Exact ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} electromagnetic duality of ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} toric code is non-Clifford

Ryohei Kobayashi · 2026

Read Exact ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} electromagnetic duality of ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} toric code is non-Clifford by Ryohei Kobayashi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-28230.txt.

Introduction

Kobayashi studies the electromagnetic duality of the two-dimensional Z2 toric code, a symmetry swapping its electric and magnetic particles. He proves this duality cannot be realized exactly by a Clifford circuit as an internal Z2 symmetry. The proof covers symmetries with a coarse translation invariance for odd step sizes. So an exact Z2 version must use non-Clifford gates, while Clifford versions need a larger Z2^m algebra. The result links duality to the Clifford hierarchy.

Catalog record

CREATORRyohei Kobayashi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24016
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.28230

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Exact ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} electromagnetic duality of ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} toric code is non-Clifford Ryohei Kobayashi Abstract The 2D ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} toric code admits a global symmetry exchanging electric and magnetic quasiparticles, known as electromagnetic duality. Known realizations include lattice translation symmetry, an exact ℤ 4 \mathbb{Z}_{4} symmetry generated by a Clifford circuit, and an exact ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry generated by a non-Clifford circuit. We show that a Clifford electromagnetic duality cannot realize an exact internal ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry. This is proved rigorously for symmetries with coarse translation invariance by l l lattice units for generic odd l l . Therefore an exact internal ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} electromagnetic duality must be non-Clifford, whereas generic internal Clifford realization necessarily has ℤ 2 m \mathbb{Z}_{2^{m}} algebra with m ≥ 2 m\geq 2 . Our result suggests an unexpected connection between the algebra of exact electromagnetic duality and Clifford hierarchy of circuits. Introduction.– Global symmetry plays a central role in quantum many-body systems. It constrains dynamics, and organizes phases of matter. In topologically ordered systems, symmetry acts nontrivially on anyons and generates logical operators of error-correcting codes. Among solvable models of topological order, the \mathbb{Z}_{2} toric code occupies a distinguished place Kitaev 2003 : it is the canonical lattice realization of \mathbb{Z}_{2} gauge theory, and its global symmetries provide a basic platform for both quantum error correction and fault-tolerant logical operations Yoshida 2015 ; Yoshida 2016 ; Yoshida 2017 ; Barkeshli et al. 2023 ; Barkeshli et al. 2024a ; Barkeshli et al. 2024b . At the level of topological order, (2+1)D \mathbb{Z}_{2} gauge theory admits an electromagnetic duality exchanging the electric and magnetic quasiparticles. In the square-lattice toric code this duality exchanges star and plaquette operators. A standard microscopic realization combines a transversal Hadamard transformation with a lattice translation, and therefore is not an exact {\mathbb{Z}}_{2} symmetry. More recently, an exact internal Clifford symmetry exchanging e and m was constructed as a finite-depth Clifford circuit generating a \mathbb{Z}_{4} action rather than a \mathbb{Z}_{2} action Barkeshli et al. 2023 . On the other hand, exact non-Clifford {\mathbb{Z}}_{2} symmetry for electromagnetic duality are known to exist on the microscopic Hilbert space Shirley et al. 2025 ; Tu et al. 2026 . Thus the obstruction to exact {\mathbb{Z}}_{2} electromagnetic duality is not absolute; rather, it is specific to Clifford operators. In this Letter, we prove a no-go theorem for exact Clifford {\mathbb{Z}}_{2} internal symmetry for electromagnetic duality. More precisely, we show that there is no exact Clifford \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry of the square-lattice toric code that exchanges e and m and is translation-invariant with respect to an enlarged l\times l unit cell, with generic odd integer l . Equivalently, if an exact symmetry implementing electromagnetic duality is represented by an automorphism of the Pauli group that commutes with translations by l\hat{x} and l\hat{y} for odd l , then it cannot have order two. While our proof is established for odd l , we also checked the first even cases, l=2,4 , by computer and found no exact {\mathbb{Z}}_{2} symmetry exchanging e and m with local action on Pauli