-yield populations spanning geometric, photometric, kinematic, temporal, and computational failure modes. Notable subpopulations include objects whose peak brightness coincides exclusively with scheduled telescope downtime, objects whose detections fall within Rubin focal plane chip gaps, and objects whose orbital arcs expire before linking jobs are dispatched from the compute queue. We additionally characterise the non-yield arising from the Death Star (DS-1; D ≈ 160 D\approx 160 km), whose orbital mechanics (when constrained by the well-established Endor engagement geometry ( 10 ) ) place it at a maximum heliocentric distance of 27.5 27.5 au and an apparent magnitude of m r ≈ 19 m_{r}\approx 19 -23, squarely within the LSST operational photometric window. Its absence from the LSST alert stream is interpreted as confirmation of its destruction at the Battle of Endor. The failure to detect the Sun within the LSST should be a stark warning to the community of the LSST’s inability to catalogue the solar system (by mass). show][email protected] I Introduction The Vera C. Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time ( 5 , LSST;) represents the most ambitious wide-field optical all-sky survey of the solar system yet attempted. Over a ten-year baseline, the 8.4m Simonyi Survey Telescope will image approximately 18,000 deg 2 of southern sky to a single-visit depth of m_{r}\sim 24.5 , generating an expected catalogue of \gtrsim 1 solar system object(s) from near-Earth asteroids to trans-Neptunian objects ( 6 ) . The community has invested considerable effort in predicting what the LSST will find ( 3 ; 8 ; 14 ; 13 ; 2 , e.g.) . The present work takes a complementary view. We argue that the non-yield — that is, the population of objects the LSST will definitively not detect — is an equally important and considerably under-characterised survey product. A complete census of the solar system requires knowledge not only of what a survey finds, but of what it cannot find, and why. This framing is not without precedent. Survey completeness analyses routinely quantify objects missed due to geometric, photometric, and temporal biases ( 17 , e.g.) . We consider these obvious, and instead extend this tradition by investigating failure modes that have received comparatively little attention: failures arising from the unique orbit configurations, compute cluster scheduling policy, relativistic constraints on the orbital velocity of a spherical weapons platform, and the fundamental orientation of the telescope relative to the nearest star. Throughout this work we assume a standard flat \Lambda CDM cosmology, which has no bearing on any result but is the kind of thing one writes in an introduction. II Survey Description and Detection Framework Moving object detection is performed through the Solar System Processing (SSP) pipeline, which differences image pairs separated in time and constructs tracklets from this data. An object is considered “detected” once it is linked into a valid orbit and reported to the Minor Planet Center (MPC). The effective photometric window is approximately 16\lesssim m_{r}\lesssim 24.5 , set by saturation, detection limits, and whether the object happens to be observed at the right time. Objects outside this range are treated as non-yield. Observations of any of our synthetic populations are definitely really totally simulated using the survey simulator Sorcha ( 11 ) with the v5.0.0 cadence simulation from the SCOC 2024 baseline. III The Non-Yield Catalogue We present the non-yield catalogue of detections N in order of increasing abstraction. Table 1 summarises all populations and their estimated non-yields. III.1 Geometric Non-Yield III.1.1 The Counter-Earth Population (L3) The Sun-Earth Lagrange point L3 lies along the Sun-Earth line at 1 au, diametrically opposite to Earth. 16 predicted a body at this location as shown in Figure 1 , which he termed the Antichthon (counter-Earth), on the grounds that ten celestial bodies was a more satisfying number than nine. This prediction went observationally untested for approximately 2,400 years, until the separation of NASA’s STEREO spacecraft from Earth provided a direct view of the L3 region during the early phase of the mission ( 7 ) . No body was found. The Antichthon hypothesis has been falsified. The LSST will (probably) not change this conclusion. The LSST cannot observe L3 directly, as it lies permanently behind the Sun as seen from Cerro Pachón (and most other ground locations). Objects genuinely displaced to L3 would drift into geometrically accessible sky on the Lyapunov instability timescale of \tau_{\rm L3}\sim 10^{2}-10^{3} yr ( 12 ) , driven primarily by perturbations dynamics of the Sun-Earth three-body problem ( 9 ) . This timescale exceeds the ten-year survey baseline, so objects at or near L3 today remain unobservable throughout the mission. The non-yield is N_{\rm Antichthon}=0\pm 0 , drawn from a population we already know does not exist. Figure 1: Orbit configuration of Antichthon as we like to believe Philolaus mind-mapped it. Earth (or, Terra) is on the right, whilst Antichthon is on the left, or counter to Earth. Both orbit anticlockwise around the Sun at the centre. Red lines denote the Lagrange points of the Earth(Terra)-Sun system. Of course, this renders Antichthon unobservable at any stage of Earth’s orbit. III.1.2 The Sun The Sun is an object within the solar system and so is therefore, definitionally speaking, a solar system object. We address its detectability here. The Sun has an absolute magnitude M\approx-26.7 , exceeding the LSST bright limit by approximately 43 magnitudes — the largest margin by which any solar system object fails to fall within the survey’s operational photometric window. In this sense, the Sun’s non-yield of N_{\mathrm{Sun}}=0\pm 0 is the most extreme non-detection in the catalogue. The heliocentric orbital elements of the Sun present an additional complication. The semi-major axis is zero by definition, the eccentricity is undefined, and all angular elements are degenerate. The Sun cannot be submitted to the MPC as a minor planet (not for lack of the authors’ attempts). This is not a pipeline limitation but an ontological one, and we do not expect it to be resolved in the forthcoming data releases. Detection efficiency at r_{\mathrm{H}}=0 au is \epsilon=0.000\pm 0.000 . Efficiency formally rises for r_{\mathrm{H}}>0 au, which may be of interest to stellar astronomers but is outside the scope of this survey. We ran the numbers and burnt a few CPU hours to compute that the LSST would need to be pointed directly at the Sun to resolve this non-detection. This option was never considered even briefly, and has been rejected. 1 1 1 The telescope is worth \gtrsim\$800 million. The Sun constitutes 99.86% of the total mass of the solar system. The LSST catalogue will contain 0.000% of the Sun. On these grounds alone, LSST’s coverage of the solar system is incomplete at a level that should concern any referee, and the LSST Solar System Science Collaboration should address it. III.2 Photometric Non-Yield III.2.1 Bright-Limit Exceedance The LSST detector saturates at approximately m_{r}\sim 16 . The distinction between “a very active comet” and “something