Urban mobility enables deprivation bubble breaking in Indian and Mexican cities

Yuan Liao, Federico Delussu, Sílvia de Sojo, Laura Alessandretti, Antonio Desiderio · 2026

Read Urban mobility enables deprivation bubble breaking in Indian and Mexican cities by Yuan Liao, Federico Delussu, Sílvia de Sojo, Laura Alessandretti, Antonio Desiderio (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-29782.txt.

Introduction

Liao and co-authors measure how daily travel lets poor city residents reach better-off areas. Static home-based scores miss this part of spatial inequality. They join phone mobility data with satellite deprivation scores for 64 cities in India and Mexico. Residents of deprived areas travel to richer places more than gravity models predict. Local amenity variety keeps needs local, they find. But dense, well-linked areas push more trips across class lines.

Catalog record

CREATORYuan Liao, Federico Delussu, Sílvia de Sojo, Laura Alessandretti, Antonio Desiderio
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59010
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY SA
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.29782

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Urban mobility enables deprivation bubble breaking in Indian and Mexican cities Yuan Liao, Federico Delussu, Sílvia de Sojo, Laura Alessandretti, Antonio Desiderio Abstract Urban deprivation is traditionally measured using static, residence-based indicators, capturing the socioeconomic, demographic, and spatial conditions of neighborhoods. However, this approach overlooks how daily movement allows residents to navigate the city, potentially exposing them to opportunities that differ significantly from their residential environments. To bridge this gap, we quantify the extent of bubble breaking – travel to less deprived areas – by analyzing mobile phone mobility networks combined with satellite-derived deprivation indices across 64 cities in India and Mexico. We find that residents of deprived areas systematically travel to better-off locations to meet daily needs, exhibiting a compensatory mobility pattern that significantly exceeds expectations derived from gravity models based on population and road networks. This residual bubble breaking (the part gravity models can not explain) is associated with a tension in the built environment: while high local amenity diversity allows residents to satisfy needs locally, high amenity density and positive spillovers from neighboring areas is associated with movement across socioeconomic boundaries. Overall, residual bubble breaking reflects the extent to which residents rely on cross-neighborhood mobility to overcome local amenity deficits, a dimension of spatial inequality that residence-based measures leave unobserved. keywords urban mobility, mobile phone data, social exposure, built environment, satellite-derived deprivation Introduction Urban deprivation tends to concentrate into spatial and socioeconomic “bubbles” – geographically bounded neighbourhoods with persistently low access to economic and social opportunities [ 1 , 2 ] . This pattern is particularly pronounced in low- and middle-income countries, where poverty, limited access to services, discrimination, and institutional barriers give rise to spatially and socially segregated pockets such as slums and informal settlements [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . These “bubbles” are commonly understood as spatial deprivation traps : daily life is assumed to be confined to the immediate area, with residents relying on locally based informal work and facing mobility constraints [ 7 ] . These constraints are thought to limit access to broader employment opportunities [ 8 ] , public services [ 9 ] , and social infrastructure [ 10 ] . A common interpretation of such deprivation traps is that many such neighbourhoods accumulate structural disadvantages that are difficult to escape. Yet, this interpretation rests almost entirely on static, residence-based data [ 11 ] . Most deprivation research relies on satellite images and other residence-based indicators that show where disadvantage is located but not how residents move through the city in their daily lives [ 12 ] . The characteristics of deprived urban areas have been widely studied in relation to hazard exposure [ 13 ] , health outcomes [ 14 ] , and educational attainment [ 15 ] . However, most deprivation research does not account for how individuals experience different levels of deprivation as they move beyond their residential neighbourhoods [ 12 ] . In contrast, the field of urban segregation and inequalities has increasingly moved beyond residence-based measures toward mobility-based approaches to understand the socioeconomic mixing individuals experience across the spaces they visit [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] . This shift was enabled by the availability of mobile phone data that captures individuals’ movements, with most empirical evidence to date drawn from high-income countries [ 18 ] . Yet deprivation research rarely incorporates mobility data, leaving us without evidence on activity-based deprivation exposure — the levels of deprivation individuals encounter across their daily destinations. Classical theories of urban economics [ 19 , 20 ] and accessibility [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] suggest that jobs and services are concentrated in more advantaged areas, generating structural pressures on residents of deprived neighbourhoods to travel beyond their immediate surroundings to meet their daily activity needs. This motivates the hypothesis that daily mobility systematically shifts individuals’ exposure away from residential deprivation and toward more advantaged urban environments. Testing this hypothesis at scale is especially urgent in low- and middle-income countries, where inequality and deprivation are salient issues affecting large populations [ 24 , 25 ] , but where country-level mobility data have historically been unavailable. Here, we address this gap by testing whether, in highly unequal urban contexts, individuals tend to systematically travel to areas less deprived than their residential neighbourhoods — a pattern we describe using the term ‘bubble breaking’, drawing on prior uses of the phrase in the segregation literature [ 26 ] . We do so using a mobile-phone dataset from 64 cities in India and Mexico, two countries that differ markedly in urban form, infrastructure, and patterns of deprivation. We find consistent evidence that individuals tend to travel to less deprived areas, and that this tendency is stronger than expected under a gravity-based mobility model [ 27 ] that accounts only for population distribution and the road network [ 28 , 29 ] . Additionally, we show that three key features of the urban environment—overall urban form [ 30 , 31 , 32 ] , local neighbourhood opportunities [ 33 , 34 , 35 ] , and mobility-related constraints [ 36 , 37 , 38 ] —help explain variation in the extent of bubble breaking across neighbourhoods and cities. Results To test the bubble-breaking hypothesis at scale, we considered mobility networks capturing travel in India and Mexico. Network nodes represent geographical areas of approximately 5 km^{2} defined using the H3 discrete global grid system [ 39 ] at resolution 7 (see Methods). A directed link between two nodes exists if at least one trip occurs between the corresponding areas, and link weights correspond to the total number of trips generated by individuals on that connection over the period from November 1, 2019, to March 1, 2020. These flows are derived from aggregated smartphone GPS traces provided by Cuebiq as part of the NetMob 2024 Data Challenge [ 40 ] (see “Mobility Network” in the Methods). We identified 64 spatially disjoint clusters of at least 25 contiguous areas where mobility data were available (see “City Boundary” in the Methods for details). Then, we assign multiple attributes to each area to characterize its social and spatial context. First, we quantify socioeconomic deprivation using NASA’s Global Gridded Relative Deprivation Index (GRDI) [ 41 ] . The GRDI ranges from 0 (least deprived) to 100 (most deprived), based on a combination of sociodemographic and satellite-derived indicators, including child dependency ratios, infant mortality rates, subnational human development index, building footprints, and nighttime lights (see “Deprivation” in the Methods section, Fig. 1 a, b, and Supplementary Fig. 1 ). This indicator is globally defined and applied in absolute terms, without normalization to country- or city-specific deprivation distributions; this choice is reflected in the higher overall deprivation levels observed in New Delhi compared to Greater Mexico City (Fig. 1 a, b). Additionally, we describe each area using population density from the Global Human Settlement Layer (GHSL) [ 42 ] and the number and diversity of local amenities derived from Point of Interest (POI) data from Overture Maps [ 43 ] (see the Methods section for more details). Individuals break residential deprivation bubbles We quantify the extent to which individuals break out of their residential deprivation “bubbles” by

Read the complete text