operators. Although this does not amount to a proof for all even l , it provides further evidence that exact {\mathbb{Z}}_{2} electromagnetic duality is absent within Clifford operators, and hints at an interesting connection between the algebra of exact electromagnetic duality and Clifford hierarchy of circuits. Our proof is formulated in the polynomial formalism for translation-invariant Pauli stabilizer Hamiltonians Haah 2013 . In this language, a Clifford symmetry with l\times l enlarged translation symmetry is represented by a symplectic automorphism over the blocked Laurent polynomial ring. We show that, for odd l , the conditions of symplecticity, order two, and electromagnetic duality are algebraically incompatible. As a consequence, any exact odd-supercell translation-invariant Clifford implementation of electromagnetic duality must have order at least four. This lower bound is saturated by the explicit \mathbb{Z}_{4} symmetry obtained in Ref. Barkeshli et al. 2023 ; Shirley et al. 2025 (see Fig. 1 ). Figure 1: A finite-depth circuit U=U_{B}U_{G}U_{R} of the \mathbb{Z}_{2} toric code generates an exact \mathbb{Z}_{4} Clifford symmetry exchanging e and m Barkeshli et al. 2023 . On the checkerboard lattice, each plaquette supports a toric code stabilizer, as shown in the lower-right. Plaquettes of one color support X stabilizers, while plaquettes of the other color support Z stabilizers. Under conjugation by U , the X and Z stabilizers are exchanged. The \mathbb{Z}_{4} algebra of this operator is discussed explicitly in Ref. Shirley et al. 2025 . Toric code and polynomial formalism.– We begin by briefly reviewing the \mathbb{Z}_{2} toric code on a square lattice and its description in the polynomial formalism for translation-invariant Pauli stabilizer Hamiltonians. We follow the notation of Ref. Haah 2013 . See e.g., Haah 2021 ; Haah 2011 ; Haah et al. 2022 ; Tantivasadakarn 2020 ; Liang et al. 2025 ; Chen et al. 2024 ; Sun et al. 2026 ; Ruba and Yang 2025 for the applications of polynomial formalisms in Pauli models. The toric code is a commuting-projector Hamiltonian of qubits placed on the edges of a square lattice, H_{\mathrm{TC}}=-\sum_{v}A_{v}-\sum_{p}B_{p}, (1) where A_{v}=\prod_{v\subset\partial e}X_{e}~,\qquad B_{p}=\prod_{e\subset\partial p}Z_{e}~. (2) We then express the toric code utilizing the presentation of the translation-invariant Pauli Hamiltonian by Laurent polynomials. We consider one qubit at each edge of the square lattice. A lattice translation by one unit in the \hat{x} or \hat{y} direction is represented by multiplication by formal variables x or y , respectively. The translation group is thus encoded by the Laurent polynomial ring R=\mathbb{F}_{2}[x^{\pm 1},y^{\pm 1}]. (3) We represent generic Pauli operator with finite support by a column vector with entries in R . We first write single Pauli X,Z operator by the following vectors: \displaystyle X_{12}=\begin{pmatrix}1\\ 0\\ 0\\ 0\end{pmatrix},\ X_{14}=\begin{pmatrix}0\\ 1\\ 0\\ 0\end{pmatrix},\ Z_{12}=\begin{pmatrix}0\\ 0\\ 1\\ 0\end{pmatrix},\ Z_{14}=\begin{pmatrix}0\\ 0\\ 0\\ 1\end{pmatrix}, (4) where 12,14 are edges of the square lattice presented in Fig. 2 . We then express generic Pauli operators with finite support by a vector v=\begin{pmatrix}v_{X}\\ v_{Z}\end{pmatrix}\in R^{4},\qquad v_{X},v_{Z}\in R^{2}, (5) where the upper two entries encode the product of X operators involved in a single operator, and the lower two entries encode Z operators. The sums of monomials in entries of v_{X},v_{Z} indicate products of Pauli operators over translated cells, and multiplying the monomial x^{m}y^{n} to v translates the operator by a vector (m,n) . For instance, the toric code Hamiltonians nearby the edges 12,14 correspond to \displaystyle A_{1}=\begin{pmatrix}1+x^{-1}\\ 1+y^{-1}\\ 0\\ 0\end{pmatrix},\ B_{1245}=\begin{pmatrix}0\\ 0\\ 1+y\\ 1+x\end{pmatrix}. (6) A basic ingredient in this formalism is the antipode map denoted by \overline{x}=x^{-1},\qquad\overline{y}=y^{-1}, (7) extended linearly to all of R . Thus, for f=\sum_{m,n}c_{m,n}x^{m}y^{n}\in R, (8) its antipode is \bar{f}=\sum_{m,n}c_{m,n}x^{-m}y^{-n}. (9) If v is a column vector over R , we define v^{\dagger}:=\bar{v}^{\,T}, (10) namely transpose followed by the antipode map. The commutation of Pauli operators is encoded by the symplectic form \Lambda=\begin{pmatrix}0&I_{2}\\ I_{2}&0\end{pmatrix}. (11) Two Pauli operators represented by u,v\in R^{4} commute iff \langle u^{\dagger}\Lambda v\rangle_{0}=0, (12) where \langle f\rangle_{0} with f given by ( 8 ) is defined as \langle f\rangle_{0}:=c_{0,0} . A translation-invariant stabilizer Hamiltonian with t generator types is then specified by a matrix \sigma\in\mathrm{Mat}_{4\times t}(R), (13) whose columns represent the stabilizer generators in one reference unit

Read the complete text