Unequal Mass Binary Evolution Driven by High Mach Circumbinary Disks 2026 Unequal Mass Binary Evolution Driven by High Mach Circumbinary Disks – A

Madeline Clyburn, Jonathan Zrake · 2026

Read Unequal Mass Binary Evolution Driven by High Mach Circumbinary Disks 2026 Unequal Mass Binary Evolution Driven by High Mach Circumbinary Disks – A by Madeline Clyburn, Jonathan Zrake (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-27022.txt.

Introduction

Clyburn and Zrake simulate how gas disks steer unequal-mass black hole binaries. Two-dimensional hydrodynamics runs follow the binaries for a thousand orbits at fixed separation. Mass ratios range from 0.05 to 1, with varied disk Mach number and viscosity. Equal-mass pairs gain orbital energy in slow disks but lose it above Mach 25. That flip moves to higher Mach numbers as the mass ratio drops. Light secondaries cannot push the disk away and swallow most inflow instead. Such pairs tend to spiral outward in viscous disks.

Catalog record

CREATORMadeline Clyburn, Jonathan Zrake
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53733
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.27022

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unequal Mass Binary Evolution Driven by High Mach Circumbinary Disks 2026 Unequal Mass Binary Evolution Driven by High Mach Circumbinary Disks – A Madeline Clyburn, Jonathan Zrake Abstract We present a study of the gas-driven orbital evolution of unequal mass black hole binaries with circumbinary gas disks (CBDs), varying Mach number ( ℳ \mathcal{M} ) and viscosity ( ν \mathcal{\nu} ). Using two-dimensional grid-based hydrodynamics simulations spanning a thousand binary orbits at fixed separation, we explore low to moderate mass ratios ( q = 0.05 q=0.05 – 1.0 1.0 ) and examine how variations in ℳ \mathcal{M} and q q affect the torques and component accretion rates exerted by the CBD and consequently the binary evolution. Equal mass binary systems receive positive torques in low- ℳ \mathcal{M} disks but transition to negative torques for ℳ ≳ 25 \mathcal{M}\gtrsim 25 . As q q decreases, the transition moves to higher Mach numbers. For q < 0.1 q<0.1 , we find no torque sign reversal below ℳ ≈ 52 \mathcal{M}\approx 52 , except in sufficiently low-viscosity disks. We find that the secondary black hole cannot effectively repel the CBD, it instead accretes most of the inflowing gas from the CBD; these low mass ratio binaries in high viscosity disks therefore tend to outspiral, although inspiral can occur in less viscous environments. We also find that binaries with mass ratios in the range of 0.25 − 0.5 0.25-0.5 can show preferential accretion favoring the primary when the gas viscosity is low, exemplifying an exception to the established rule of thumb that accretion favors the secondary. We discuss differences between our results and those reported in the literature on the orbital evolution and preferential accretion, and emphasize that our simulations extend into a regime that remains largely unexplored. Overall, our results suggest that intermediate mass ratio inspirals (IMRIs) in CBDs may be less frequent, but this depends sensitively on the interplay between mass ratio, disk temperature, and viscosity. 1 Introduction Most, if not all, massive galaxies host a central massive or supermassive black hole with mass M\simeq 10^{6}-10^{10}\ M ⊙ ( 17 ; 42 , e.g.,) . Additionally, major galaxy mergers occur frequently in our universe, and when two galaxies merge, their central black holes are expected to eventually form a massive black hole binary (MBHB) on timescales of \sim 1 Gyr ( 4 ; 70 ; 16 ; 39 ; 41 ) . These MBHBs will likely reside within the gas-rich environments of active galactic nuclei (AGN) ( 3 ) and may thus be surrounded by an accretion disk. As the binary interacts with gas and stars most of these MBHBs are believed to contract until gravitational waves (GWs) drive the binary to coalescence ( 4 ) . The upcoming space-based GW detector, LISA , will observe the GWs emitted by MBHBs in the final years to hours of their lives ( 59 , e.g.,) . Through GW de-phasing, these GW detections may also reveal the presence of a circumbinary