Retrospective Economic Evaluation of Group Testing in the COVID-19 Pandemic
Michael Balzer, Kainat Khowaja, Christiane Fuchs · 2026
Read Retrospective Economic Evaluation of Group Testing in the COVID-19 Pandemic by Michael Balzer, Kainat Khowaja, Christiane Fuchs (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28930.txt.
Introduction
Balzer, Khowaja, and Fuchs build a model to judge the economic cost of group testing in a pandemic. Testing each person alone is often infeasible, so samples are pooled. Standard cost views count only costs and miss income lost to quarantine and workplace disruption. Their model joins test counts at optimized pool sizes with German income data. Monte Carlo tests on COVID-19 show the best algorithm choice changes once income losses count. Direct cost views understate total cost. Shorter quarantine methods win, even if they need more tests.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael Balzer, Kainat Khowaja, Christiane Fuchs |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41714 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28930
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Retrospective Economic Evaluation of Group Testing in the COVID-19 Pandemic Michael Balzer, Kainat Khowaja, Christiane Fuchs Abstract Surveillance of diseases in a pandemic is an important part of public health policy. Diagnostic testing at the individual level is often infeasible due to resource constraints. To circumvent these constraints, group testing can be applied. The economic cost evaluation from the payer’s perspective typically focuses only on deterministic costs which overlooks the substantial economic impact of productivity losses resulting from quarantine and workplace disruptions. The objective of this article is to develop a mathematical model for a retrospective economic evaluation of group testing that incorporates both deterministic costs and income-based economic loss. Group testing algorithms are revisited and simulated at optimized pool sizes to determine the required number of tests. Income data from the German Socio-Economic Panel are integrated into a mathematical model to capture the economic loss. Afterward, hybrid Monte Carlo experiments are conducted by evaluating the economic cost in the Coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic in Germany. Monte Carlo experiments show that the optimal choice of group testing algorithms changes substantially when income-based economic losses are included. Evaluations considering only deterministic costs systematically underestimate the total economic cost. Algorithms with a longer quarantine duration are less attractive than shorter quarantine duration if income-based economic loss is accounted for. The findings show that current evaluations underestimate the true economic cost. Group testing algorithms with shorter duration and fewer stages are preferred, even when they require a larger number of tests. These results underscore the importance of incorporating income-based economic loss into a mathematical model. keywords Monte Carlo experiments, COVID-19, Pandemics, Economic cost, Mathematic modeling 1 Introduction A wide range of pathogens cause infectious diseases which have a profound impact on human life. The human immunodeficiency virus, chlamydia, gonorrhea or more recently the late severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) are examples of such infectious diseases ( 26 ; 8 ; 19 ) . Unsurprisingly, an important part of public health policy consists of the surveillance of diseases where the goal is to monitor and prevent the rapid spread in populations ( 16 ) . Monitoring leverages diagnostic testing where the most common approach relies on testing individuals in a population by specifically designed protocols. For instance, in pandemics, testing focuses mainly on ill individuals, whereas asymptomatic or healthy individuals are neglected. However, if the population to be screened is large, the individual testing procedure is often difficult or even impossible to perform given limited resources ( 18 ) . Alternatively, individuals of a population can be grouped and evaluated on joint test results. If a test indicates that there is no infected individual in a group, then every individual in that group is directly declared as negative and thus non-infected. Consequently, should a group include at least one infected individual, then this group is labeled as positive and further testing is necessary. This algorithmic outline is generally called group testing (GT) ( 10 ; 14 ; 1 ) . Since the advent of the COVID-19 pandemic, GT has garnered increased attention due to the decrease in test numbers compared to individual testing. Additionally, GT algorithms have been associated with a reduction in economic cost and the mitigation of resource constraint ( 12 ; 19 ; 1 ) . For instance, several studies examining SARS-CoV-2 testing in Germany conclude that the economic cost savings can be traced back to a reduction in material costs which are composed of start-up, pre-screening questionnaire and apps as well as implementation costs (see, for example, 22 ; 30 ; 21 ; 25 ). On the negative side, GT algorithms are accompanied by waiting times for testing rounds where individuals from positive pools have to be quarantined until declared negative. However, the economic loss associated with the quarantine duration is unknown. Although 4 account for the economic loss associated with the quarantine duration in a retrospective healthcare study based on sick benefits, a general economic evaluation of the GT algorithms from the payer’s perspective is missing. The aim of this article is to propose a mathematical model for an economic evaluation of GT algorithms from the payer’s perspective in Germany which includes regional, economic and temporal disparities. Furthermore, hybrid Monte Carlo experiments are conducted which combine artificial generation of optimal test numbers for GT algorithms with a real-world income data set for the economic loss. Particularly, the mathematical model relies on interpreting the monetary compensation of individuals in the form of their income as the economic loss for the quarantine duration. Since the incomes in Germany are subject to variation due to spatio-temporal disparities, often unavailable, outdated or subject to measurement error, the data set provided by the Socio-Economic Panel (SOEP) research infrastructure is utilized. The data set consists of a large-scale panel data study on households and individuals via questionnaires ( 13 ) . Motivated by conjectures in GT literature which suggest that GT algorithms with longer quarantine duration are generally unlikely to be applied in pandemics, the hybrid Monte Carlo experiments show that focusing on purely deterministic costs leads to an underestimation of economic costs ( 1 ) . Thus, by tackling GT algorithms under the assumption that they are embedded in real-world application settings where resource-constraints and uncertainty are naturally occurring, the results confirm that GT algorithms with shorter quarantine duration are preferred. In Section 2 , the mathematical model is introduced. Afterwards, Monte Carlo experiments are conducted in Section 3 . Finally, results are concluded and discussed in Section 4 . 2 Methods 2.1 Group Testing algorithms In Section 1 , GT is described as any algorithm that divides a population into disjoint pools and evaluates results based on joint tests. A variety of GT algorithms have been developed which follow this algorithmic outline. The focus in this article lies on well established GT algorithms which garnered profound interest in pandemics. Particularly, multi-stage Dorfman-type algorithms discussed in ( 10 ) and ( 24 ) are considered. The practical application in the COVID-19 pandemic of these GT algorithms has been reviewed in 12 ; 19 and 1 . Generally, GT algorithms can be divided into two types, which are adaptive and non-adaptive algorithms. Moreover, GT algorithms can be divided further into two different branches, which are probabilistic and combinatorial GT algorithms. Non-adaptive GT algorithms are based on designing the testing procedure beforehand such that intermediate results do not matter in subsequent stages. Combinatorial GT is more general and assumes a deterministic model but is also often not applicable in pandemics due to the inherent complex procedure and long-running time of the algorithms. Adaptive GT algorithms rely on stage-wise procedures, where further tests can only be carried out when the results from the previous testing stages are recovered. Probabilistic GT relies on the assumption that there is a probability distribution on the number of infected individuals ( 31 ; 14 ; 11 ; 2 ; 19 ) . Multi-stage Dorfman-type algorithms can be described as adaptive, probabilistic GT algorithms, where in the final stage individual retesting has to be performed to confirm the status of infection. Such GT algorithms are called trivial or conservative and can more easily be investigated mathematically ( 1 ) .