Fast Posterior Sampling in Tightly Identified SVARs Using ‘Soft’ Sign Restrictions
Matthew Read · 2026
Read Fast Posterior Sampling in Tightly Identified SVARs Using ‘Soft’ Sign Restrictions by Matthew Read (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-27088.txt.
Introduction
Read and Zhu speed up Bayesian inference in structural vector autoregressions with sign restrictions. Tight identification makes standard accept-reject sampling wastefully slow. Their sampler first draws from a soft target that smoothly penalizes restriction violations. Efficient Markov chain methods can then explore that smooth density. An importance-sampling step converts the draws to ones obeying the hard restrictions. The method also supports prior-robust Bayesian analysis. An oil-market model with sign, elasticity, and narrative restrictions shows the approach's breadth. The gains grow as identification gets tighter.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matthew Read |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 95112 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.27088
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fast Posterior Sampling in Tightly Identified SVARs Using ‘Soft’ Sign Restrictions Thanks: We thank Joshua Chan, Thorsten Drautzburg, Toru Kitagawa, James Morley, Yong Song, Benjamin Wong, three anonymous referees and the Co-Editor, James Hamilton, for valuable comments. We also thank participants at the 2023 Continuing Education in Macroeconometrics workshop, the 2023 Time Series and Forecasting Symposium, the 2024 Econometric Society Australasia Meeting and the 2025 World Congress of the Econometric Society. The views expressed in this paper are those of the authors and should not be attributed to the Reserve Bank of Australia. Any errors are the sole responsibility of the authors. Thanks: Department of Econometrics and Business Statistics, Monash University. email: [email protected] Matthew Read Abstract We propose algorithms for conducting Bayesian inference in structural vector autoregressions identified using sign restrictions. The key feature of our approach is a sampling step based on ‘soft’ sign restrictions. This step draws from a target density that smoothly penalises parameter values that violate the restrictions, facilitating the use of computationally efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling algorithms. An importance-sampling step yields draws conditional on the ‘hard’ sign restrictions. Relative to standard accept-reject sampling, the method substantially speeds up sampling when identification is tight. It also facilitates implementing prior-robust Bayesian methods. We illustrate the broad applicability of the approach in an oil-market model identified using a rich set of sign, elasticity and narrative restrictions. JEL Classification Numbers: C32, Q35, Q43 Keywords: Bayesian inference, Markov Chain Monte Carlo, sign restrictions, structural vector autoregression. 1 Introduction Sign-restricted structural vector autoregressions (SVARs) are used extensively to estimate the effects of macroeconomic shocks. Researchers using sign restrictions typically work with the SVAR’s ‘orthogonal reduced-form’ parameterisation and conduct Bayesian inference under a uniform (Haar) prior on the orthonormal (rotation) matrix, \mathbf{Q} . 1 1 1 See the references in Baumeister and Hamilton 2018 for many examples. There is debate about the use of this prior. In set-identified models, a component of the prior is never updated ( Poirier 1998 ). This can result in posterior inference being asymptotically sensitive to the choice of prior and Bayesian credible sets lying strictly within frequentist confidence sets ( Moon and Schorfheide 2012 ; Baumeister and Hamilton 2024 ). These concerns tend to be negligible when identification is tight, which is the setting we focus on. Posterior sampling in this setting is almost universally implemented using accept-reject sampling (e.g. Uhlig 2005 ; Rubio-Ramírez et al. 2010 ; Arias et al. 2018 ). Sign restrictions generate an identified set for \mathbf{Q} , which is the set of observationally equivalent parameter values. Accept-reject sampling can be computationally demanding when the identified set has small measure – that is, when identification is tight. For example, in a model from Kilian and Murphy 2014 , Baumeister and Hamilton 2024 report that only 16 out of 5 million draws satisfy the identifying restrictions. In such cases, accurately approximating the posterior can require a very large number of proposal draws. This bottleneck is likely to intensify as applied work moves towards richer sets of identifying restrictions (e.g. Inoue and Kilian 2026 ). 