Mapping data literacy trajectories in K–12 education Conference: The 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 13 – 17, 2026; Barcelona, Spain CCS: Social and professional topics K-12 education CCS: Social and professional topics Computing literacy CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence
Robert Whyte, Manni Cheung, Katharine Childs, Jane Waite, Sue Sentance · 2026
Read Mapping data literacy trajectories in K–12 education Conference: The 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 13 – 17, 2026; Barcelona, Spain CCS: Social and professional topics K-12 education CCS: Social and professional topics Computing literacy CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence by Robert Whyte, Manni Cheung, Katharine Childs, Jane Waite, Sue Sentance (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28317.txt.
Introduction
Whyte and four co-authors map how school students build data literacy across subjects. They review 84 studies of K-12 learners working with data. From them they build a framework that sorts learning activities by two axes: whether the system runs on rules or on data, and whether its workings are clear or hidden. They then trace four paths learners take across these settings. The paths aim to help teachers design richer data lessons.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Robert Whyte, Manni Cheung, Katharine Childs, Jane Waite, Sue Sentance |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27289 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28317
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mapping data literacy trajectories in K–12 education Conference: The 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 13 – 17, 2026; Barcelona, Spain CCS: Social and professional topics K-12 education CCS: Social and professional topics Computing literacy CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence Robert Whyte, Manni Cheung, Katharine Childs, Jane Waite, Sue Sentance Abstract . Data literacy skills are fundamental in computer science education. However, understanding how data-driven systems work represents a paradigm shift from traditional rule-based programming. We conducted a systematic literature review of 84 studies to understand K–12 learners’ engagement with data across disciplines and contexts. We propose the data paradigms framework that categorises learning activities along two dimensions: (i) logic (knowledge-based or data-driven systems), and (ii) explainability (transparent or opaque models). We further apply the notion of learning trajectories to visualize the pathways learners follow across these distinct paradigms. We detail four distinct trajectories as a provocation for researchers and educators to reflect on how the notion of data literacy varies depending on the learning context. We suggest these trajectories could be useful to those concerned with the design of data literacy learning environments within and beyond CS education. 1. Introduction Data literacy is increasingly positioned as a foundational competency in a data-driven society, spanning domains such as visualization, cognitive science, artificial intelligence (AI) and education ( 7 ) . In computer science (CS) education, the rise of data-driven technologies (e.g., AI and machine learning) has led to calls for CS to expand to incorporate relevant data literacy skills ( 21 ) . However, traditional programming instruction, which focuses on rule-based logic, is insufficient for helping students master the data-driven nature of these emerging technologies ( 36 ) . Likewise, what data literacy skills are needed is uncertain. Across curricula, learners may be introduced to concepts and skills relating to coding, database work, statistical analysis, and data ethics, yet the emphasis placed on these skills and how they relate to one another can differ by context. 4 argues that data science’s cross-disciplinary nature can produce a “fractured perspective” ( 4 , p. 248) in which connections between contributing domains (e.g., statistics, computer science, mathematics) remain underdeveloped or invisible. To address this, they propose a more integrated framework that makes core competencies, such as domain understanding, problem formulation, and data management, explicit across the data lifecycle, and clarifies how these competencies align across disciplines. On the other hand, 26 ; 27 outline a set of concepts and practices they argue are fundamental to a ‘data-centric’ CS education. These framings suggest that ‘mapping the field’ is an ongoing project that warrants an interdisciplinary view and that further theorisation is needed of what data literacy looks like in CS education and how instructional experiences should be structured into meaningful progressions. This position paper is therefore guided by the question: How can we map the learning experiences taken by K–12 students across interdisciplinary data literacy activities through a common framework? 2. Theoretical framework Prior research on AI literacy in K–12 settings has often included learning about ML, yet in practice this relies on students’ capability to reason with data, for example, by trying out different examples and labels and observing how the model’s outputs change ( 36 ) . However, evidence remains limited on how students and teachers develop accurate mental models of data-driven systems and the specific concepts and skills that support that development. Strengthening this line of research likely requires interdisciplinary grounding, particularly from mathematics and statistics education ( 33 ) . We propose two dimensions we argue are central to incorporating data science activities into K–12 computing education. 2.1. Knowledge-based vs data-driven models In CS education, students typically solve problems through algorithmic solutions (e.g., programming). This approach, termed rule-based (or knowledge-based or symbolic ), is based on the idea of “logical proof of correctness” ( 33 , p. 27) and aligns with a traditional algorithmic view of problem solving in which a solution is formalised and implemented ( 37 ; 36 ) . This contrasts with a data-driven approach where students instead train and evaluate models using data and evaluate systems through a “statistical demonstration of effectiveness” ( 33 , p. 27) . 33 describes these as two notional machines, namely the “classical logical computer” and the “statistical model” ( 33 , p. 28) . 2.2. Explainability of models In many ML systems and tools, certain processes are often abstracted away (i.e., black-boxed ) so either the inner workings of the learning algorithm and/or the role of data in shaping model outcomes may be less visible to learners ( 24 ) . A pedagogical challenge for educators, then, is the extent to which data-driven models can be explained ( 15 ) . Explainability varies across models, including how transparent, interpretable, and understandable a model’s internal logic is to end users ( 2 ) . Explainability can decrease as dimensionality increases since humans cannot readily inspect or reason over all components of a high-dimensional model at once ( 5 ) . For example, a low-dimensional linear regression can be considered highly explainable because its decisions can be accounted for in terms of explicit parameters and relationships ( 5 ) . By contrast, data-driven models such as recurrent neural networks (RNNs) or random forests are typically harder to explain because the pathways by which they produce decisions are comparatively opaque ( 2 ) . Strengthening the explainability of such models, especially where decision-making processes are not transparent, is frequently presented as important for establishing trust and supporting reliable use ( 20 ) . Within explainable AI (XAI), post-hoc techniques aim to provide explanations of otherwise opaque models ( 5 ) . Common examples include feature importance methods that indicate which inputs most influenced a particular output, and counterfactual explanations, which illustrate the smallest changes needed to obtain a different prediction ( 15 ) . By contrast, ante-hoc explanations, sometimes termed “intrinsic explainability” ( 30 , p. 2) , are associated with models whose structure is itself transparent, such as “linear regression, decision tree models, k-nearest neighbors” ( 2 , p. 348) , where input–output relationships are more directly legible. From an educational perspective, this introduces a tension: if learners’ early experiences with rule-based programming formulated an expectation that computational systems are transparent and verifiable, they may struggle to reconcile that expectation with the limited transparency often characteristic of more opaque data-driven systems ( 33 , p. 28) . 2.3. Summary As CS education evolves to incorporate data literacy skills, questions remain over what and how to teach, particularly given the interdisciplinary nature of data science. To address this “fractured” issue ( 4 , p. 248) , we focus on two dimensions that could provide a common vocabulary to describe learning environments across an emerging landscape: (i) logic (i.e., knowledge-based versus data-driven), and (ii) explainability (i.e., transparent versus opaque models). We review K–12 interventions through these dimensions to characterise existing data literacy experiences and identify shared data literacy pathways. 3. Method 3.1. Systematic literature review We conducted a systematic review of literature relating to the teaching and learning of data literacy skills in K–12 settings ( 42 ) . Further details on the screening process and criteria, as well as