Mind the Gap: How the Technical Mechanisms of Agentic AI Outpace Global Legal Frameworks
Marcel Osmond, Thomas Jego · 2026
Read Mind the Gap: How the Technical Mechanisms of Agentic AI Outpace Global Legal Frameworks by Marcel Osmond, Thomas Jego (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-27075.txt.
Introduction
Osmond and Jego survey how regulators and industry define agentic AI, and find the definitions wrong on the tech. They compare eleven rulebooks and frameworks with six leading developer architectures. Legal texts conflate model capability with agentic architecture, the authors argue. They also credit token prediction with thinking. Autonomy appears as a simple scale, not a shift to looping, tool-using execution. The authors build a shared one from developer docs. Loose definitions, they warn, leave the real control points ungoverned.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marcel Osmond, Thomas Jego |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62197 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.27075
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mind the Gap: How the Technical Mechanisms of Agentic AI Outpace Global Legal Frameworks Marcel Osmond, Thomas Jego Abstract This article presents the first systematic comparative survey of how public bodies, international organisations, national regulators, and the private sector define agentic artificial intelligence, identifying the technical inaccuracies pervading each definition. Analysing eleven regulatory instruments and industry frameworks — including the EU AI Act, the OECD/G7 Principles, NIST, the UK ICO, and the European Commission — alongside six leading developer architectures, this study demonstrates a persistent definitional gap: legal definitions consistently conflate model capability with agentic architecture, attribute cognitive deliberation to probabilistic token prediction, and treat autonomy as a scalar property rather than a structural shift from single-inference to iterative execution loops with tool integration. A consensus technical definition synthesised from developer documentation is proposed. The article examines the consequences of this gap, demonstrating that definitional imprecision produces regulatory instruments structurally incapable of governing the actual mechanisms — system prompts, API permissions, sandboxing, and orchestration code — that constitute agentic autonomy. Time Complexity Legal frameworks Technical capability Gap Figure 1: Conceptual visualization of the widening gap between technological capability growth and regulatory development. K eywords Agentic AI \cdot AI Regulation \cdot Definitional Gap \cdot EU AI Act \cdot Autonomous Systems \cdot AI Governance 1 Introduction Artificial intelligence systems capable of autonomous, multi-step action — systems that can browse the web, execute code, query databases, send emails and interact with external services without human confirmation at each step — are no longer a theoretical prospect. They are being deployed commercially, integrated into professional workflows, and embedded in consumer products at a pace that has consistently outrun the regulatory frameworks nominally designed to govern them. This paper is concerned with a specific and foundational dimension of that governance gap: the failure of legal and policy definitions to accurately capture what agentic AI systems are, how they work, and where the real locus of risk and responsibility lies. The definitional question is not a preliminary technicality to be resolved before the serious legal analysis begins. It is the serious legal analysis. A regulatory framework that mischaracterises its subject matter will, by construction, generate compliance obligations calibrated to the wrong features of the technology. It will direct liability toward entities that do not control the relevant risks and away from those that do. It will require testing and certification procedures that cannot meaningfully be applied to systems whose behaviour is non-deterministic and dynamically generated. And it will create safe harbours — whether intentionally or not — for the specific architectural decisions that actually determine whether an agentic system causes harm. This paper demonstrates, through a systematic comparative survey of eleven regulatory instruments and policy frameworks, that this failure is not isolated or incidental. It is structural, recurrent, and traceable to identifiable methodological causes. The frameworks examined span four continents and include binding legislation, intergovernmental guidance, national regulatory authority publications and private sector documentation: the EU Artificial Intelligence Act; the European Data Protection Supervisor’s TechSonar guidance; the European Commission’s Agentic AI Landscape Report; the OECD Recommendation on Artificial Intelligence and the G7 Guiding Principles built upon it; the NIST AI Risk Management Framework; the UK Information Commissioner’s Office guidance on agentic AI; the Singapore