Structural Pass Analysis in Football: Learning Pass Archetypes and Tactical Impact from Spatio-Temporal Tracking Data
Oktay Karakuş, Hasan Arkadaş · 2026
Read Structural Pass Analysis in Football: Learning Pass Archetypes and Tactical Impact from Spatio-Temporal Tracking Data by Oktay Karakuş, Hasan Arkadaş (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28916.txt.
Introduction
Karakuş, Arkadaş, and Eyüpoğlu present a framework for describing the structure of football passes. Passes are often judged by ball progression and attacking outcomes alone. Their method uses synchronized event and tracking data to add the shape of the opposing team. Three scores capture line bypass, space gain, and defensive disruption after one second. A fixed weight composite gives a Tactical Impact Value for each pass. On 41,078 open play passes from the 2022 World Cup, four profiles emerged. They are circulatory, destabilising, line-breaking, and space-expanding passes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Oktay Karakuş, Hasan Arkadaş |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 76905 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28916
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Structural Pass Analysis in Football: Learning Pass Archetypes and Tactical Impact from Spatio-Temporal Tracking Data Oktay Karakuş, Hasan Arkadaş Abstract The increasing availability of spatio-temporal tracking data has created new opportunities for analysing tactical behaviour in football. However, many existing approaches evaluate passes primarily through outcome-based metrics such as scoring probability or possession value, providing limited insight into how passes influence the defensive organisation of the opponent. This paper introduces a structural framework for analysing football passes based on their interaction with defensive structure. Using synchronised tracking and event data, we derive three complementary structural metrics, Line Bypass Score, Space Gain Metric, and Structural Disruption Index, that quantify how passes alter the spatial configuration of defenders. These metrics are combined into a composite measure termed Tactical Impact Value (TIV), which captures the structural influence of individual passes. Using tracking and event data from matches of the 2022 FIFA World Cup, we analyse structural passing behaviour across multiple tactical levels. Unsupervised clustering of structural features reveals four interpretable pass archetypes: circulatory, destabilising, line-breaking, and space-expanding passes. Empirical results show that passes with higher Tactical Impact Value are significantly more likely to lead to territorial progression, particularly entries into the final third and penalty box. Spatial and team-level analyses further reveal distinctive structural passing styles across teams, while player-level analysis highlights the role of build-up defenders as key drivers of structural progression. In addition, analysing passer–receiver interactions identifies structurally impactful passing partnerships that amplify tactical progression within teams. Overall, the proposed framework demonstrates how structural representations derived from tracking data can reveal interpretable tactical patterns in football. By modelling how passes reshape defensive organisation, the approach complements existing action valuation models and provides a new perspective for analysing tactical behaviour in spatio-temporal sports data. 1 Introduction Football is a low-scoring sport in which small tactical advantages can determine match outcomes. Consequently, understanding how individual actions contribute to attacking progression has become a central objective in football analytics. The increasing availability of event and tracking data has enabled the development of data-driven methods that quantify player actions and provide insights into tactical behaviour during matches. Early work focused on modelling the quality of scoring opportunities through expected goals (xG) models, which estimate the probability that a shot results in a goal based on contextual features such as location and shot characteristics [ 13 ] . Building on these ideas, several frameworks have been proposed to evaluate the value of on-ball actions more broadly. For example, the Valuing Actions by Estimating Probabilities (VAEP) framework quantifies actions by measuring how they change the probabilities of scoring and conceding in subsequent game states [ 3 ] . Similarly, Expected Threat (xT) models estimate the value of moving the ball to different regions of the pitch by learning scoring likelihoods associated with spatial locations [ 21 ] . These approaches have significantly advanced the quantitative analysis of offensive actions in football. Despite their success, most existing approaches evaluate passes primarily through their outcomes or their contribution to expected scoring opportunities. While such outcome-oriented metrics are effective for assessing attacking productivity, they often overlook the structural effects that passes have on the defensive organisation of the opponent. In practice, many passes are tactically valuable not because they immediately increase scoring probability, but because they reshape defensive structures, create imbalances, or open new passing lanes that enable subsequent actions. Recent research in spatio-temporal sports analytics has emphasised the importance of modelling spatial interactions between players. For instance, pitch control models estimate which team is most likely to control different regions of the pitch based on player positions and movement dynamics [ 24 ] . Similarly, studies analysing spatial structure have demonstrated that the creation and manipulation of space play a critical role in attacking success [ 7 ] . However, these spatial perspectives have rarely been integrated into frameworks that systematically analyse the tactical impact of passes. Recent tracking-based approaches have also begun to evaluate passes against organised defensive structures using predictive models of pass reception and player availability [ 17 ] . However, these approaches primarily assess passing options before or during execution, whereas our objective is to quantify the structural effect of executed passes on defensive organisation itself. In this paper, we introduce a structural framework for analysing football passes using spatio-temporal match data. Rather than focusing solely on pass outcomes, our approach quantifies how passes modify the defensive organisation of the opponent. Specifically, we introduce three complementary structural metrics that capture different mechanisms through which passes affect defensive structure: the Line Bypass Score (LBS) , which quantifies the extent to which a pass penetrates defensive lines; the Space Gain Metric (SGM) , which measures how a pass alters the available attacking space; and the Structural Disruption Index (SDI) , which captures the deformation of defensive organisation induced by the pass. From a machine learning perspective, these metrics define a structural feature representation of passes in a defensive-interaction space, enabling the unsupervised discovery of tactical pass archetypes from spatio-temporal tracking data. Based on these structural metrics, we derive a taxonomy of pass archetypes that distinguishes between circulatory, destabilising, line-breaking, and space-expanding passes. We further introduce the Tactical Impact Value (TIV) , a composite metric that summarises the structural influence of a pass on the defensive configuration. Using event and tracking data from matches of the 2022 FIFA World Cup, we analyse how different pass archetypes influence attacking progression and downstream outcomes such as final-third entries, box entries, and shots. Our work builds upon recent efforts to identify tactically meaningful passing actions from positional data. In particular, Karakuş and Arkadaş [ 12 ] proposed an unsupervised approach for detecting line-breaking passes by modelling defensive structures using spatial segmentation. While their work focuses specifically on identifying line-breaking passes, the framework introduced in this paper generalises this idea by modelling multiple structural mechanisms through which passes interact with defensive organisation. The main contributions of this paper are threefold: • We introduce a structural framework for analysing football passes that explicitly models how passes interact with and reshape the defensive organisation of the opponent. • We derive an interpretable taxonomy of structural pass archetypes from spatio-temporal tracking data using unsupervised clustering of structural pass features. • We propose Tactical Impact Value (TIV), a composite metric that quantifies the structural impact of passes and demonstrates its relationship with territorial progression, team-level tactical styles, and player-level structural passing roles. The remainder of this paper is organised as follows. Section 3 describes the data used in this study. Section 4 introduces the structural metrics and the Tactical Impact Value framework. Section 5 presents empirical analyses of structural pass archetypes and their tactical effects. Section 6 discusses the implications of the findings for football analytics and tactical analysis. Section 7 outlines limitations of the current study and directions for future work. Finally, Section 8 concludes the paper. 2 Related Work 2.1 Action valuation and pass evaluation A substantial body of research in football analytics has focused on assigning value to on-ball actions based on their contribution to future scoring opportunities. Early work on shot valuation showed that spatio-temporal context can substantially improve expected-goals models beyond simple shot counts or raw conversion rates [ 13 ]