Fine Structures of Berry Curvature and Unquantized Valley Chern Numbers in Valley Photonic Crystals

Wei Dai, Taiki Yoda, Yuto Moritake, Masaya Notomi · 2026

Read Fine Structures of Berry Curvature and Unquantized Valley Chern Numbers in Valley Photonic Crystals by Wei Dai, Taiki Yoda, Yuto Moritake, Masaya Notomi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-27244.txt.

Introduction

Dai and co-authors show that valley Chern numbers in valley photonic crystals are not quantized. Valley topology is defined locally near the K points, since global Chern numbers vanish. Half-integer valley Chern numbers had been widely assumed in the field. The team computed Berry curvatures across a continuous family of designs. The values form a continuous spectrum that shifts with structural parameters. Fine structures appear in the Berry curvature's momentum-space pattern. Cancellations within and between valleys explain this.

Catalog record

CREATORWei Dai, Taiki Yoda, Yuto Moritake, Masaya Notomi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43644
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.27244

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Fine Structures of Berry Curvature and Unquantized Valley Chern Numbers in Valley Photonic Crystals Wei Dai, Taiki Yoda, Yuto Moritake, Masaya Notomi Abstract Valley photonics has emerged as a promising platform in topological photonic systems, yet the topological nature of valley-dependent phenomena remains unsettled. Theoretically, inter-valley scattering may occur with structural imperfections, and global Chern numbers vanish due to time-reversal symmetry. As a result, valley-dependent topology is locally defined around K ⁡ ( K ′ ) K(K^{\prime}) points in the half-Brillouin zone (HBZ). While half-integer valley Chern numbers have been widely assumed, their quantization and topological validity remain controversial. Here, we systematically investigate a continuous spectrum of valley photonic crystal designs by evaluating their Berry curvatures, valley Chern numbers, and angular momenta. We show that valley Chern numbers are generically unquantized and instead form a continuous spectrum varying with structural parameters. We further reveal previously unexplored fine structures in the Berry curvature distribution in momentum space. The unquantized valley Chern numbers are attributed to inter- and intra-valley cancellation of Berry curvature, highlighting the absence of a protecting mechanism for quantization. Our results call for a reassessment of valley-dependent topology and provide a more rigorous framework for interpreting valley-related photonic phenomena. I Introduction Inspired by electronic two-dimensional Dirac materials 31 ; 35 , the photonic analog of valleytronics has led to novel light manipulation via the valley degree of freedom as a new degree of freedom. Similar to two-dimensional Dirac materials such as graphene 5 and monolayer transition metal dichalcogenide 32 , two-dimensional photonic crystals (PhC) with hexagonal lattice structure has K/K^{\prime} valleys at the corner of the hexagonal Brillouin zone. Breaking two-fold rotational symmetry around the z axis ( C_{2z} symmetry) causes opposite chirality in modes at the K and K^{\prime} points, i.e. the chirality of modes couples to the valley degree of freedom. The two K and K^{\prime} valleys thus can be distinguished in hexagonal lattice PhCs without C_{2z} symmetry. These PhC are sometimes called valley photonic crystals (VPhCs). The first valley-photonic phenomena proposed is the valley-Hall effect of light 21 ; 22 ; 36 . Following works also revealed that gapped valley states at the K and K’ points carry the characteristic angular momentum: the vortex of the Poynting vector, the in-plane circular polarization, and phase singularity of the electromagnetic fields 23 ; 19 ; 6 and Berry curvature 28 ; 13 ; 9 . Due to the time-reversal-symmetry (TRS), opposite valleys have opposite Berry curvatures: \Omega_{n,-\textbf{k}}=-\Omega_{n,\textbf{k}} , where n is the band index and k is the wavevector. This leads to a zero net Chern number in the first Brillouin zone of VPhCs. To describe the local band topology hosted by each valley, a valley Chern number is defined on half Brillouin zone (HBZ) centered at K/K^{\prime} points: C_{v}^{K/K^{\prime}}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{HBZ}\Omega^{K/K^{\prime}}(\mathbf{k})d^{2}k . A valley PhC waveguide (VPhCWG) is constructed by connecting two spatially-inverted valley photonic crystals, which have opposite C_{v} , with a proper domain wall. Valley-polarized states