“There is literally zero funding”: Understanding the Emerging Role of Trusted Flaggers under the EU Digital Services Act ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 CCS: Applied computing Law CCS: Social and professional topics Governmental regulations CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI

Marie-Therese Sekwenz, Kyle Beadle, Simon Parkin · 2026

Read “There is literally zero funding”: Understanding the Emerging Role of Trusted Flaggers under the EU Digital Services Act ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 CCS: Applied computing Law CCS: Social and professional topics Governmental regulations CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI by Marie-Therese Sekwenz, Kyle Beadle, Simon Parkin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-29874.txt.

Introduction

Sekwenz, Beadle, and Parkin study Trusted Flaggers under the EU Digital Services Act. These accredited groups spot and report illegal content to platforms. The role was about a year old at study time. The team interviewed seven flagger groups and ran a joint workshop. Accreditation proves cumbersome, they find. Workloads grow while resources stay flat. Platform priorities often clash with flagger goals. They urge more study of user representation and better standards.

Catalog record

CREATORMarie-Therese Sekwenz, Kyle Beadle, Simon Parkin
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63470
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY SA
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.29874

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

“There is literally zero funding”: Understanding the Emerging Role of Trusted Flaggers under the EU Digital Services Act ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 CCS: Applied computing Law CCS: Social and professional topics Governmental regulations CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI Marie-Therese Sekwenz, Kyle Beadle, Simon Parkin Abstract . The European Union’s Digital Services Act (DSA) introduced regulatory mechanisms which serve as a way to manage harmful content online. The recognition of Trusted Flaggers (TFs) is one such mechanism which accredits entities with experience, platform independence, and skill in identifying and reporting illegal content. With the DSA’s TF role being roughly one year old, we interviewed representatives of seven such TF organizations to learn about their experiences of becoming a TF and how it impacts their interactions with online platforms and with individual users. We additionally ran a workshop involving TF representatives, primarily as it was requested by TFs themselves, who collectively wanted to share experiences of their new role and learn from each other rather than be isolated. Notably, we found that accreditation as a TF can be cumbersome, that resources for TFs remain the same despite an increasing workload, and that platforms priorities often diverge from TFs. We conclude with recommendations for future research into understanding user representation within the DSA and the need for standardization measures tailored to the needs and resource constraints of TFs. 1. Introduction Online platforms are a central component of today’s interaction between individuals, whether it is to communicate ( 58 ) , find information ( 33 ) , shop ( 65 ) , or just be entertained ( 70 ) . However, these online spaces pose different risks to users – one of which is illegal content online. To have a regulatory answer to this and many other risks the EU has created the Digital Services Act (DSA) ( 49 ) . This novel regulation forms obligations for transparency, assessment, reporting, and design for online platforms like Instagram, TikTok, X, or Pornhub, as well as for search engines (See Art 33 DSA ( 13 ) ). Other countries are also pursuing comparable approaches to regulating online platforms and their processes for responding to harmful content, like the UK ( 39 ) , India ( 29 ) , or i.e. in the US specific rules in Florida ( 55 ) and Texas ( 61 ) . The DSA includes transparency obligations (Arts. 15, 24, 42, 17, 39 DSA), systemic risk assessment and mitigation (Arts. 34-35 DSA), independent audit structures (Art. 37 DSA), or new user facing redress mechanisms (Arts. 20-21). The DSA also creates Trusted Flaggers (TF) as a role to patrol the online space and identify illegal content online (Art. 3(h) DSA) that has eluded the prior moderation process (Art. 22 DSA). A TF is accredited status by the DSA’s national regulators. 