Why That Robot? A Qualitative Analysis of Justification Strategies for Robot Color Selection Across Occupational Contexts

Jiangen He, Wanqi Zhang, Jessica K. Barfield · 2026

Read Why That Robot? A Qualitative Analysis of Justification Strategies for Robot Color Selection Across Occupational Contexts by Jiangen He, Wanqi Zhang, Jessica K. Barfield (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28919.txt.

Introduction

He, Zhang, and Barfield study how people justify robot color choices across jobs. Robots are entering the workforce, and social bias may shape user preferences. They analyze 4,146 justifications from 1,038 participants. Four professional contexts frame the choices, which vary by robot skin tone and human-like features. Functionalism was the dominant justification, at 52 percent. Yet practical reasons often aligned with racial and occupational stereotypes. Exposure to stereotype primes shifted color choices, while reasons stayed mundane. As robots grew more human-like, users shifted toward machine centric reasoning that downplayed race.

Catalog record

CREATORJiangen He, Wanqi Zhang, Jessica K. Barfield
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38039
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28919

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Why That Robot? A Qualitative Analysis of Justification Strategies for Robot Color Selection Across Occupational Contexts Jiangen He, Wanqi Zhang, Jessica K. Barfield Abstract As robots increasingly enter the workforce, human-robot interaction (HRI) must address how implicit social biases influence user preferences. This paper investigates how users rationalize their selections of robots varying in skin tone and anthropomorphic features across different occupations. By qualitatively analyzing 4,146 open-ended justifications from 1,038 participants, we map the reasoning frameworks driving robot color selection across four professional contexts. We developed and validated a comprehensive, multidimensional coding scheme via human–AI consensus ( κ = 0.73 \kappa=0.73 ). Our results demonstrate that while utilitarian Functionalism is the dominant justification strategy (52%), participants systematically adapted these practical rationales to align with established racial and occupational stereotypes. Furthermore, we reveal that bias frequently operates beneath conscious rationalization: exposure to racial stereotype primes significantly shifted participants’ color choices, yet their spoken justifications remained masked by standard affective or task-related reasoning. We also found that demographic backgrounds significantly shape justification strategies, and that robot shape strongly modulates color interpretation. Specifically, as robots become highly anthropomorphic, users increasingly retreat from functional reasoning toward Machine-Centric de-racialization. Through these empirical results, we provide actionable design implications to help reduce the perpetuation of societal biases in future workforce robots. I INTRODUCTION As robots increasingly enter the workforce across diverse occupational sectors, the potential for human biases to influence robot selection has become a critical topic of discussion within the human-robot interaction (HRI) community. For HRI, fundamental questions have emerged regarding whether human biases: (i) influence human-robot selection decisions, (ii) shape the strategies users employ when choosing robots for different occupations, and (iii) implicate ethical concerns when users select robots that vary by racial characteristics such as skin tone and anthropomorphic features. In our previous studies exploring how occupational contexts shape robot selection, we examined whether societal biases influenced choices in construction, healthcare, educational, and athletic domains [ 15 ] . Our research was guided by Social Role Theory [ 10 ] , which posits that stereotypes emerge from observable patterns of group membership across different occupational roles, and the Stereotype Content Model [ 13 ] , which states that social perceptions are formed along two core dimensions: warmth (trustworthiness) and competence (skill). In our prior research, we found significant selection biases, where healthcare and educational scenarios led to strong favoritism for lighter-skinned robots, while construction and athletic contexts showed greater acceptance for darker-toned alternatives [ 15 ] . Furthermore, we demonstrated that exposure to human professionals from specific racial backgrounds—acting as a stereotype prime—systematically shifted robot selection in stereotype-consistent directions [ 15 ] . These findings indicate that occupational biases and color-based discrimination transfer directly from inter-human to human-robot evaluation contexts, with significant implications for the integration of robots into society. While our previous research documented these selection biases, it did not explore the underlying rationales for why participants chose robots with specific skin tones or anthropomorphic characteristics. Consequently, the present study employs a qualitative approach, analyzing over 4,000 open-ended responses to examine the reasons behind these selection decisions. Following an inductive thematic approach, our analysis allows us to gain insights into the human biases and psychological mechanisms that guide robot selection across diverse professional roles. This approach is motivated by psychological research demonstrating that stereotypes often operate through automatic activation processes, where contextual cues prime specific cognitive schemas that influence subsequent judgments [ 25 ] . By using qualitative methods, we explore the nuanced rationales participants provide for their selections. Further, addressing our topic allows us to focus on an important and emerging issue for the HRI community, that is, issues of ethics for AI-guided robots in an age of increasingly smart robots which display social identities [ 2 ] . Our current paper allows us to address a gap in the HRI literature regarding the understanding of reasons and strategies that are used when robots are selected to enter different occupational contexts. To add to the emerging stream of research on human biases in robotics, in the current study we used open-ended questions to elicit the reasons why participants made selections in different contexts. Using a systematic qualitative coding process, we first created a scheme to identify the reasons why users selected robots for different occupations, we next evaluated the reliability of the coding scheme, and concluded with design guidelines for the selection of robots entering the workforce. We organize our findings around four research questions: • RQ1 : What reasoning frameworks do participants employ to justify robot color selection? • RQ2 : How do situational factors—task context, robot color, and racial priming—shape justification patterns? • RQ3 : How do participant demographics interact with robot color to shape justification strategies? • RQ4 : How does robot human-likeness modulate the relationship between appearance and justification? II Related Work II-A Social Categorization and Robot Racialization Emerging literature demonstrates that humans project social categories onto robots. Research has shown that humans display racial bias toward robots in shooter-bias tasks [ 1 , 3 ] , and robot skin tone interacts with user prejudice to shape attributions of agency [ 12 ] . Sparrow argues that race, as a social construction, inevitably extends to robots, carrying significant ethical implications [ 26 ] . These studies indicate that HRI is not immune to social categorization, providing a foundation for examining how users perceive and categorize robots based on visual cues. II-B Occupational Contexts and Role-Based Stereotypes Occupational roles are potent sources of stereotype activation. Social role theory argues that stereotypes emerge from observed occupational distributions [ 17 ] , while the Stereotype Content Model (SCM) shows systematic associations between social categories and occupational roles along competence and warmth dimensions [ 8 , 22 ] . Empirical evidence reveals stereotypical linkages: Latinos with manual labor, Asians with academic competence, Blacks with athletic ability, and Whites with professional roles [ 22 , 17 , 23 ] . In HRI, such contexts may prime users to expect certain robotic appearances that align with these established human stereotypes. II-C Anthropomorphism and Human-Likeness Anthropomorphism determines how strongly social categories influence user perceptions. While anthropomorphic design can increase trust, it also amplifies the salience of social category cues, such as skin tone [ 6 , 20 ] . Physical human-likeness interacts with warmth and competence cues to shape robot evaluations [ 4 ] . Specifically, anthropomorphic features can trigger deeper social judgments, making robots more vulnerable to stereotype-based evaluations when occupational priming is present [ 12 , 9 ] . II-D Interpreting Appearance Cues in Human–Robot Interaction Beyond social categorization, robot appearance can also shape how users interpret a robot’s role and capabilities within a given context. Research in design and social perception suggests that visual features often function as heuristic cues that people use to infer the intended purpose and functional properties of technological artifacts [ 18 ] . In human–robot interaction, appearance cues such as form, color, and material can influence perceptions of competence, professionalism, and task suitability. For example, studies of color perception show that darker colors are often associated with durability and strength, whereas lighter colors are linked to cleanliness and approachability in service contexts [ 11 , 14

Read the complete text