Late-time attractors in relativistic spin hydrodynamics in Gubser flow

Gen-Hui Li, Xiang Ren, Dong-Lin Wang, Shi Pu · 2026

Read Late-time attractors in relativistic spin hydrodynamics in Gubser flow by Gen-Hui Li, Xiang Ren, Dong-Lin Wang, Shi Pu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-27182.txt.

Introduction

Li and co-authors study late-time attractors for spin density in relativistic spin hydrodynamics under Gubser flow. They derive the differential equation that governs the spin density's evolution. Its late-time asymptotic solutions reveal both attractor and repeller branches. Mapping the solutions back to flat Minkowski space exposes power-law decay regimes. When the system is much larger than the proper time, spin components decay slowly. They then behave like ordinary hydrodynamic modes of the flow. The scaling laws of the flow control that slow decay.

Catalog record

CREATORGen-Hui Li, Xiang Ren, Dong-Lin Wang, Shi Pu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56351
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.27182

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Late-time attractors in relativistic spin hydrodynamics in Gubser flow Gen-Hui Li, Xiang Ren, Dong-Lin Wang, Shi Pu Abstract We investigate the late-time asymptotic solutions and attractor structure of the spin density in minimal causal spin hydrodynamics in Gubser flow. After deriving the differential equation governing the spin density, we obtain its late-time asymptotic solutions and identify both attractors and repellers in the corresponding numerical solutions. We then map these solutions back to flat Minkowski space and find parameter regions where the spin density exhibits a power-law decay. We further show that, when the characteristic length scale of the system is much larger than the proper time, several components of the spin density can decay as slowly as conventional thermodynamic variables in relativistic hydrodynamics. In this regime, the spin density behaves as a hydrodynamic mode governed by the late-time scaling laws of the flow. I Introduction In noncentral relativistic heavy-ion collisions, the colliding nuclei carry a large initial orbital angular momentum. Part of this angular momentum can be transferred to the spin degrees of freedom of produced hadrons, leading to spin polarization of hyperons and spin alignment of vector mesons through spin–orbit coupling Liang:2004ph ; Liang:2004xn . The RHIC-STAR Collaboration has measured the global polarization, i.e., the polarization along the direction of the initial orbital angular momentum, as a function of collision energy, for \Lambda and \overline{\Lambda} , and other hyperons STAR:2017ckg ; STAR:2018gyt ; STAR:2020xbm ; STAR:2021beb ; STAR:2023nvo . At high and intermediate collision energies, the observed global polarization is primarily driven by thermal vorticity and can be described by a variety of phenomenological models Karpenko:2016jyx ; Li:2017slc ; Sun:2017xhx ; Wei:2018zfb ; Vitiuk:2019rfv ; Fu:2020oxj ; Lei:2021mvp ; Ryu:2021lnx . The global polarization in low-energy collisions STAR:2021beb ; STAR:2023nvo ; HADES:2022enx , in particular near and below the production threshold of the \Lambda hyperon, has also been investigated Guo:2021udq ; Deng:2020ygd ; Deng:2021miw ; Vitiuk:2019rfv ; Sun:2025oib ; Liu:2025kpp ; Zheng:2025ngn ; Xu:2026hxz , but a definitive understanding has not yet been reached. On the other hand, the local polarization of hyperons, namely the polarization along the beam direction and the out-of-plane direction as a function of azimuthal angle or transverse momentum, has not been successfully described for a long time by the same models that reproduce the global polarization. To address this discrepancy, a hydrodynamic effect referred to as shear-induced polarization Liu:2021uhn ; Fu:2021pok ; Becattini:2021suc ; Becattini:2021iol ; Hidaka:2017auj ; Yi:2021ryh ; Yi:2021unq ; Florkowski:2021xvy ; Alzhrani:2022dpi ; Palermo:2022lvh ; Buzzegoli:2022fxu ; Wu:2022mkr ; Yi:2023tgg ; Wu:2023tku ; Palermo:2024tza has been identified as playing an important role in the local polarization. In addition, polarization induced by gradients of the baryon chemical potential (often discussed in terms of the spin Hall effect Fu:2022myl ; Ivanov:2022geb ; Hidaka:2017auj ; Wu:2023tku and anomalous spin Hall effect Fang:2024vds ; Wang:2025mfz ), may become relevant at low collision energies. Partonic-interaction corrections have also been investigated systematically in recent studies, e.g. see Refs. Fang:2022ttm ; Fang:2024vds ; Fang:2025pzy and the references therein. Nevertheless, achieving a quantitative description of local polarization at low energies remains challenging Yi:2021ryh ; Yi:2023tgg ; Wu:2023tku ; Yi:2024kwu . Recently, the CMS measurement of local polarization in p+Pb collisions CMS:2025nqr has also been reported to be incompatible with standard modeling assumptions Yi:2024kwu ; Yi:2025anh ; Yi:2025sgk . For further details, we refer to