90 + 90^{+} years of the Scottish Book

Stanisław Domoradzki, Małgorzata Stawiska, Mykhailo Zarichnyi · 2026

Read 90 + 90^{+} years of the Scottish Book by Stanisław Domoradzki, Małgorzata Stawiska, Mykhailo Zarichnyi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-27867.txt.

Introduction

Domoradzki and co-authors reflect on ninety years of the Scottish Book. The book of problems grew in a Lwów café circle. New math fields trace roots to its pages. Junior scholars drew stimulation from its open questions. A decade of progress since the last review is summed. Solved problems get fresh status notes. Kindred problem collections are surveyed as well. The piece honors a living problem tradition.

Catalog record

CREATORStanisław Domoradzki, Małgorzata Stawiska, Mykhailo Zarichnyi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58535
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.27867

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

90 + 90^{+} years of the Scottish Book Stanisław Domoradzki, Małgorzata Stawiska, Mykhailo Zarichnyi Abstract . Inspired by the recent 90th anniversary of the Scottish Book we present some reflections about its impact. First we discuss new areas of mathematics it helped launch. Then we argue that it was actively used in stimulating the interests and results of junior mathematicians and students. Also, we summarize the progress during the decade that has passed since the publication of [ 55 ] , which contained a review of solved problems from the Scottish Book. We also provide an overview of collections of open problems related in one way or another to the Scottish Book. All formulations of the Scottish Book problems in English are cited here from [ 55 , Chapter 6] . 1. Introduction The year 2025 marked the ninetieth anniversary of the beginning of the legendary “Scottish Book”, a notebook that was born within the walls of the “Scottish” coffee house in Lwów and became one of the symbols of the Lwów Mathematical School. This school, formed around the figures of Stefan Banach, Hugo Steinhaus, Stanisław Ulam and their colleagues, was one of the brightest centers of mathematics in the interwar Europe. Its strength lay not only in brilliant individual discoveries, but also in the joint formulation of open problems, challenges that became signposts for future generations. The problems recorded in the “Scottish Book” covered functional analysis, topology, measure theory and other fields. Many of them remained open for decades, stimulating the development of new methods and directions. Some problems were solved in the second half of the 20th century, while others still inspire modern researchers. It is this practice — the collective formulation of problems — that has shown that progress in science often begins with a clearly posed question. Today, over ninety years later, the “Scottish Book” is perceived not only as a historical document, but also as a living symbol: proof that mathematics is born in dialogue, in a joint search, in the ability to see a problem as the beginning of a path. The anniversary of this book is an opportunity to once again remember the Lwów Mathematical School, to assess its achievements and significance for the development of modern mathematics. An extensive historical literature is devoted to the Lwów Mathematical School. First of all, we note the book by Roman Duda [ 28 ] , also translated into English. Of course, there is a place for the Scottish Café and the Scottish Book in it as well as in other publications. Our current article, without claiming to be complete, can serve as a supplement to existing research. In addition, 11 years have passed since the second edition of Mauldin’s book [ 55 ] on the Scottish Book, which, in particular, gave the most complete overview of the problems solved at that time or noted progress in work on unsolved problems. During these years, mathematicians have solved a number of other problems, and this motivated us to address these new development while writing this article. 2. New and old mathematics in problems from “The Scottish Book” We commonly refer to “the” Scottish Book, but it should be noted that there are several somewhat different versions of the Scottish Book in circulation, each one with some kind of endorsement. On the site [ 76 ] , the following are accessible: a copy of the manuscript from the private collection of the Banach family (containing 193 problems, the last one unnumbered); a copy of the typescript from the private collection of the Alexiewicz family, with comments and underlining by Andrzej Alexiewicz (155 problems); a copy of the typescript in English, translated by Stanisław Ulam, from the collection of Archives of the Library of the Mathematics Department of Wrocław University (193 problems). Ulam’s translation gave rise to the publication of the Scottish Book, first as the Los Alamos Laboratory preprints (in 1957 and 1977), then as a volume edited by R. Dan Mauldin (two editions, in 1979 and 2015, the latter is [ 55 ] ), containing problems, their solutions (whenever available), extensive commentaries and other material, such as personal recollections by Ulam and Mark Kac, as well as lectures from the 1979 conference in Denton, Texas, devoted to the Scottish Book. The second edition had also a kind of companion conference: American Mathematical Society Special Session on the Scottish Book at the Joint Mathematics Meeting in San Antonio, Texas, on January 13, 2015 (an account can be found in [ 79 ] ). The readers who associate mathematics foremost with precision may be disappointed with the varying answers to two questions: how many problems are there in the Scottish Book and what mathematical disciplines they represent? But the Scottish Book is not a mathematical object itself. It is a product of human activity and therefore susceptible to imprecision. First, the number of problems would vary because some problems consist of several parts, which may be counted separately, especially when one part has been solved and other parts are still awaiting solution. Second, classifying the mathematical themes present in the Scottish Book would give different results depending on the classification scheme used and on interpretation of the boundaries between different areas (which are fluid). From 1868 the scheme of Jahrbuch über die Fortschritte der Mathematik was used in classifying mathematical problems and publications. The emergence of new disciplines and growing specialization, as well as other circumstances (see [ 86 ] and the references therein), led to development of a very different scheme, the Mathematics Subject Classification (MSC). This scheme was started in 1940 and was revised multiple times. Bearing this in mind we propose the following thematic classification of the problems in the Scottish Book (following the current MSC2020): Set theory- 7 problems; combinatorics– 5; group theory– 5; topological groups– 9; functions of a real variable– 27; measure theory– 15; potential theory–2; sequences, series, summability- 13; harmonic analysis– 2; functional analysis– 19; operator theory–4; convex geometry– 9; general topology–25; topology of manifolds–16 probability–10; others– … Among the“others” two subsets are worth mentioning: Properties of polynomials–7; Algebraic, differential and/or elementary geometry–11. Was there any major area of mathematics not represented in the Scottish Book? Let us start with an observation of Mark Kac: “Returning to the Scottish Book, I would like to point out that although the problems in it range over most of the principal branches of Mathematics, one branch is conspicuously absent, and that is Number Theory. The reason is simple, and it is that Number Theory was not in vogue in Poland at the time. Sierpiński in his younger years (and also toward the end of his life) did important and interesting things in Number Theory, and the Warsaw school did produce two ‘mutants’: A. Walfisz (who left Poland for the Soviet Union and was Professor at Tbilisi) and S. Lubelski. There was even a serious journal, Acta Arithmetica (which continues to this day), devoted to Number Theory, but this beautiful and important area was far from the forefront of mathematical preoccupation in Poland before World War II.” ( [ 42 ] ) The full story is more complex. We do not claim here that Kac, a

Read the complete text