Algo Pärt: An Algorithmic Reconstruction of Arvo Pärt’s Summa

2026

Read Algo Pärt: An Algorithmic Reconstruction of Arvo Pärt’s Summa (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26989.txt.

Introduction

Cornelissen reconstructs Arvo Pärt's Summa with an algorithm to test how rule-based the piece is. Pärt's tintinnabuli works follow precise procedures, and Summa is his most strictly built piece. The author formalizes its voice rules as tintinnabuli processes. The generated score matches over 93 percent of the original notes. Because the voices interlock, fixing half the errors restores the score fully. Only 3.5 percent of notes need correction in the end. The study shows Summa is largely an algorithmic composition.

Catalog record

YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47580
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26989

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Algo Pärt: An Algorithmic Reconstruction of Arvo Pärt’s Summa Abstract Arvo Pärt is one of the most popular contemporary composers, known for his highly original tintinnabuli style. Works in this style are typically composed according to precise procedures and have even been described as algorithmic compositions. To understand how algorithmic Pärt’s music exactly is, this paper presents an analysis by synthesis : it proposes an algorithm that almost completely reconstructs the score of Summa , his “most strictly constructed and most encrypted work,” according to Pärt himself in 1994. The piece is analyzed and then formalized using so-called tintinnabuli processes. An implementation of the resulting algorithm generates a musical score matching Summa in over 93% of the notes. Due to interdependencies between the voices, only half of the mistakes (3,5%) need to be corrected to reproduce the original score faithfully. This study shows that Summa is a largely algorithmic composition and offers new perspectives on the music of Arvo Pärt. keywords Arvo Pärt; Summa ; tintinnabuli; computational music analysis; analysis by synthesis; score synthesis; algorithmic reconstruction; algorithmic composition 1 Introduction Music and algorithms share a long history, but rarely has their marriage been as fruitful as it has been in the hands of the Estonian composer Arvo Pärt. According to one study, Pärt was the most frequently performed contemporary composer from 2011 until 2019. 1 1 endnote: 1 This is based on data released by Bachtrack, a classical music website that tracks many thousands of concerts every year. The website annually releases statistics about concert performances, including the most performed classical composer. In the year 2018 ( bachtrack.com/classical-music-statistics-2018 ), these statistics were based on almost 20.000 concerts, in which Pärt was the top contemporary composers, as he had been since 2011 (see bachtrack.com/classical-music-statistics-2017 ). In 2019, John Williams came out first, with Pärt second. Not only is his music popular, but it is also highly original. In the 1970s, Pärt developed a unique compositional technique, known as tintinnabuli , that is deeply algorithmical due to its use of numerical procedures. The main melody may, for example, walk down a scale, moving one step further with every measure. Alternatively, it may be determined by the text: in his Missa Sillabica , the number of syllables in a word determines the melody for that word. Examples such as these raise the question how algorithmic Pärt’s music precisely is. Can all notes in a score be explained by formal procedures? And when does the composer deviate from those, if at all? To address such questions, I propose a type of computational music analysis (cf. 1 ) that one could call analysis by synthesis . Motivated by the idea that one cannot understand what one cannot create, the aim is to implement an algorithm that reconstructs as much of a score as possible. By measuring the reconstruction error , the number of errors in the reconstructed score, one can evaluate the algorithm. In practice, such an analysis is an iterative process in which one successively refines the rules to further reduce the reconstruction error. As the error decreases, the explanatory power of the algorithm increases, until adding new rules no longer seems to be theoretically productive. Adding a rule that explains only a single note, for example, is not very productive and similar to ‘overfitting’ a mathematical model. But up to that point, the algorithm provides an answer to a central question of musical analysis: how does the piece work? The idea of using algorithms to analyze Pärt’s music is not new. 2 2 endnote: 2 I found two conference papers that use small fragments of Pärt’s compositions as examples in a live coding setting ( 2 ; 15 ) . 10 cites a script by Christopher Ariza and Michael Scott Cuthbert that generates a score for Pärt’s Pari Intervallo , which can indeed be found in an old release of music21: github.com/changtailiang/music21/blob/master/music21/composition/phasing.py . David Cope appears to have discussed Cantus in Memoriam Benjamin Britten in a course on computer-assisted composition in 2008. 5 presented a poster that modelled Spiegel im Spiegel in OpenMusic (see also 17 ) . Outside the academic literature, Guy Birkin in 2015 released the album Tintinnabuli Mathematica vol. I with music generated in Mathematica using tintinnabuli rules and number sequences. He explains the process in a blog post available at aestheticcomplexity.wordpress.com/2011/11/11/programming-arvo-part . 18 describes multiple constructions commonly found in the work of Pärt using concepts borrowed from programming languages, such as loops. 17 then went on to implement several models of Pärt’s compositions. In a more formal analysis, 14 proposes to understand Pärt’s compositional procedures as musical transformations (cf. 11 ) . His analysis effectively results in several (functional) programs that model certain aspects of Pärt’s music. This paper takes these ideas one step further by first formalizing a piece, then implementing an algorithm to reconstruct the full score, and finally quantitatively evaluating that against the original: a complete analysis by synthesis. Our case study looks at Summa . This piece was written in 1977, one year after Pärt wrote his first piece in tintinnabuli style ( Für Alina ). Summa is best known as a composition for mixed choir or solo voices but was originally written for two voices (tenor and bass) and six instruments ( 8 ) . It has since been adapted for many instrumental combinations, from string quartet to trombone quartet. The composition is intricately structured, but many of the underlying regularities will escape notice when listening to a performance, or even when studying the score. Indeed, some of the procedures identified in this paper seem to have escaped previous analyses of Summa ( 6 ; 8 ; 13 ) . Arvo Pärt may have anticipated this when he wrote: I have developed a highly formal compositional system in which I have been writing my music for 20 years. In this series, Summa is the most strictly constructed and most encrypted work. The encryptions are found in many layers of the score. 3 3 endnote: 3 My translation. It is instructive to read his comment in full: Ich habe große Schwierigkeiten, wenn ich meine Werke kommentieren soll. Ich bin dafür, daß zwischen Wort und Musik ein besonders behutsames Verhältnis sein muß. Wir müssen der Musik eine Chance geben, sich allein auszudrücken. Wörter treiben die Musik in die Enge. Und auch die Musik neigt dazu, sich von Wörtern abhängig zu machen. Ich sehe in dieser »überkommunizierten« Gesellschaft Gefahr für die Existenz der Musik. Ich muß in mir Raum frei lassen für Musik, und wenn dieser Raum mit Worten besetzt wird, bleibt mir kein Bedürfnis, mich mit Musik auszudrücken — und umgekehrt: wenn ich ein Musikwerk geschrieben habe, bleibt nichts mehr mit Worten zu sagen übrig. \displaystyle\star\hskip 8.50012pt\star\hskip 8.50012pt\star Ich habe ein hochformalisiertes Kompositionssystem entwickelt, in dem ich seit 20 Jahren meine Musik schreibe. In dieser Reihe ist Summa das strengstgebaute und verschlüsselste Werk. Die Verschlüsselungen finden sich in vielen Schichten der Partitur. (Berlin, den 15.6.1994) ( 12 ) I read this as an invitation to decrypt Summa . But first, let me introduce the tintinnabuli style and the terminology that 7 ; 8 developed to describe it—some of which Pärt himself has adopted. 2 Tintinnabuli At

Read the complete text