localized at the domain-wall are expected to appear within the bulk band gap. The robust transport of valley interface states hs been widely observed in various types of VPhCWGs 34 ; 18 ; 6 ; 14 ; 13 . While most previous studies report quantized values of the valley Chern numbers: C_{v}^{K/K^{\prime}}=\pm 0.5 , some have argued that C_{v} is not quantized ( C_{v}<0.5 ) 13 and vary continuously with the structural parameters 33 . It is commonly believed that if C_{v} is non-zero, valley-dependent topology exists and various valley-dependent phenomena can be observed. However, inter-valley scattering or pseudospin flipping is not strictly prohibited even for quantized (half-integer) C_{v} , let alone smaller values. It remains unclear how one should define the valley-dependent topology when C_{v} can be an arbitrary value smaller than 0.5, and how the specific value of C_{v} affects the valley-dependent properties. These questions are further underscored by recent studies that doubted and challenged the topological protection of valley interface states in both disordered waveguides 2 ; 27 and sharply bent waveguides 7 . Practically, large photonic band gaps (PBGs) are usually necessary for PhC devices. In PhC waveguides, complete band gap is required to confine light in one dimension. In PhC nanocavity lasers, large PBG supports high-Q, sharp resonance peaks and reduces device size and power threshold 1 ; 16 ; 24 . A commonly used design of VPhCs is honeycomb arrays of air holes in dielectric slabs, which offers large band gap in optical frequency. Applications such as compact lasers 10 ; 15 and valley routing circuits 18 ; 12 have been demonstrated with this design. In the hole-type VPhCs, the lowest two TE bands form the conical dispersion (Dirac cone) at the two K points. When the C_{2z} symmetry of the photonic crystal is broken, the degenerate two states at the K points split and the gapped states exhibit the valley-dependent phenomenon. Triangular lattice designs are also reported as a special case of honeycomb-lattice with one sublattice vanishing. It is widely considered that the valley-dependent properties in both cases arise from the lifted Dirac cone, which is analogous to inversion-asymmetric graphene 31 ; 35 . However, the treatment of triangular lattice VPhCs as a special case of honeycomb-lattice is not rigorous. The base point of C_{2z} symmetry, whose breaking gives rise to the valley-dependent properties, is different in a triangular and honeycomb lattice. There lacks fair, systematic evaluation of the valley-dependent properties in a triangular-lattice and honeycomb-lattice PhCs, and the consequences of such difference in symmetry is unclear. In this paper, we first propose a generic scheme to build valley PhCs based on continuous structural deformation. We investigate the valley-dependent properties for the first three bands, especially focusing on the evolution of Berry curvature and angular momentum at K point as the structural parameters change. We demonstrate that Dirac cone is not a necessary condition for Berry curvatures to emerge. We also show that from a practical perspective, where large PBG is necessary, the triangular-lattice design have no essential difference from the honeycomb-lattice designs regarding valley-dependent properties. We also demonstrate with several examples that the valley Chern number is generally not quantized in VPhCs. II Calculation method II.1 Structural model Figure 1: Illustration of structure model. Starting from a honeycomb lattice, the investigated photonic crystal hole size and shape are gradually modified, to a triangular-lattice and then back to a honeycomb-lattice. The rounding factor f_{r} defines the rounded triangle shape in the triangular-lattice. The radius ratios f_{t} and f_{c} define the perturbation strength in the honeycomb lattice. f_{r} varies in range [0,0.5] and f_{t/c} varies in range [0,1] We investigate PhCs with honeycomb or triangular arrays of air holes in a dielectric slab. We consider a continuous evolution of lattice shapes in a hole-type silicon PhC. Figure1 shows the Wigner-Seitz unit cells of some typical designs. The hole shapes in the honeycomb-lattice is either circular or triangular. We call them Cir-HPC and Tri-HPC respectively. The honeycomb-lattice becomes a triangular-lattice when the air holes in one sublattice is shrunken to zero. One can further round the vertices of the triangle to control the C_{2z} symmetry. As shown in the top middle image in Fig.1, the rounded triangle is constructed by replacing three corners with arcs of

Read the complete text