1 1 1 Digital Service Coordinators according to Art. 22(2)DSA. Online platforms must prioritize TF reporting of illegal content over normal user flagging (Rec. 61). It remains unclear what the challenges are for organizations and individuals that pursue TF accreditation, and how their relationships with regulated platforms develop. This is especially the case given that the TF role as a mechanism is only a matter of months old at the time of writing ( 15 ) . Expectations of TF organizations within the DSA are not yet well-understood and pose a research gap ( 54 ) due to the novelty and legal complexity of the work. We aim to understand how accredited TFs perceive their role in reporting content and engaging with the platforms hosting content, as a new experience beyond the mechanisms previously available to them, such as Google’s Priority Flagger program ( 23 ) . We also contrast the capabilities and requirements of the TF role with the perception of regulatory activities within the role, and the extent to which the role enables them to achieve their goals in monitoring illegal content online. With this, our overarching Research Question (RQ) asks: How do Trusted Flaggers enact the Article 22 DSA mechanism in practice, and what frictions and accountability implications arise from this for user representation? Our Research Questions (RQs) are: RQ1: What have been Trusted Flaggers’ (TFs) experiences in becoming and acting as a TF, particularly in comparison to their activities before obtaining TF accreditation? RQ2: What gaps emerge between the capabilities the DSA assigns to Trusted Flaggers (TFs) and the resources, tooling, procedural support, and public visibility? RQ3: How do Trusted Flaggers’ (TF) experiences reveal differences in how platforms operationalize and prioritize DSA content reporting obligations, what are key challenges for TFs, and how are these practices reflected in DSA transparency and accountability artifacts (e.g., transparency reports and Statements of Reasons)? The paper is structured as follows: Section 2 outlines the Trusted Flagger mechanism under the DSA and its relationship to notice-and-action and transparency obligations. Section 3 reviews related work. Section 4 describes our methods. Section 5 reports the findings. Section 6 discusses implications and recommendations for DSA implementation and accountability. Section 7 concludes the paper. 2. Background Article 22 DSA introduces a “fast-lane” for illegal content (Art. 3(h) DSA) notices (Art. 16 DSA) submitted through content reporting interfaces by a Trusted Flagger (TF) (Art. 22 DSA) ( 51 ) . TFs are positioned as an institutional response to illegal content that harms users (like CSAM content or disinformation). Through their mandate-bound flagging activity, TFs operationalize specialized expertise in the identification and substantiation of presumed illegal content, in a way which overcomes the challenges in reporting content which non-experts would face, in terms of collecting evidence and understanding the law ( 54 ) . TF status (accreditation) is granted by national regulatory authorities of the DSA – the Digital Services Coordinators (DSCs) (Art. 22 (4), (7-8), 49-51) – for a designated area of expertise (within a specific mandate of illegal content). This status is conditioned on demonstrable competence, independence from platforms, and diligent, accurate, and objective flagging (Art. 22(2)). The status as a TF can be suspended and revoked by DSCs in cases where notices are imprecise, inaccurate, or inadequately substantiated (Arts. 16, 20, 22(6)-(7)) ( 2 ) . The DSA also embeds transparency and accountability requirements through annual public reporting (TF reports) and regulator-facing disclosures (Art. 22(3)). The DSA links TF reporting activity to platform transparency reporting (Arts. 15(1)(b)) and statements of reasons (Art. 17(3)(b), 22(3)-(5)), as well as in systemic risk mitigation measures (Art. 35(1)(g) ( 53 ; 32 ) . For the FAccT research community, TFs offer a concrete case of how regulation reshapes content moderation practice. TF designation introduces procedural prioritization (Rec. 61–62) that structures the timing of platform decisions, an aspect with normative consequences for affected parties beyond efficiency considerations ( 57 ) . TFs also change the evidentiary and substantive quality of notices by adding external expert reporting. Finally, TFs foreground questions of representation and accountability (Art. 86), because particular organizations are empowered to escalate certain harms and illegality claims within platform processes. These interactions can produce new dynamics for the actors involved and point to open questions about how best practices should be developed and institutionalized. 3. Related Work Flagging as content moderation measure Content reporting under the DSA (or, flagging ( 16

Read the complete text