Dimer Effective Field Theory Preprint: INT-PUB-26-010

Cullen Gantenberg, David B. Kaplan · 2026

Read Dimer Effective Field Theory Preprint: INT-PUB-26-010 by Cullen Gantenberg, David B. Kaplan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28842.txt.

Introduction

Gantenberg and Kaplan offer a new effective theory for nucleon scattering, built with dimer fields. Past theories fail to match data near 300 MeV. They trace the block to hidden nonanalytic structure in the complex momentum plane. It links to the peak of the angular momentum barrier in low waves. They define a C-matrix whose pole structure sets the range of the theory. Adding dimer fields as real degrees of freedom accounts for those poles. Fits then stay cutoff stable up to the pion production threshold for most low waves.

Catalog record

CREATORCullen Gantenberg, David B. Kaplan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE117546
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28842

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dimer Effective Field Theory Preprint: INT-PUB-26-010 Cullen Gantenberg, David B. Kaplan Abstract While chiral perturbation theory for mesons is characterized by a momentum expansion in Q / Λ χ Q/\Lambda_{\chi} with Λ χ ∼ 1 ​ GeV \Lambda_{\chi}\sim 1{\rm~GeV} , existing formulations of effective theory for nucleon-nucleon scattering deviate from data at Q ∼ 300 ​ MeV Q\sim 300{\rm~MeV} or lower. We offer heuristic evidence that unsuspected nonanalytic structure exists in the complex momentum plane obstructing the effective field theory expansion in the spin-triplet channels, associated with the peak of the angular momentum barrier whose energy in low partial waves satisfies k = M ​ E ∼ 300 ​ MeV k=\sqrt{ME}\sim 300{\rm~MeV} . With this motivation, we construct a meromorphic function of k 2 k^{2} we call the C C -matrix, for which the radius of convergence of its Taylor expansion in k 2 k^{2} is equivalent to that of the momentum expansion of the effective field theory. Thus the range of validity of the effective theory is directly related to the pole structure of the C C -matrix. We uncover that pole structure and confirm that it is the source of the obstruction. The systematic inclusion of dimer fields as propagating degrees of freedom in the effective theory to account for those poles results in cut-off insensitive fits to most of the lower partial wave phase shifts up the pion production threshold at order Q 0 Q^{0} , using only the one pion exchange part of the long-range nucleon-nucleon interaction. Our theory should be applicable to the singular potentials regularly found in atomic physics as well. I Introduction In developing successful theories of particle and nuclear physics, we are always limited by our ignorance about what is going on at short distance 1 1 1 For a recent compendium of papers on the status of our understanding of the nuclear interaction, see Ref. 34 . . If we include correctly all degrees of freedom at energies below some scale \Lambda_{\text{eft}} , then by invoking Weinberg’s ‘‘folk theorem’’ 2 2 2 If one writes down the most general possible Lagrangian, including all terms consistent with assumed symmetry principles, and then calculates matrix elements with this Lagrangian to any given order of perturbation theory, the result will simply be the most general possible S-matrix consistent with perturbative unitarity, analyticity, cluster decomposition, and the assumed symmetry properties 36 . we can represent the physics we have neglected by including all possible local interactions of these degrees of freedom consistent with symmetries and proportional to “low energy constants”, which are then fit to data. Each operator can be associated with a scaling dimension which renders most of them irrelevant to low energy physics. To use Wilson’s terminology: when we compute low energy observables, operators with coefficients that have large inverse mass scaling dimension will have to be accompanied by high powers of the light particle’s momentum and hence will be small at low energy. Therefore, at any order in a momentum expansion, only a finite number of operators will contribute, and with enough experimental data the theory can be predictive. A momentum expansion of the scattering amplitude has a finite radius of convergence, however, set by the location of the lowest lying nonanalyticities in the complex momentum plane. Such nonanalyticities arise from the propagation of physical particles that one has neglected in one’s theory, represent nonlocal interactions, and will be characterized by the lowest particle threshold above \Lambda_{\text{eft}} . To extend the range of validity of the local theory one has to include this new particle as an explicit degree of freedom in the effective theory. For example, learning about the quantum numbers and symmetries of the W , Z and Higgs bosons allowed the theoretical description of weak interactions to be extended to energies far beyond the limitations of Fermi’s theory. The topic of this paper is to explore whether the range of validity can be similarly extended for the effective theory for nuclear interactions first proposed by Weinberg in 1990 39 ; 40 ; 31 ; 30 . This range is not as big as one might wish: while chiral perturbation theory for pseudoscalar mesons is controlled by an expansion in powers of Q/\Lambda_{\chi} , where Q is a momentum or meson mass and \Lambda_{\chi}\sim 1{\rm~GeV} sets the UV scale, the effective theory for nucleon interactions seems to fail at a few hundred MeV in the spin-triplet channels for no obvious reason. Furthermore, this failure seems to entail an unexpected sensitivity to how one regulates the theory. Such sensitivity to UV physics undermines the rationale for an effective theory, where UV physics is supposed to be parametrized by low energy constants multiplying irrelevant operators, which are fit to data. We will argue that these issues are due to nonanalyticities in the complex momentum plane of an object we call the C -matrix at a scale parametrically set by \Lambda_{NN} , and proportional to \ell^{3} for large angular momentum \ell , where \Lambda_{NN} is the scale introduced in Ref. 23 and is defined by \displaystyle\Lambda_{NN}=\frac{8\pi f_{\pi}^{2}}{g_{A}^{2}M}\simeq 300{\rm~MeV}\ , (1) f_{\pi}=132{\rm~MeV} being the pion decay constant and M the nucleon mass. Furthermore, we show how these nonanalyticities can be accounted for by including additional “dimer” fields 23 to the effective theory, restoring locality and extending the radius of convergence significantly. As an example, Fig. 1 shows the result from this dimer effective field theory for the phase shift for nucleon-nucleon scattering in the {}^{3}P_{0} channel. The black line is the phase shift in degrees as determined from the Nijmegen partial wave analysis of scattering data 33 , plotted versus the nucleon momentum in the center of mass frame; the blue line is the result from using the first three terms in the effective range expansion. The dashed red curves are determined from the dimer effective theory at O(Q^{0}) (which includes one pion exchange), where the band indicates the dependence on UV physics as parametrized by the regulator scale \mu – required to tame the singular tensor interaction – as it is varied from \mu=100{\rm~MeV} to \mu=1500{\rm~MeV} . This result shows relative insensitivity to \mu and a good fit up to p=405{\rm~MeV} , corresponding to the lab kinetic energy T_{\text{lab}}=350{\rm~MeV} . For comparison, the Fermi momentum for nucleons in infinite matter at nuclear density is k_{F}\sim 265{\rm~MeV} , so there is reason for optimism that this theoretical technology will allow for accurate computations for nuclei and nuclear matter, perhaps well beyond nuclear density. The details for how we obtained this result are found below in § V , along with the results for other partial waves (see Fig. 17 ), but require some groundwork before we get there. Figure 1: The {}^{3}P_{0} nucleon-nucleon phase shift in degrees versus nucleon momentum in the center of mass frame ( p=405{\rm~MeV} corresponds to T_{\text{lab}}=350{\rm~MeV} ). The black curve is from the Nijmegen partial wave analysis 33 , the blue curve indicates the effective range expansion fit to O(p^{4}) , and the dashed red curve is the result from the leading O(Q^{0}) calculation in the dimer effective theory, which includes the one pion exchange potential. The result depends weakly on the renormalization scale, the variation shown as this

Read the complete text