Single vs. Binary Origin: The Diversity of Stripped-Envelope Supernova Remnants

Gaku Kawashima, Shiu-Hang Lee, Keiichi Maeda, Daniel Patnaude · 2026

Read Single vs. Binary Origin: The Diversity of Stripped-Envelope Supernova Remnants by Gaku Kawashima, Shiu-Hang Lee, Keiichi Maeda, Daniel Patnaude (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28234.txt.

Introduction

Kawashima and three co-authors simulate how supernova remnants differ when the exploded star had a binary partner. They run remnants from both single and binary progenitors, using mass-loss records from stellar models. Binary-stripped stars leave smoother surroundings, so their remnants show calmer shocks and weaker X-ray peaks. The team also defines a timescale set by the star's total lost mass. It lines up remnant phases across messy environments, aiding readings of observed abundances.

Catalog record

CREATORGaku Kawashima, Shiu-Hang Lee, Keiichi Maeda, Daniel Patnaude
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62389
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28234

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Single vs. Binary Origin: The Diversity of Stripped-Envelope Supernova Remnants Gaku Kawashima, Shiu-Hang Lee, Keiichi Maeda, Daniel Patnaude Abstract Core-collapse supernova remnants (CCSNRs) are crucial for understanding the final stages of massive star evolution, as they reflect the imprints of their progenitors’ pre-explosion activities. However, the evolution of CCSNRs, particularly those originating from progenitors with high mass-loss rates—known as stripped-envelope SNRs (SESNRs)—remains poorly understood. This is largely due to the lack of comprehensive numerical models connecting progenitor stars to their remnants, especially in the context of binarity. In this study, we perform self-consistent simulations of CCSNRs from both single and binary progenitors, utilizing mass-loss histories and supernova ejecta profiles directly derived from stellar evolution and explosion calculations. Our models reveal significant differences in the circumstellar medium (CSM) structures between single and binary progenitors, which drive distinct SNR dynamics and spectral characteristics. We find that binary-stripped progenitors tend to produce SNRs with more monotonic CSM profiles, resulting in smoother shock dynamics and less pronounced X-ray luminosity peaks compared to their single-star counterparts. Additionally, we introduce a new characteristic timescale, t CSM t_{\rm CSM} , defined by the total mass lost by the progenitor. This timescale effectively scales the evolutionary phases of CCSNRs in complex CSM environments, thereby facilitating the comparison of SESNRs. Given that observed elemental abundances in SNRs reflect the nucleosynthesis yields of the progenitor, our results highlight the importance of considering the dynamical state of SNRs when interpreting observed abundances. This work provides a fiducial framework for future observational and theoretical studies of CCSNRs, particularly regarding the impact of binary evolution. show][email protected] I INTRODUCTION Supernova remnants (SNRs) play a pivotal role as they act as drivers of high-energy materials, such as nucleosynthesized heavy elements ( 64 ; 59 ; 3 ; 56 ; 11 ; 34 ) , and as sites of cosmic ray acceleration ( 18 ; 14 ; 8 ; 9 , e.g., diffusive shock acceleration:) . While supernovae (SNe) are broadly classified by their explosion mechanisms into Type Ia (thermonuclear) and core-collapse (CC) types, core-collapse supernova remnants (CCSNRs), which arise from the explosions of massive stars ( \gtrsim 8M_{\odot} ), are especially important in the context of the lifecycle of the universe, as they connect stellar death to the birth of new stars via their high masses. Since massive stars eject a considerable amount of their mass during their lifetimes, the evolution of CCSNRs is governed by their interaction with the surrounding circumstellar medium (CSM), which is shaped by the complex mass-loss history of the progenitor. Some SNe originate from progenitors that have experienced extensive mass loss, stripping away their outer envelopes; these are referred to as stripped-envelope SNe (SESNe), observationally classified as Type IIb, Ib, and Ic supernovae based on their early-time spectra ( 20 ; 70 ) . Among the SNRs suggested to have such origins—sometimes called stripped-envelope SNRs (SESNRs)—Cassiopeia A ( 27 ; 4 ; 1 , e.g.,) and RX J1713.7-3946 ( 26 ; 55 , e.g.,) are notable examples where thermal X-ray emission has been detected, providing clues to their progenitor properties. However, a clear mapping between the observed diversity