Profile Graphical Models

Alejandra Avalos-Pacheco, Monia Lupparelli, Francesco C. Stingo · 2026

Read Profile Graphical Models by Alejandra Avalos-Pacheco, Monia Lupparelli, Francesco C. Stingo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28423.txt.

Introduction

Avalos-Pacheco, Lupparelli, and Stingo introduce profile graphical models, which show in one graph how an outside factor reshapes the links among variables. Each level of a risk factor gets its own conditional independence pattern, learned jointly. The authors define the class, prove its Markov properties, and link it to chain graph models. A Bayesian method with spike-and-slab priors plus a fast EM algorithm does the fitting. On leukemia protein data, the model found leaner networks and more patient differences.

Catalog record

CREATORAlejandra Avalos-Pacheco, Monia Lupparelli, Francesco C. Stingo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE105714
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28423

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Profile Graphical Models Alejandra Avalos-Pacheco, Monia Lupparelli, Francesco C. Stingo Abstract We introduce a novel class of graphical models, termed profile graphical models, that represent, within a single graph, how an external factor influences the dependence structure of a multivariate set of variables. This class is quite general and includes multiple graphs and chain graphs as special cases. Profile graphical models capture the conditional distributions of a multivariate random vector given different levels of a risk factor, and learn how the conditional independence structure among variables may vary across these risk profiles; we formally define this family of models and establish their corresponding Markov properties. We derive key structural and probabilistic properties that underpin a more powerful inferential framework than existing approaches, underscoring that our contribution extends beyond a novel graphical representation. Furthermore, we show that the resulting profile undirected graphical models are independence-compatible with two-block LWF chain graph models. We then develop a Bayesian approach for Gaussian undirected profile graphical models based on continuous spike-and-slab priors to learn shared sparsity structures across different levels of the risk factor. We also design a fast EM algorithm for efficient inference. Inferential properties are explored through simulation studies, including the comparison with competing methods. The practical utility of this class of models is demonstrated through the analysis of protein network data from various subtypes of acute myeloid leukemia. Our results show a more parsimonious network and greater patient heterogeneity than its competitors, highlighting its enhanced ability to capture subject-specific differences. Keywords: Undirected graphs; Chain graphs; Context-specific independence; Multiple graphs; Differential graphs. 1 Introduction Multivariate regression models can be represented by chain graphs ( Lauritzen and Wermuth 1989 ; Frydenberg 1990 ; Andersson et al. 2001 ; Wermuth and Sadeghi 2012 ) , which capture the conditional independence structure between multiple response and explanatory variables. In their simplest form, responses and predictors form two distinct chain components, with missing edges corresponding to conditional independencies under suitable Markov properties. Among the various types of chain graphs ( Drton 2009 ) , we focus on the LWF chain graph ( Frydenberg 1990 ) , which defines a smooth statistical model and provides a flexible framework for modeling dependencies among outcomes given covariates. Model selection for chain graphs has attracted significant attention, with recent developments in penalized likelihood ( Rothman et al. 2010 ; Yin and Li 2011 ; Lee and Liu 2012 ) , two-step procedures ( Cai et al. 2012 ; Chen et al. 2016 ) , and Bayesian approaches ( Bhadra and Mallick 2013 ; Consonni et al. 2017 ) . However, these models remain limited when the goal is to characterize how an explanatory variable affects the joint dependence structure among outcomes, rather than each outcome individually. The conditional independence models encoded by chain graphs provide information only through missing edges, leaving unexplored how existing dependencies change with external factors. This issue is particularly relevant in situations where associations between variables may reverse or shift across different conditions, as in the well-known effect reversal ( Cox and Wermuth 2003 ) and Simpson’s paradox ( Simpson 1951 ) . An alternative line of work addresses this issue indirectly by modeling subgroups or subpopulations through multiple graphical models ( Guo et al. 2011 ; Danaher et al. 2014 ; Peterson et al. 2015 ) or context-specific independencies ( Hojsgaard 2003 ; Corander 2003 ; Nyman et al. 2014 ; Nyman et al. 2016 ) . Yet, these approaches typically do not incorporate external factors directly into the model and often restrict context-specific variations to adjacent vertices. Building on these ideas, we propose a novel class of graphical models—profile undirected graphs—which preserve the interpretability of chain graphs while extending them to model how dependence structures among responses vary with an external factor. Our contributions are fourfold: (i) We introduce profile undirected graphs as a general framework for modeling all profile outcome distributions, i.e., conditional distributions of responses given any level of a risk factor. (ii) We derive the corresponding Markov properties based on a unified connected set rule. (iii) We establish formal compatibility, in terms of independence models, between the proposed profile graphs and specific chain graph structures. (iv) We develop parameterizations for Gaussian models and incorporate continuous spike-and-slab priors to learn shared sparsity patterns across levels of the external factor. For efficient inference, we implement a fast EM algorithm and demonstrate the usefulness of our proposed methodology through extensive simulations including comparison with competing methods and a cancer genomics application. We provide a profile graphical model of protein networks that evolve across disease subtypes, thereby uncovering subtype-specific dependency patterns invisible to standard chain graph or multiple graph analysis. 2 Theoretical framework basic setup Let G=(V,E) be a graph defined by a set of vertices a\in V and a set of edges (a,b)\in E joining pairs of vertices a,b\in V , and let Y_{V}=(Y_{a})_{a\in V} be a random vector of variables indexed by the finite set V with |p=V| . A graph, associated to a random vector Y_{V} , is generally used to represent conditional independence structures under suitable Markov properties. Typically, missing edges in G correspond to conditional independencies for the joint distribution of Y_{V} . Also, let us consider the random categorical variable X with strictly positive probability distribution representing an external factor with respect to (in the sequel, wrt) the random vector Y_{V} of outcome/response variables. The variable X takes level x\in\mathcal{X} , with q=|\mathcal{X}| . Our interest lies in the effect of X on the joint independence structure of Y_{V} and, in particular, in exploring via a graphical modelling approach how this structure may change under different levels x\in\mathcal{X} , which we call profiles . Chain graphs are generally used to model the effects of background variables on joint response variables. In the simplest form, a two-block chain graph C=[\{C_{1},C_{2}\},E] is defined by a set of vertices partitioned in chain components C_{1} and C_{2} , and a set of edges E . Depending on the set of Markov properties specified for the chain graph we may have different independence models for the joint distribution of random vectors (Y_{C_{t}})_{t\in\{1,2\}} , associated to the chain components \{C_{t}\}_{t\in\{1,2\}} . In particular we focus on the class of LWF chain graph models ( Frydenberg 1990 ) ; these models correspond to multivariate regression models with suitable independence constraints corresponding by missing edges, both within and between chain components. Any pair of vertices a,b\in C_{t} within the same chain component with t=1,2 and a\neq b , can be joined by undirected edges; vertices between chain components, a\in C_{1} and b\in C_{2} , are joined by directed edges preserving the same direction such that cycles are not allowed. For our purpose, the set of vertices C_{1} and C_{2} are associated, respectively, to the random vector Y_{V} of response variables and to the background variable X , so that C_{1}=V and |C_{2}|=1 . In principle, the chain component C_{2} may include a multiple categorical random vector; in this case X represents a random variable with state space given by the combination of a multiple factor levels. For any x\in\mathcal{X} , let Y_{V}(x) be a x-profile outcome vector , that is the random vector Y_{V}|\{X=x\} conditioned on a specific

Read the complete text