Entanglement in prepare-and-measure scenarios without receiver inputs
Elna Svegborn, Armin Tavakoli · 2026
Read Entanglement in prepare-and-measure scenarios without receiver inputs by Elna Svegborn, Armin Tavakoli (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-29625.txt.
Introduction
Svegborn and Tavakoli study one-way quantum tests where the receiver picks no settings. A quantum edge there needs two things: shared entanglement and measurements that adapt to the message. For classical messages, they find the smallest setup with such an edge. High-dimensional entanglement makes the edge largest. In the next setup up, CHSH-type nonlocality can power the edge. That setup suits certification experiments well. With quantum messages read first, the edge grows larger still. Non-projective read-out proves essential for that gain.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Elna Svegborn, Armin Tavakoli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50387 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.29625
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Entanglement in prepare-and-measure scenarios without receiver inputs Elna Svegborn, Armin Tavakoli Abstract The most elementary prepare-and-measure scenarios have no independent measurement inputs. No inputs mean that quantum advantages require two indispensable ingredients: shared entanglement and measurements that can be adapted to the communicated messages. Understanding these scenarios is therefore conceptually natural, but also practically relevant, since they act as testbeds for black-box certification of adaptive one-way LOCC. Here, we study them systematically and reveal several of their basic features. For classical messages, we first identify the minimal scenario with a quantum advantage and show that it is maximised by high-dimensional entanglement. Then, we identify the next-to-minimal scenario, and show that quantum advantages can be propelled by nonlocality of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt type, which makes this an appropriate setting for certification experiments. Proceeding further, we replace classical messages with quantum messages, but require the receiver to read the message before measuring the entangled particle. We show that this leads to amplified quantum advantages, that are made possible only thanks to non-projective message read-out. This in dispensable role of non-projective measurements challenges the common wisdom that they play a secondary role in revealing the power of quantum correlations in black-box experiments. Introduction— Entanglement is a pivotal resource for communication. Although it cannot by itself transmit information, shared entanglement can boost the ability of communicating parties to perform a distributed computation Cleve and Buhrman 1997 ; Brassard 2001 . These communication complexity advantages are fundamentally tied to Bell nonlocality Brukner et al. 2004 ; Buhrman et al. 2016 ; Tavakoli et al. 2020a . These protocols typically proceed in two steps: first the parties measure their share of the entangled state to obtain correlations that violate a Bell inequality, and then they use these correlations as advice for how to encode and decode classical communication Buhrman et al. 2010 . However, it has been brought to attention that more general use of entanglement is possible, where one party can delay measuring one share of the entangled state until after the other party’s message has arrived, and thereby adapting the measurement to the communication in real time Pauwels et al. 2022a . These adaptive protocols, based on classical feed-forward, have been shown to further boost quantum advantages. The prepare-and-measure (PM) scenario, featuring a sender (Alice) and a receiver (Bob), is the standard setting to study these types of questions. In general, Alice and Bob both hold independent inputs and their job is to probabilistically compute functions of both inputs, while only being allowed limited communication resources. Given the ubiquity of the PM scenario (see the review Brask et al. 2026 ), it is natural to take an interest in their simplest form. In the case, Bob has no independent input, and thus his goal is to learn some property about Alice’s input. In addition to being the most elementary setting, the PM scenarios without measurement inputs are particularly interesting because — in contrast to scenarios where Bob has inputs — they do not admit any quantum advantage by replacing classical messages with quantum messages of the same dimension Frenkel and Weiner 2015 . This means that quantum advantages are impossible unless the parties share entanglement. Moreover, when Bob has no input, the traditional approach to communication complexity, based on first violating a Bell inequality and then communicating classically, will always fail since Bell nonlocality is impossible without measurement inputs Massar and Pironio 2003 . This leads to a crucial observation: every quantum advantage must rely on shared entanglement and measurements that adapt in real time to the communicated messages. In addition to theoretical interest, PM scenarios without independent measurement inputs also have a distinct applied motivation. Because the only quantum advantages are entanglement-based and of adaptive nature, such protocols can be interpreted as black-box certificates of adaptive one-way LOCC, i.e. certifying that an experiment has the capacity to measure one part of a state and use the outcome in real time to inform what operations to perform on the other part of the state. Such feed-forward capability is broadly relevant in quantum technology, for instance in teleportation, quantum networks, quantum algorithms and quantum error correction. The associated tests in the PM scenario are device-independent, modulo the minimal assumption that the alphabet of the classical communication is restricted. However, beyond the fact that they exist Frenkel and Weiner 2022 ; Vieira et al. 2023 ; Alimuddin et al. 2023 ; Rout et al. 2025 , little is known about quantum advantages in PM scenarios without independent receiver inputs. Given their conceptual and practical interest, it is relevant to fill this gap of knowledge. In this work, we systematically reveal their key basic features. We focus on the elementary setting where the communication is one bit and identify the minimal input/output alphabets necessary to make a quantum advantage possible. We find that this minimal scenario admits a simple task-interpretation and derive the optimal protocol based on two-qubit entanglement, which turns out to use non-maximally entangled states. Furthermore, already in this minimial scenario, we find that entanglement of higher-than-qubit dimension is necessary for the maximal quantum advantage. However, in order to pave the way for practical certification of one-way adaptive LOCC, one would ideally seek a test that (i) uses maximally entangled qubits, (ii) has good noise-resilience, and (iii) has input/output alphabets as small as possible. We meet all three desiderata by examining the next-to-minimal scenario, where we show that violations of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) Bell inequality can be linked to quantum advantages in the PM scenario. We then venture further and upgrade the communication from a bit to a qubit. In line with the adaptive nature of the protocol, we require Bob to first read the quantum message and then use the classical read-out to advice his choice of measurement on his entangled particle. We find that in spite of qubit messages alone not offering any advantage over bits Frenkel and Weiner 2015 , using them as advice for which measurements to perform on entangled particles does lead to further advantages. Importantly, this general type of advantage is impossible unless one uses non-projective measurements, thereby giving them a distinct operational relevance in quantum correlations studies. Preliminaries.— Consider the PM scenario where Alice selects an input, x\in\{0,\ldots,|X|-1\} , encodes it into a classical message m\in\{1,\ldots,d\} and sends it to Bob who decodes it into an output b\in\{0,\ldots,|B|-1\} . This leads to a probability distribution p(b|x) . Note that for this to be non-trivial we need d<|X| ; otherwise Alice can just send her input Bob. In this classical approach, Alice and Bob may coordinate their encoding/decoding strategies with a shared random variable, \lambda , subject to some distribution p(\lambda) . Hence, the correlations admit a classical model if they can be written as p(b|x)=\sum_{\lambda,m}p(\lambda)p(m|x,\lambda)p(b|m,\lambda) . The space of classical correlations is geometrically represented as a polytope. Therefore, it can be characterised by inequalities of the form Gallego et al. 2010 \mathcal{S}=\sum_{b,x}c_{bx}p(b|x)\leq\beta, (1) where c_{bx} are some real-valued coefficients and \beta is a tight bound satisfied by all classical models. A quantum advantage means the violation of these inequalities. This requires the parties to share an entangled state, \psi_{AB} , as illustrated in Fig 1 . Alice encodes her