of SESNRs, explosion types, and their specific pre-explosion progenitor scenarios remains elusive, largely due to the lack of comprehensive numerical models that account for the effects of binarity. Although a significant fraction of massive stars exist in binary systems and interact with companions before exploding as CCSNe ( 51 ) , the systematic differences between SNRs from single and binary progenitors remain poorly understood. Currently, identifying an SNR as originating from a binary system relies on a patchwork of indirect evidence, such as a low ejecta mass coupled with a high shock velocity, a shell-dominated morphology, or oxygen-rich abundances, which often lacks coherent theoretical support. Observational constraints alone are insufficient because SNRs are primarily detected via shock-heated material, making it difficult to directly infer explosion details or progenitor properties without robust theoretical models. Therefore, numerical simulations are crucial for interpreting observations and constructing a coherent theoretical framework. While foundational numerical models ( 10 ; 58 ) have successfully described the hydrodynamical evolution of SNRs in simplified environments guided by self-similar analytical solutions, they often do not fully capture the diversity arising from realistic, structured CSM environments. Furthermore, not only the CSM but also the detailed SN ejecta profile is important for modeling SNRs, since the observation of thermal emission from ejecta provides elemental records of pre-explosion composition, which is a key for back-engineering the remnants. Recent hydrodynamical simulations have begun to address these complexities. While systematic surveys have explored the broad impact of steady wind mass loss on SNR evolution ( 42 ; 43 ; 24 ) , other studies have focused on specific scenarios; for example, 69 ; 68 ; 67 examined SNRs evolving through CSM shaped by winds from multiple evolutionary stages. However, these models rely on canonical values inferred from observations, lacking the intrinsic link between a progenitor’s time-dependent mass-loss history and its final internal structure. In fact, modern stellar evolution studies emphasize the necessity of a comprehensive, self-consistent model, demonstrating that single and binary progenitors differ significantly in both mass-loss histories and pre-supernova core structures with time, which in turn affect SN yields ( 29 ; 60 ; 17 ) . In this work, we perform a systematic study of CCSNRs, specifically focusing on the distinct evolutionary paths of single and binary stripped-envelope progenitors. We construct consistent, end-to-end numerical simulation pipelines that directly link detailed mass-loss histories and SN ejecta derived from the stellar evolution calculations of 17 to the formation of wind-blown CSM and the subsequent SNR hydrodynamics. By creating a comprehensive set of fiducial models and synthesizing their X-ray emission, we aim to establish a unified picture of CCSNR evolution and provide a theoretical basis for understanding their observed diversity. While recent studies have explored end-to-end modeling connecting stellar evolution to macroscopic feedback from supernova remnants, including binary populations ( 19 , e.g.,) , our study specifically focuses on the detailed internal hydrodynamics during the SNR evolution and the synthesis of their X-ray emission. This approach aims to facilitate direct comparisons with observable SNRs, filling the gap between theoretical models of large-scale environment interactions and the properties of actual observed objects. This paper is organized as follows. Section II describes our numerical methods, including the stellar evolution input models and hydrodynamical simulation setup. Section III presents our results, focusing on the dynamical and spectral differences between single and binary progenitor scenarios. In Section IV , we discuss the implications of our findings and compare them with observations. Section V summarizes our conclusions. II METHODS II.1 Progenitors and SNe This study builds on the stellar evolution and explosion models of 17 . We utilize their single and binary star models which were evolved from the zero-age main sequence (ZAMS) to the SN explosion following core collapse using the MESA stellar evolution code ( 44 ; 45 ; 46 ; 47 ; 48 ; 25 , version 12115;) . We adopt the mass-loss histories and stellar properties at the onset of core collapse, as well as the chemical yields immediately prior to shock breakout. Our SNR code computes non-equilibrium ionization states for 30 elements, requiring distribution of stable

Read the complete text