Model AI Governance Framework; the New Zealand Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment’s Responsible AI Guidance; the New South Wales Government’s AI Agent Usage and Deployment Guidance; and the published academic framework of Maas and Olasunkanmi on Treaty-Following AI. These instruments were selected on the basis of their direct definitional engagement with autonomous or agentic AI systems and their significance within their respective regulatory traditions. To evaluate the technical accuracy of each definition, the paper draws on the developer documentation of six leading agentic AI developers — Anthropic, Google Cloud, OpenAI, Microsoft, C3.ai, and Meta — extracting from those sources the elements of agentic architecture on which technical consensus is clearest. This methodology grounds the critical analysis in the operational reality of deployed systems rather than in theoretical computer science abstraction, and produces, as a secondary contribution, a synthesised technical definition that regulatory drafters could adopt or adapt. The paper proceeds in three parts. Part I surveys each of the eleven frameworks in turn, identifying in each case the specific technical inaccuracy or architectural misunderstanding that produces what this paper terms the definitional gap . Part II synthesises these findings into four recurring categories of definitional failure — anthropomorphism, architectural conflation, the levels-of-autonomy fallacy, and the learning-and-memory myth — and examines the structural reasons why non-technical authorship processes systematically produce them. The conclusion draws out the legal consequences of the definitional gap and identifies the conditions for more technically adequate regulatory instruments. The paper’s original contribution is threefold. It is the first systematic comparative survey of agentic AI definitions across this range of jurisdictions and institutional contexts. It identifies and names four specific categories of definitional failure that recur across the corpus regardless of legal tradition or institutional origin. And it demonstrates that the consequence of these failures is a body of regulatory instruments that are simultaneously overbroad and underinclusive — reaching AI systems that pose no distinctive agentic risk while failing to govern the specific engineering decisions that determine the real-world risk profile of agentic deployments. 2 Legal and Policy Definitions of Agentic AI: A Comparative Survey and Technical Gap Analysis There is currently no widely adopted, binding legal definition of Agentic AI in major treaties, statutes, or regulations. Existing laws generally regulate these systems under broader ‘‘AI system,’’ 1 1 1 Andy Goldstein, Agentic AI, European Data Protection Supervisor. Accessible at: https://www.edps.europa.eu/data-protection/technology-monitoring/techsonar/agentic-ai_en automated system, or sectoral concepts rather than using “agentic” as a defined legal term. The following survey examines the principal definitions advanced by public bodies, international frameworks, national regulators, and the private sector, and identifies, in each case, the technical inaccuracies and architectural misunderstandings that produce what this paper terms the definitional gap . Synthesising the technical documentation of six leading agentic AI developers — Anthropic, Google Cloud, OpenAI, Microsoft, C3.ai, and Meta — and extracting those elements on which technical consensus is clearest, the following definition is proposed: ‘‘An agentic AI system is an autonomous computational system that pursues defined goals by autonomously perceiving context, planning, and executing multi-step actions --- through access to tools, external systems, and other agents --- with minimal human intervention once objectives are set, while adapting its behaviour based on human feedback and operating within prescribed instructions and guardrails.’’ 2 2 2 Google Cloud, Agentic AI (Google Cloud Documentation) available at: https://cloud.google.com/discover/what-is-agentic-ai , 3 3 3 Anthropic, Empirical Work on Agents (Anthropic Research) available at: https://www.anthropic.com/research/measuring-agent-autonomy , 4 4 4 OpenAI, Developer Documentation on Agents (OpenAI Developer Platform) available at: https://developers.openai.com/tracks/building-agents/ , 5 5 5 Microsoft, Agent Factory: The new era of agentic AI (Microsoft Azure) available at: https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/blog/agent-factory-the-new-era-of-agentic-ai-common-use-cases-and-design-patterns/ , 6 6 6 C3.ai, Agentic System Architecture (C3.ai Documentation) available at: https://c3.ai/blog/agentic-ai-explained/ , 7 7 7 Meta, AI Security Research (Meta AI Research) available at: https://ai.meta.com/blog/practical-ai-agent-security/ By defining agentic AI as Level 4 or 5 systems, regulators effectively create a de facto safe harbour for Level 3 autonomous agents — systems that use a single model to plan and execute multi-step actions