recent reviews Gao:2020vbh ; Becattini:2022zvf ; Becattini:2024uha ; Niida:2024ntm and the references therein. To get a better understanding of spin polarization in relativistic heavy-ion collisions, it is essential to investigate the dynamical evolution of spin degrees of freedom in the medium produced in the collisions. One approach is quantum kinetic theory Gao:2012ix ; Chen:2012ca ; Hidaka:2016yjf ; Hidaka:2017auj ; Gao:2019znl ; Weickgenannt:2019dks ; Liu:2020flb ; Weickgenannt:2020aaf ; Weickgenannt:2021cuo ; Sheng:2021kfc ; Hidaka:2022dmn ; Fang:2022ttm ; Dong:2022yzt ; Dong:2023cng ; Fang:2023bbw ; Yin:2024dnu ; Fang:2024vds ; Fang:2025pzy ; Bhadury:2025boe , which provides a microscopic effective description of the evolution of quasi-particles with spin. Another approach is to formulate macroscopic evolution equations for spin, namely relativistic spin hydrodynamics Montenegro:2017rbu ; Florkowski:2017ruc ; Florkowski:2018fap ; Hattori:2019lfp ; Fukushima:2020ucl . This motivates extending conventional relativistic hydrodynamics by incorporating spin as an additional hydrodynamic degree of freedom. Such formulations have been developed using quantum statistical field theory Becattini:2018duy ; Hu:2022azy ; Dey:2024cwo ; Tiwari:2024trl ; She:2024rnx , quantum kinetic theory Florkowski:2018myy ; Bhadury:2020puc ; Shi:2020htn ; Speranza:2020ilk ; Bhadury:2020cop ; Singh:2020rht ; Peng:2021ago ; Weickgenannt:2022zxs ; Weickgenannt:2022jes ; Weickgenannt:2022qvh ; Bhadury:2022ulr ; Wagner:2023cct ; Florkowski:2024bfw ; Wagner:2024fhf ; Wagner:2024fry ; Daher:2025pfq , analyses based on the entropy principle Hattori:2019lfp ; Fukushima:2020ucl ; Gallegos:2020otk ; Li:2020eon ; Gallegos:2021bzp ; She:2021lhe ; Hongo:2021ona ; Biswas:2023qsw ; Fang:2025aig ; Zhang:2026zee , and the effective field-theory approach Montenegro:2017rbu ; Montenegro:2017lvf . Very recently, using spin hydrodynamics, an extended Bargmann-Michel-Telegdi equation that incorporates rotation and dissipative effects has been derived Fang:2025aig . For further discussion of spin hydrodynamics, we refer to recent reviews Florkowski:2018fap ; Shi:2023sxh ; Huang:2024ffg and the references therein. Although the basic framework of relativistic spin hydrodynamics has been established, several open issues remain. One issue concerns causality and stability. It has been found that first-order spin hydrodynamics in a gradient expansion, formulated in the canonical form, is generically acausal and unstable Xie:2023gbo ; Sarwar:2022yzs ; Daher:2022wzf ; Daher:2024bah . Moreover, even after a minimal extension to second order, spin hydrodynamics can still exhibit unstable modes in a linear-mode analysis, even when the asymptotic causality conditions are satisfied Xie:2023gbo 1 1 1 This behavior is markedly different from conventional relativistic hydrodynamics without spin, see, e.g., the discussion in Refs. Denicol:2008ha ; Pu:2009fj ; Kovtun:2019hdm . Also see Refs. Heller:2022ejw ; Gavassino:2023myj ; Gavassino:2023mad ; Wang:2023csj ; Hoult:2023clg for recent discussions of improved causality and stability criteria in linear-mode analyses for relativistic many-body theories. . To address this issue, Ref. Ren:2024pur applied the thermodynamic stability method Gavassino:2021kjm and derived causality and stability conditions. A second issue concerns the choice of pseudo-gauge. In addition to the canonical form Hattori:2019lfp ; Hongo:2021ona , the Belinfante form Fukushima:2020ucl and other pseudo-gauge choices Florkowski:2018fap ; Speranza:2020ilk ; Weickgenannt:2022zxs ; Dey:2023hft can also be used in constructing spin hydrodynamics. Although there has been recent progress in this direction Li:2020eon ; Buzzegoli:2021wlg ; Buzzegoli:2024mra ; Becattini:2025twu , the problem remains unsettled and should be addressed systematically in future work. A third issue is that several recent studies Becattini:2023ouz ; Florkowski:2024bfw ; Becattini:2025oyi have reported that the thermodynamic relations commonly employed in spin hydrodynamics at finite spin density and spin chemical potential differ from those obtained in microscopic approaches. By contrast, other works have found consistency between spin-hydrodynamic thermodynamics and microscopic results by carefully accounting for rotational effects Ambrus:2025dca or by introducing an appropriate pseudo-gauge transformation Armas:2026bmw . In addition, there is another long-standing issue in spin hydrodynamics, especially in the canonical formulation. In canonical spin hydrodynamics, the spin density is not a conserved quantity Hattori:2019lfp , in contrast to the conserved charge (number) density. It is commonly expected that the spin density relaxes more rapidly than other macroscopic hydrodynamic fields, which would make its effects difficult to observe on the freeze-out hypersurface. This expectation is supported, for example, by analytic solutions of canonical spin hydrodynamics in Bjorken flow Wang:2021ngp

Read the complete text