Empirical Likelihood for Nonsmooth Functionals
2026
Read Empirical Likelihood for Nonsmooth Functionals (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-27743.txt.
Introduction
Namkoong extends empirical likelihood to rough statistical targets. Classic versions need smooth functionals to calibrate well. The optimal-value target breaks that need at ties. Such ties arise just when careful inference matters most. His method pairs empirical likelihood with a corrected bootstrap. A geometric step reduces the profile to a distance. Cone shape at the kink sets the limit law. A multiplier bootstrap fixes the naive version.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89397 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.27743
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Empirical Likelihood for Nonsmooth Functionals Abstract Empirical likelihood is an attractive inferential framework that respects natural parameter boundaries, but existing approaches typically require smoothness of the functional and miscalibrate substantially when these assumptions are violated. For the optimal-value functional central to policy evaluation, smoothness holds only when the optimum is unique—a condition that fails exactly when rigorous inference is most needed where more complex policies have modest gains. In this work, we develop a bootstrap empirical likelihood method for partially nonsmooth functionals. Our analytic workhorse is a geometric reduction of the profile likelihood to the distance between the score mean and a level set whose shape (a tangent cone given by nonsmoothness patterns) determines the asymptotic distribution. Unlike the classical proof technology based on Taylor expansions on the dual optima, our geometric approach leverages properties of a deterministic convex program and can directly apply to nonsmooth functionals. Since the ordinary bootstrap is not valid in the presence of nonsmoothness, we derive a corrected multiplier bootstrap approach that adapts to the unknown level-set geometry. Hongseok Namkoong Decision, Risk, and Operations Division, Columbia Business School [email protected] 1 Introduction Empirical likelihood (EL) is a nonparametric method of inference that retains many of the virtues of parametric likelihood without committing to a parametric model. Given data X_{1},\dots,X_{n} , one maximizes the product \prod_{i=1}^{n}p_{i} over probability vectors (p_{1},\dots,p_{n}) subject to the constraint that a parameter of interest takes a hypothesized value. The resulting likelihood-ratio statistic converges to \chi^{2} under the null, yielding confidence regions that are automatically shaped by the data, respect natural parameter boundaries, and satisfy a Bartlett correction [ 18 ] . Because the construction requires no variance estimation and no distributional specification, EL confidence regions have complementary advantages to normal-theory counterparts in finite samples: they are range-respecting, transformation-invariant, and self-normalizing. These properties have made EL an attractive foundation for inference on means, quantiles, regression parameters, and smooth functions thereof. For a decision-maker choosing among competing options under uncertainty, the appeal of EL is especially direct. The shape adaptation means that confidence regions contract along directions the data resolve well and expand where they do not, so the resulting bounds on decision-relevant quantities are neither artificially wide nor miscalibrated. This paper is motivated by whether these advantages can be extended to a class of problems that is central to modern data-driven decision-making but falls outside the scope of existing EL theory: inference on the average reward under the best available policy, which often guides investment decisions for interventions with an initial fixed setup cost. Motivating application A large and growing class of decision problems requires evaluating candidate policies from data collected under a different, unknown behavioral policy. In healthcare, a clinician considering a new treatment assignment rule sees only the outcomes of the assignments that were actually made; in e-commerce, a platform testing pricing strategies observes revenue only under the prices that were historically charged. Formally, the observed data consist of covariates, an action or treatment drawn from the behavioral policy, and an outcome. The decision-maker has several candidate policies, each mapping covariates to actions, and the quantity of interest is the value of the best available option, \tau(P_{0})=\max_{1\leq j\leq