Free energy analyticity of the disordered XY model and Debye screening in the 2D Coulomb gas

Lucas D’Alimonte, Piet Lammers · 2026

Read Free energy analyticity of the disordered XY model and Debye screening in the 2D Coulomb gas by Lucas D’Alimonte, Piet Lammers (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28734.txt.

Introduction

D'Alimonte and Lammers prove that free energy is analytic in the disordered regime for three statistical mechanics models. The models are the classical XY model, the two-dimensional lattice Coulomb gas, and the square well model. For the square well model, disorder holds at any positive temperature. Their proof shows that Gibbs measures are factors of independent random variables, with information clusters that decay exponentially in size. For the Coulomb gas, they get a strong form of Debye screening. The Debye phase also covers the complement of the BKT phase.

Catalog record

CREATORLucas D’Alimonte, Piet Lammers
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE123416
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28734

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Free energy analyticity of the disordered XY model and Debye screening in the 2D Coulomb gas Lucas D’Alimonte, Piet Lammers Abstract . We consider three models of statistical mechanics: the classical XY model in arbitrary dimension, the lattice Coulomb gas in dimension two, and the square well model in arbitrary dimension. For each of these three models, we prove that the free energy is analytic in the disordered regime (the square well model is disordered at any positive temperature). In order to prove these results, we prove that the Gibbs measures of these models are factors of i.i.d. with information clusters of exponentially decaying size (volume). In the case of the Coulomb gas, we obtain a strong version of Debye screening with an arbitrary number of arbitrary local observables of the Coulomb gas, and we prove that the Debye phase contains the complement of the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless phase of the Villain model. 1. Preface 1.1. Classifying phase transitions by regularity The idea of classifying phase transitions of lattice models according to the regularity of their free energy was introduced by Paul Ehrenfest in 1933 [ 20 ] . He predicted that a generic thermodynamical quantity — the free energy — considered as a function of the parameters of the system (often the temperature ) should be analytic, except at special transition points . At those points a phase transition occurs, the nature of which can be further investigated by studying the regularity of the free energy. In Ehrenfest’s terminology, the transition is said to be of k -th order at some point \beta_{c} if the free energy at that point is C^{k-1} but not C^{k} . The determination of the order of phase transitions is of deep theoretical interest, and has been thoroughly discussed since the systematic study of statistical mechanics. 1.2. Probabilistic perspectives Phase transitions can also be characterised in terms of qualitative changes in the probabilistic behaviour of the model when the inverse temperature passes certain threshold values (spontaneous magnetisation in the Ising model, the appearance of an infinite cluster in percolation theory, etc.). The probabilistic viewpoint provides a welcome testing ground for mathematicians for the analysis of phase transitions, and those probabilistic questions can be investigated using tools coming from several fields (combinatorics, complex analysis, measure theory, algebra, and others). This also gives rise to an integrated approach: analysing the relation between the regularity of the free energy (or other thermodynamical quantities) and the probabilistic behaviour at and around criticality. 1.3. The BKT transition Berezinskii [ 8 , 9 ] and later Kosterlitz and Thouless [ 36 ] conjectured a new type of phase transition in two-dimensional media with a continuous symmetry. This phase transition is driven by the changing behaviour of so-called topological defects , and a key feature of the prediction in [ 36 ] is that the free energy is smooth (but not analytic) at the critical point ( infinite order in Ehrenfest’s terminology). This transition is now called the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless (BKT) transition. While this prediction is widely expected to be correct, a rigorous analysis of the near-critical window is still missing due to the lack of precise tools that apply in the nonperturbative regime. The 2D XY model is not expected to be integrable, and while progress is being made on its probabilistic analysis, the lack of a hard quantative input makes it difficult to obtain a complete picture at the moment. Let us compare this to recent developments in the context of the 2D random-cluster model with cluster weight q\geq 1 , and the associated six-vertex model. By using the Bethe Ansatz (a manifestation of integrability), it has been proved that the phase transition is continuous for q\in[1,4] [ 19 ] and discontinuous for q>4 [ 16 ] . This is closely related to the behaviour of the free energy of the model as a function of q and of the slope in the six-vertex model. We now understand the behaviour for small slopes for all q>0 [ 17 ] . This implies that the mass of the model (the inverse of the correlation length, which is zero for q\leq 4 ) is analytic on (4,\infty) and drops smoothly to zero near q=4 . Similarly, the explicit expressions in [ 17 ] reveal that the free energy of the model is smooth in q and analytic everywhere except at q=4 . These behaviours are reminiscent of the BKT transition, but we cannot at the moment answer these questions for the XY model with similar methods because exact integrability (leading to explicit expressions for the free energy) appears not to be available. 1.4. Analyticity away from criticality In the absence of integrability, this article aims to progress on the probabilistic analysis of the XY model in the subcritical regime (in the open interval [0,\beta_{c}) ). It derives analyticity of the free energy in this interval. As a by-product, we also obtain analyticity of the free energy of the closely related 2D lattice Coulomb gas on the same subcritical interval, and we establish that the interactions between the Coulomb particles decay exponentially fast in the distance in the same temperature regime (Debye screening). While the question of analyticity throughout the entire subcritical regime may appear simple at first sight, it is not uncommon that subtle complications arise. In the tradition of deriving analyticity, let us first mention the remarkable and celebrated work of Lee and Yang [ 41 , 42 ] regarding the analyticity of the free energy as a function of the magnetic field, which is the first successful non-perturbative approach of this type of question. Georgakopoulos and Panagiotis proved in [ 30 ] that the density of the infinite cluster in Bernoulli percolation is analytic in the whole supercritical regime, providing a first example of a non-perturbative proof of analyticity in a percolation model using some form of renormalisation or coarse-graining argument combined with involved combinatorial constructions. We also mention the work [ 52 ] , that establishes a similar result in the case of a related model, the Gaussian free field percolation . In the Ising model, the most complete picture has been obtained by Ott, who proved in [ 51 , 50 ] that the free energy of the Ising model is analytic in \beta everywhere but at \beta_{c} . In perturbative setting, the most complete picture was described in the context of general Gibbs measures in [ 53 ] . Finally, we mention that the correspondence between Ehrenfest’s notion of phase transition and the probabilistic viewpoint was questioned by Griffiths, who discovered in [ 32 ] the very intriguing phenomenon that now bears the name of Griffiths singularities . In the setting of diluted magnets (Ising models with random Hamiltonians), he showed that the analyticity of the free energy of the model could be broken away of the critical point , due to the random fluctuations of the Hamiltonian. In the absence of those random defects (on so-called pure models), this phenomenon should however not exist, and Ehrenfest’s correspondance is expected to be exact. 1.5. Background on the XY model and the discrete 2D Coulomb gas The critical behaviour of the XY model depends starkly on the dimension of the

Read the complete text