disk (CBD), offering a unique opportunity for multi-messenger astronomy ( 37 ; 12 ; 11 ; 38 ; 66 , e.g.,) . Furthermore, identifying the electromagnetic (EM) counterparts to MBHB mergers will provide insight into the nature of accretion flows, the morphology of host galaxies, and the environments in which MBHBs evolve. A growing body of literature has begun to explore the expected EM signatures of MBHB inspirals for both equal and unequal mass systems ( 26 ; 27 ; 25 ; 23 ; 52 ; 65 ; 33 ; 2 ; 44 ; 57 ; 7 ; 28 ; 6 ; 73 , see) . Nevertheless, despite decades of study, there remains significant uncertainty regarding whether binary–disk interactions can effectively shrink the binary orbit to separations where GWs can drive a merger within a Hubble time. This longstanding issue, commonly referred to as the “final parsec problem” ( 47 , e.g.,) , hinges on whether the CBD extracts or supplies angular momentum to the binary, thereby determining whether the system merges efficiently or stalls at sub-parsec scales. Early analytical and numerical work generally supported the idea that gas torques remove angular momentum from the binary, accelerating inspiral and eventual coalescence ( 64 ; 32 ; 1 ; 46 ; 8 ; 34 ; 61 ; 40 ; 56 ; 54 ; 48 ; 30 , e.g.,) . However, more recent simulations have challenged this view, showing that the binary net torque can become positive ( 51 ; 49 ; 50 ; 19 ; 13 ; 20 , e.g.,) . In this case, the binary gains angular momentum from the disk, leading to orbital expansion or even long-term stalling. 68 helped clarify this result by showing that the direction of angular momentum transfer depends sensitively on the disk’s structure. In particular, they found that equal mass ( q=1.0 ) binaries in relatively warm disks ( \mathcal{M}=10 ) can experience positive torques and outspiral, while thinner and cooler disks ( \mathcal{M}\gtrsim 35 ) tend to be negatively torqued and thus, inspiral. Subsequent studies have reinforced this picture, demonstrating that the balance between inspiral and outspiral is controlled by a combination of parameters, including gas temperature, disk mass, viscosity, binary eccentricity, and mass ratio ( 35 ; 30 ; 14 ; 29 ; 53 ; 62 ; 15 ; 69 , e.g.,) . This sensitivity underscores the complex and still poorly understood role of disk–binary coupling in MBHB evolution. Understanding the physical conditions that govern the direction of angular momentum transfer is essential not only for determining whether gas-assisted mergers can solve the final parsec problem, but also for predicting the GW and EM signatures of MBHBs observable by LISA . To our knowledge, only two studies have begun to explore how binaries evolve in the low mass ratio, high Mach number regime. 53 first investigated this parameter space, considering binaries with q=0.1-1.0 and disk Mach numbers up to \mathcal{M}=40 . Building on this, 15 extended the study to mass ratios as low as q=0.01 , and disk Mach numbers up to \mathcal{M}=30 . Both works reported a similar torque trend to the equal mass case described in 68 : at sufficiently high Mach numbers, unequal mass binaries generally experience net negative torques and inspiral. However, in the mass ratio range of 0.01\lesssim q\lesssim 0.05 , low mass ratio binaries were found to have net positive torques up to \mathcal{M}=30 and thus outspiral ( 15 ) . Whether this outspiraling trend for low mass ratio binaries persists at higher Mach numbers ( \mathcal{M}>30 ) remains unknown. Yet this question is astrophysically significant, as observations indicate that AGN accretion disks are typically cooler and thinner, with h/r\simeq 10^{-2}-10^{-3} , corresponding to Mach numbers in the range \mathcal{M}\equiv(h/r)^{-1}\simeq 100-1,000 ( 60 ; 45 ; 36 , e.g.,) . Moreover, a large fraction of the MBHB population is expected to have unequal masses ( 58 ; 5 ) . Understanding how angular momentum is exchanged in this regime is crucial, as unequal mass binaries with thin, cool disks are predicted to dominate the observable MBHB population and future LISA detections ( 31 , e.g., ) . In addition to binary migration behavior, the distribution of gas accretion between

Read the complete text