J}\left\{\theta_{j}(P_{0}):=\mathbb{E}_{P_{0}}[Y^{\pi_{j}}]\right\}, (1) where Y^{\pi_{j}} is the potential outcome under policy \pi_{j} . Because the counterfactual outcomes are not directly observed, estimating each policy value requires modeling nuisance functions—the propensity score and the conditional outcome means—making the problem genuinely semiparametric. Over the past decade, the double/debiased machine learning (DML) literature has provided a clean reduction of this difficulty [ 4 ] . After splitting the sample and fitting nuisance models on an auxiliary fold, one forms augmented inverse-probability weighting (AIPW) scores on the evaluation fold: X_{ni,j}=\widehat{m}_{\pi_{j}(W_{i})}(W_{i})+\frac{\mathbbm{1}\{A_{i}=\pi_{j}(W_{i})\}}{\widehat{e}_{\pi_{j}(W_{i})}(W_{i})}\bigl(Y_{i}-\widehat{m}_{A_{i}}(W_{i})\bigr),\qquad j=1,\dots,J. (2) Under standard overlap and rate conditions on the nuisance estimators [ 4 , 1 , 12 ] , the score vector satisfies a central limit theorem centered at the true policy-value vector, and its sample mean converges at \sqrt{n} -rate. The debiasing step thus converts a semiparametric problem into a nonparametric one: inference on the maximum of a \sqrt{n} -normal score mean. Given these score vectors, it is natural to apply empirical likelihood. Why are ties relevant? In many applied settings, the primary question is not “which policy is best?” but “does the best available policy improve enough over a simple default to justify its implementation cost?” A decision-maker comparing a complex personalized treatment rule (which requires expensive real-time data collection and infrastructure) against a simpler rule that ignores certain covariates is performing exactly this kind of opportunity sizing. A growing body of empirical work suggests that the gains from personalization are often modest: in education, personalized tutoring policies frequently offer only marginal improvements over static alternatives [ 16 ] ; in healthcare, heterogeneous treatment effects are routinely small relative to average effects [ 5 ] ; and in welfare-maximizing policy design, the improvement from targeting over a uniform rule can be negligible [ 13 ] . When several candidate policies achieve similar expected rewards, the set of optimal policies contains multiple elements—and it is in this near-tied regime that a rigorous confidence bound on the best attainable value is most decision-relevant. It is also where existing methods break down. Limitations of existing EL approaches The existing EL machinery, however, does not accommodate the nonsmooth max functional ( 1 ). Both classical EL results for nonlinear functionals [ 18 , 6 ] and semiparametric EL extensions [ 8 , 3 ] require that the target map be smooth. Molanes-López et al. 2009 study EL for non-smooth criterion functions, but their framework targets U-statistics and related criteria rather than the directionally differentiable max functional that arises in policy evaluation. Applying them to ( 1 ) forces one of two workarounds. The first is projected joint EL : build a joint confidence region for the full policy-value vector and project onto the maximum. This is valid but pays a dimension- J critical value for a scalar target; at the 95\% level with twenty policies, the resulting bound is significantly wider than necessary (Proposition 5 ). The second is selected-policy EL : estimate the empirically best policy and run one-dimensional EL on that coordinate. This ignores selection uncertainty and undercovers badly near ties. Beyond the conservatism-versus-coverage tradeoff, semiparametric bootstrap calibration can create a computational bottleneck. The bootstrap method of Hjort et al. 2009 requires refitting all nuisance models inside every resample, turning a moderate inferential problem into an expensive learning problem repeated hundreds of times. For smooth targets, Bravo et al. 2020 sidestep this cost by replacing the original moment with an influence-function-corrected equation, restoring the Wilks property without resampling-level refitting. Their fix, however, relies on smoothness of the target functional and does not extend to the nonsmooth max functional ( 1 ). A further difficulty is nonregularity. When one policy is uniquely optimal, the max functional is Hadamard differentiable (HD) and a standard \chi^{2} calibration applies [ 6 ] . But the uniqueness assumption is itself at least as hard to verify as the inferential task: certifying that one policy is strictly better than all others requires the same kind of statistical evidence as the confidence bound one is trying to construct. When two or more policies are