2 2 2 Rich sets of identifying restrictions can mitigate the problem of ‘masquerading’ shocks, where linear combinations of shocks satisfy the sign restrictions ( Wolf 2020 ; Wolf 2022 ). This paper develops an approach to sampling \mathbf{Q} that addresses the bottleneck associated with accept-reject sampling. Its key feature is an initial sampling step based on ‘soft’ sign restrictions. The approach involves: 1) specifying a target distribution that smoothly penalises parameter values violating the sign restrictions; 2) using a Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm – the slice sampler (e.g. Neal 2003 ) – to draw from this target distribution; and 3) importance sampling to obtain uniform draws of \mathbf{Q} conditional on the (hard) sign restrictions. We emphasise that we do not conduct inference under a relaxed set of restrictions; the soft sign restrictions are a computational device to facilitate sampling under the hard restrictions. 3 3 3 For approaches to conducting Bayesian inference under non-dogmatic sign restrictions, see Baumeister and Hamilton 2018 ; Baumeister and Hamilton 2019 . Our approach delivers efficiency gains for two reasons. First, we sample from a smooth density that tends to assign higher probability to the identified set and smaller but nonzero probability outside the identified set. This means the sampler, when initialised outside the identified set, will tend to drift from its initial point towards the identified set. Second, once the sampler has moved within the identified set, it tends to remain there. By initially sampling from a computationally convenient approximation to the target density and then using importance sampling to obtain draws from the hard-truncated distribution, our approach is analogous to tempering, which is often used in Sequential Monte Carlo (e.g. Herbst and Schorfheide 2015 ). Existing approaches to uniform sampling of \mathbf{Q} under sign restrictions can in some cases be more efficient than accept-reject sampling, but are only applicable under certain classes of restrictions. Amir-Ahmadi and Drautzburg 2021 develop a Gibbs sampler that draws from a uniform distribution over the identified set for \mathbf{Q} . However, the sampler is not applicable when the sign restrictions constrain all columns of \mathbf{Q} (e.g. when there are restrictions on the impulse responses to all shocks) or when each restriction does not linearly constrain a single column of \mathbf{Q} . 4 4 4 Read 2022 extends this sampler to allow for zero restrictions. Chan et al. 2025 exploit invariance of the uniform distribution for \mathbf{Q} to column permutations and sign flips to efficiently generate draws that satisfy sign and ranking restrictions on impact responses. Their method can be combined with an accept-reject step to impose additional restrictions, though this will be costly if these restrictions substantially tighten identification. The gains from their method are largest in high-dimensional SVARs, as there are many possible permutations, while the gains are smaller in the lower-dimensional SVARs that we focus on. 5 5 5 Hou 2024 proposes an MCMC algorithm for posterior sampling under linear equality and inequality restrictions on impact impulse responses, with additional inequality restrictions implementable via an accept-reject step. The posterior corresponds to an independent Gaussian prior over the columns of the impact impulse-response matrix, rather than the uniform prior for \mathbf{Q} . In contrast with these existing approaches, our sampler can be directly applied when the identifying restrictions are nonlinear and/or constrain all columns of \mathbf{Q} , and can thus handle a wide variety of identifying restrictions, provided these take the form of inequalities. These include restrictions on: impulse responses (e.g. Uhlig 2005 ); structural coefficients (e.g. Arias et al. 2019 ); ratios of impulse responses and elasticities (e.g. Kilian and Murphy 2012 ; Baumeister and Hamilton 2024 ); long-run cumulative impulse responses (e.g. Furlanetto et al. 2025 ); and forecast error variance decompositions (e.g. Volpicella 2022 ). They are also applicable under: shape or ranking restrictions (e.g. Amir-Ahmadi and Drautzburg 2021 ); narrative restrictions (e.g. Ludvigson et al. 2017 ; Ludvigson et al. 2021 ; Antolín-Díaz and Rubio-Ramírez 2018 ); and restrictions on the relationship between proxies and structural shocks (e.g. Arias et al. 2021 ; Giacomini et al. 2022b ; Braun and Brüggemann 2023 ). In contemporaneous work, Arias