Searching for unresolved massive black hole pairs through AGN photometric variability

Lorenzo Bertassi ,, Maria Charisi, Fabio Rigamonti, Stefano Covino, Massimo Dotti · 2026

Read Searching for unresolved massive black hole pairs through AGN photometric variability by Lorenzo Bertassi ,, Maria Charisi, Fabio Rigamonti, Stefano Covino, Massimo Dotti (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-00101.txt.

Introduction

Bertassi and four colleagues test whether active-galaxy light curves hide two massive black holes rather than one. They compare a single damped random walk against a pair of independent ones in a Bayesian analysis. Mock trials keep false alarms below 1 percent for both even and uneven sampling, though full parameter recovery stays modest. Pairs become identifiable when their noise timescales differ sharply, with a ratio below one fifth, while their variability amplitudes stay comparable, with a ratio above one fifth.

Catalog record

CREATORLorenzo Bertassi ,, Maria Charisi, Fabio Rigamonti, Stefano Covino, Massimo Dotti
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52993
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.00101

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Searching for unresolved massive black hole pairs through AGN photometric variability Lorenzo Bertassi ,, Maria Charisi, Fabio Rigamonti, Stefano Covino, Massimo Dotti Abstract Since their discovery, active galactic nuclei light curves are known to be intrinsically variable. In the optical/UV band, this variability is consistent with correlated or red noise and is particularly well described by the damped random walk model. In this work, we evaluate the feasibility of a new method for identifying spatially unresolved couples of active galactic nuclei through a fully Bayesian time-domain analysis of the observed light curves. More specifically, we check whether observed light curves are better described by a single DRW, which we interpret as emitted by a single massive black hole, or a pair of independent damped random walks, generated by a pair of massive black holes. We test the method on mock light curves associated with single massive black holes and pairs generated with different cadences and lengths of observational campaigns. We constrained the occurrence of false positives, that is, the percentage of single MBH light curves that show substantial evidence in favour of the unresolved MBH pair scenario, finding a fraction of 0.2 % 0.2\% and 0.59 % 0.59\% in the even and uneven sampling scenarios. We discuss how well the method recovers the model parameters, showing that about 51 % 51\% and 7 % 7\% of the simulated light curves have all the recovered parameters within 20 % 20\% of their true values in our best scenario of evenly sampled light curves for the single massive black hole and massive black hole pair scenarios, respectively. We finally study the region of the parameter space in which the detection of a massive black hole pair is possible, finding that such objects can be correctly identified if the timescales of the process describing the noise are very different, with a ratio smaller than ∼ 0.2 \sim 0.2 , and the variability amplitudes are similar, with their ratio bigger than ∼ 0.2 \sim 0.2 . When limiting to such a region of the parameter space, the fraction of pairs with all the recovered parameters within 20 % 20\% of the injected values increases up to about 14 % 14\% and 8 % 8\% for evenly and unevenly sampled light curves, respectively. 1 Introduction In the hierarchical model of galaxy formation, smaller galaxies merge to form the larger present-day galaxies ( 102 ) . As nearly all massive galaxies are expected to host a massive black hole (MBH) at their centre ( 55 ) , massive black hole pairs (MBHPs) and, at even smaller separations, massive black hole binaries (MBHBs) are predicted to form in the aftermath of the merger ( 9 ) . In our current view, the two MBHs, still unbound from one another, residing at the centres of the merging galaxies, are expected to drift toward the centre of the newly formed galaxy because of dynamical friction. The dynamical friction efficiency at large MBH separations ( 0.001-10 kpc) is still poorly constrained ( 34 , see) , due to both the possible interaction between the MBHs and galaxy substructures such as spiral arms, bars and stellar or gaseous clumps ( 40 ; 31 ; 85 ; 16 ; 15 , e.g.) and tidal effects. More specifically, tides can significantly increase the pairing timescale by decreasing the mass of the progenitor galaxy cores, 1 1 1 The efficiency of tidal stripping depends on the possible deepening of the potential well of the core, as a consequence of merger driven gas inflows ( 19 , e.g.) . ( 44 ; 68 ; 95 , e.g. ) . Past this stage, the evolution is expected to be driven by three-body scatterings with stars ( 9 ; 64 ) and/or the interaction with the gas surrounding the two MBHs ( 6 ; 46 ) . If the abovementioned processes manage to efficiently remove orbital energy and angular momentum from the two MBHs, the resulting binary, i.e. the system when the two MBHs are gravitationally bound to each other, will coalesce due to gravitational wave emission ( 87 , see) , becoming one of the most promising source population to be detected by space-borne interferometers ( 3 , e.g., the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, LISA,) and pulsar timing arrays ( 99 , PTAs, see) . Recently, evidence for a gravitational wave background possibly generated by inspiralling MBHBs has been found in PTA data ( 2 ; 71 ; 106 ; 38 ; 65 , see) . Even though the background is likely generated by MBHBs, the uncertainties in stellar and gas-driven evolution result in a significant scatter in the predicted GW signal (e.g. 94 ; 42 , and references therein) . Stringent EM constraints on MBHPs and MBHBs are needed for a comparison between theory and observation. To date, there are only \sim 100 confirmed observations of MBHPs resolved as dual AGN, see 28 for a review, 108 for a more recent collection of \sim 10 kpc MBHPs, 49 ; 63 ; 80 ; 22 ; 105 ; 21 ; 79 for recent searches of \sim kpc MBHPs and 88 for a candidate with \sim 100 pc separation. A secure identification of spatially unresolved MBH pairs and binaries is challenging. Current searches for unresolved signatures (see 36 , for a review) have focused on close MBHBs where quasi-periodic modulations of the continuum ( 91 ; 1 ; 45 ; 37 ; 58 ; 20 ; 76 ; 77 ; 81 ; 59 ; 60 ; 48 ; 23 ; 109 ; 24 ; 72 ; 12 ) and of the broad emission line (BEL) profile ( 82 ; 89 ; 39 ; 30 ; 75 ; 74 ; 84 ; 73 ; 13 ) are expected to occur on timescales of months to centuries. At large enough separations, the search for photometric and spectroscopic features becomes either impossible (as the underlying assumptions of the models break) or unfeasible (as the required length of the observational campaigns to observe such modulations becomes too long). One exception to this is a test originally proposed by 43 and recently quantitatively detailed by 35 , which assumes that the two MBHs are far enough from each other for their emission (both in the continuum and in the BELs) to be uncorrelated on observational timescales. In this case, different spectral regions of BELs react at two independent continua. This test allows for the identification of pairs and binaries with orbital periods of decades to centuries using reverberation-mapping campaigns lasting \mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\lower 3.0pt\hbox{$\sim$}\hss}\raise 2.0pt\hbox{$<$}}1 yr ( 35 ) , but fails when the separation is so large (e.g. \sim 0.5 pc for a binary of \sim 10^{6}\mathrm{M_{\odot}} ) that the two independent BLRs have a too-small relative shift, due to the small orbital velocity of the binary ( 35 , \mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\lower 3.0pt\hbox{$\sim$}\hss}\raise 2.0pt\hbox{$<$}}100 km/s, see) . In this work, we present a new photometric test for couples of active MBHs (either MBHBs or MBHPs) too widely separated to be identified through continuum periodicity (e.g., with separations \mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\lower 3.0pt\hbox{$\sim$}\hss}\raise 2.0pt\hbox{$>$}}0.001 pc for a binary of \sim 10^{6}\mathrm{M_{\odot}} ), but too close to be spatially resolved. For example, assuming an angular resolution

Read the complete text