A Lower Bound on the Number of Fundamental Constants
William Luke Matthewson · 2026
Read A Lower Bound on the Number of Fundamental Constants by William Luke Matthewson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-29300.txt.
Introduction
Matthewson sets out a lower bound on the number of fundamental constants. The question is how many constants a complete mathematical description of the physical universe requires. He reports that the bound is described here for the first time. The answer he gives is one. A single constant, on this showing, is the minimum such a description needs. The formal proof is arithmetized and meta-mathematical in form. He leaves that formal proof to the reader.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | William Luke Matthewson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 13832 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.29300
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Lower Bound on the Number of Fundamental Constants William Luke Matthewson Abstract We describe here, for the first time, a lower bound on the total number of fundamental constants required for a mathematical description of our physical universe to be complete. The answer is shown to be one. The formal arithmetized meta-mathematical proof of this is left to the reader. ‘ ACHILLES : This fellow must be playing the fool.’ - from Gödel, Escher, Bach (1999) by Douglas R. Hofstadter [ 8 ] . 1 Some Fundamentals The issue of fundamental constants has been widely discussed in the literature. Given that the purpose of scientific inquiry is to pursue a complete understanding of the nature of reality, by means of some mathematical description, it is reasonable to ask whether there will be some necessary fundamental axioms that must be assumed, the precise details of which are determined simply by the arbitrary happenstance 1 1 1 To quote Lev Okun, ‘The word “arbitrary” here means that a given parameter has acquired its actual value in the process of cosmological evolution of the early universe. It could have with some probability other values as well.’ [ 11 ] of our universe, in order to achieve this description. In order to avoid getting caught up in arguments of a semantic nature, we should clarify here what is meant by a fundamental constant. The general consensus in the literature seems to be that in order to be considered a fundamental constant, a quantity should satisfy various conditions [ 12 , 11 , 3 , 9 ] . Firstly, a fundamental constant is a quantity that cannot be derived from other, more fundamental, constants and which is necessary for a complete description of reality [ 12 ] . On the surface, true fundamental constants are also obliged to be dimensionful. In [ 3 ] the distinction is made between so-called ‘fundamental parameters’ (e.g. the fine-structure constant, \alpha=e^{2}/\hbar c\simeq 1/137 ) which depend on the particular theory and are dimensionless ratios, and dimensionful ‘fundamental units’, like the speed of light, c . Despite this, we can always normalise by the fundamental units to rewrite things in terms of some pure numbers. For example, normalising c\rightarrow 1 makes a velocity, v\rightarrow v/c , seem like just a dimensionless ratio. However, according to at least two of the authors in [ 3 ] , the pure number c^{\prime}=1 still contains necessary information about the structure of reality: When velocities become {\mathcal{O}}(1) (in these units), we can expect dramatic new phenomena to occur [ 3 ] . Thus, it is not quite the dimensionality that is a necessary condition, but rather the characteristic impact of the quantity on the structure and behaviour of our physical reality. In the example of c this corresponds to its role as a universal limit on the velocities of particles. Other dimensionless quantities that are not considered fundamental by our definition are mathematical constants such as \pi or e , etc. These are ideal, abstractly defined quantities, calculable 2 2 2 As opposed to measurable. to arbitrary precision, with values following from our mathematical description, that could in principle exist independently of the current instance of the universe, thus are not deemed fundamental constants. One convenient and compact way to talk about our current framework for understanding reality was proposed by Zelmanov [ 13 , 14 ] , following from works by Gamow, Ivanenko and Landau [ 4 ] , and Bronshtein [ 1 , 2 ] . For much better reviews of the subject material, see [ 7 , 11 , 10 , 6 ] . The system is called the ‘cube of physical theories’ and imagines the space described by three orthogonal axes, each measuring one of the following: the inverse speed of light in a vacuum, 1/c , the gravitational constant, G , and the reduced Planck’s constant, \hbar (see Fig. 1 ). In this depiction, each vertex represents a different potential physical theory, not all of which had then been, or are now, fully described [ 4 , 13 , 14 , 7 , 6 , 11 , 10 ] . For example, the vertex at the origin represents classical, non-relativistic mechanics, while the vertex that lies along the 1/c axis corresponds to special relativity. The final goal in this picture is to develop the theory at (1/c,\,\hbar,\,G) , which would appear to be all-encompassing, and hope that, in so doing, the fundamental parameters be simultaneously determined as as consequence of self-consistency [ 12 , 11 ] . \hbar \frac{1}{c} G Figure 1: Graphical depiction of the cube of physical theories in the space defined by the orthogonal axes of G , 1/c , and \hbar . The question of which fundamental constants are indeed fundamental is still a matter of debate, and the consensus in definition and qualities of the fundamental constants given above is a result of some compromise on this author’s part. As for the actual number, depending on who you ask, and which of the components of the definition one is willing to sacrifice, there are various arguments for variously 3, 2 or 0 fundamental constants, among others [ 3 ] . Clearly, it is a complex issue that has yet to be satisfactorily resolved. Here we are not concerned so much with the absolute number of fundamental constants, because that is too difficult, but rather a lower bound on the number of fundamental constants that it is conceivable to have in our description of reality. The answer is, of course, one, as will be explained in the detailed and incontrovertible arguments set out in the next section. 2 The Least Fundamental We introduce the quantity ㄴ 3 3 3 Pronounced ‘nee-uhn’, this represents the voiced alveolar nasal consonant, similar to English ‘n’, in the Korean hangeul script. which describes the total number of fundamental constants required 4 4 4 The total number of ‘fundamental’ instances required in writing this text, is 62. by our physical reality in order to be described by a self-consistent mathematical framework. With regards to the cube of physical theories, ㄴrefers to the number of axes in this picture, or the dimensions of this space, required for a complete description of our physical reality. In order to determine a lower bound, we start with some basic statements that we believe the sensible reader will consider reasonable. First, it should be clear that ㄴis an integer, since we cannot have partial constituents of a fundamental constant, by definition. Second, we are positive that ㄴcannot be negative, as this does not really have any meaning. Then, by simple examination, we have min( ㄴ) =0 . However, if ㄴwere itself a fundamental constant 5 5 5 As a fundamental constant, ㄴwould be difficult to represent directly as another axis in the scheme of the cube of physical theories, but that is not sufficient grounds for dismissal of this postulate. (something which will be proved unambiguously to the reader in the remainder of the text) then this value would be impossible, since we would know that there is always at least one fundamental constant, ㄴitself, implying that the lower bound is in fact min(