Obstructions to Smooth Full-Holonomy Cayley Fibrations
Viktor Majewski, Jacek Rzemieniecki · 2026
Read Obstructions to Smooth Full-Holonomy Cayley Fibrations by Viktor Majewski, Jacek Rzemieniecki (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26920.txt.
Introduction
Lin and co-authors prove that smooth Cayley fibrations with full holonomy cannot exist. The setting is a compact torsion-free Spin(7)-manifold with full holonomy. Every Cayley fibration of such a manifold, they show, must have singular fibers. That confirms a long-standing expectation for calibrated fibrations with exceptional holonomy. Rigidity of the Spin(7) structure first cuts any smooth example down to two topological cases. A new spinnability theorem then rules out both cases. The hardest case uses families Seiberg-Witten theory and equivariant methods.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Viktor Majewski, Jacek Rzemieniecki |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31822 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26920
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Obstructions to Smooth Full-Holonomy Cayley Fibrations Viktor Majewski, Jacek Rzemieniecki Abstract We study smooth fibrations of compact torsion-free Spin ( 7 ) {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -manifolds by Cayley submanifolds. Using geometric and topological constraints coming from the Spin ( 7 ) {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -structure, we show that only two topological configurations can arise. One of these is excluded by a spinnability criterion for fiber bundles, with the relevant hypothesis verified using gauge-theoretic input, while the remaining case is reduced to an open conjecture in 4 4 -manifold topology. In particular, this rules out smooth Cayley fibrations on all known examples of compact torsion-free Spin ( 7 ) {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -manifolds. 1 Introduction Manifolds with exceptional holonomy provide a fundamental class of Riemannian manifolds with rigid geometric structure. In dimension eight, torsion-free {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -manifolds are characterized by a parallel Cayley calibration, whose calibrated submanifolds are volume-minimizing 4 -dimensional submanifolds. This naturally leads to the question of whether such manifolds contain global fibrations by Cayley submanifolds, and to what extent the existence of such a fibration is compatible with full {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -holonomy. These fibrations are the {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -analogues of special Lagrangian fibrations in Calabi-Yau geometry and coassociative fibrations in G_{2} -geometry. A guiding principle in all these settings is that global fibrations by calibrated submanifolds are highly constrained and typically forced to develop singularities. This phenomenon is already visible in G_{2} -geometry. In the study of semi-flat G_{2} -manifolds and their coassociative fibrations, Baraglia 2 showed that full G_{2} -holonomy manifolds fibering over a 3 -manifold necessarily admit singular fibers, providing strong evidence that singularities are an intrinsic feature of fibrations of manifolds with full exceptional holonomy. Motivated by this picture, the following {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -version is conjectured to be true ( 13 , p. 1) : Conjecture 1.1 . A torsion-free {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -manifold with full holonomy does not admit a smooth Cayley fibration. The adiabatic limit program of Donaldson 10 for special holonomy manifolds is formulated in a setting where calibrated fibrations necessarily involve singular fibers. Similarly, Englebert’s recent construction of the first examples of calibrated fibrations on closed exceptional-holonomy manifolds 11 , 12 , 13 also include singular fibers as a necessary part of the picture. The goal of this paper is to make this expectation precise and to provide strong evidence for the non-existence of smooth Cayley fibrations with full Spin(7)-holonomy. Theorem 1.2 . Suppose that X is a closed full-holonomy {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -manifold which admits a smooth Cayley fibration. Then the fibration can be written as \pi:X\to B where the base B and the fiber are homeomorphic to \#^{3}\overline{\mathbb{CP}}^{2} and K3\#K3\#(S^{2}\times S^{2}) , respectively. Consequently, it holds that (b^{2}(X),b^{3}(X),b^{4}_{+}(X),b^{4}_{-}(X))=(49,0,118,22) . In particular, this shows that all the known examples 20 , 21 , 25 of closed full-holonomy {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -manifolds do not admit nonsingular Cayley fibrations. Moreover, Cayley fibrations with K3 fibers need to have singularities, as anticipated by 10 and 13 . Finally, inspired by the recent advances in understanding mapping class groups of 4 -manifolds 3 , 4 , 23 , 24 , 29 , we state the following conjecture. Conjecture 1.3 . Suppose that F is a smooth manifold homeomorphic to K3\#K3\#(S^{2}\times S^{2}) . Then F\setminus B admits a nontrivial boundary Dehn twist, where B\subset F is a small 4 -ball. In view of Lemma 4.3 and Proposition A.3 , the following is an immediate corollary of Theorem 1.2 . Corollary 1.4 . Conjecture 1.3 implies Conjecture 1.1 . This connection is further elaborated upon in Section 4 and Appendix A . Acknowledgments: The authors thank Thomas Walpuski for insightful discussions and comments on a draft of this article, Johannes Nordström for valuable comments on an earlier version of this article, and David Baraglia and Scotty Tilton for helpful correspondence. This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) under Germany’s Excellence Strategy through the Berlin Mathematics Research Center MATH+ (EXC-2046/2, project ID: 390685689). 2 Spin(7)-Background Let (W,g) be an eight dimensional Euclidean vector space. The group {\mathrm{Spin}}(W,g)\cong\mathrm{Spin}(8) has three real eight-dimensional representations: the vector representation on the Euclidean space (W,g) , and two chiral spinor representations \mathbb{S}^{+}_{g} and \mathbb{S}^{-}_{g} . Both \mathbb{S}^{+}_{g} and \mathbb{S}^{-}_{g} can be endowed with \mathrm{Spin}(8) -invariant inner products, such that the Clifford multiplication \displaystyle\mathrm{cl}_{g}\colon W\rightarrow\mathrm{End}(\mathbb{S}^{+}_{g},\mathbb{S}^{-}_{g})\oplus\mathrm{End}(\mathbb{S}^{-}_{g},\mathbb{S}^{+}_{g}) is skew-adjoint. Given a unit length positive spinor \psi_{g}\in\mathbb{S}^{+} , we can identify both \displaystyle\mathrm{cl}_{g}(\bullet)\psi_{g}\colon W\cong\mathbb{S}^{-}_{g}\hskip 28.45274pt\text{and}\hskip 28.45274pt{\mathrm{Stab}}(\psi_{g})\cong{\mathrm{Spin}}(7). Since {\mathrm{Stab}}(\psi_{g}) fixes the Euclidean structure on (W,g) we deduce that {\mathrm{Spin}}(7)\subset{\mathrm{SO}}(8) . Using \psi_{g} we can define the Cayley form \displaystyle\Phi\coloneqq\left<\psi_{g},{\mathrm{cl}}^{4}_{g}\circ\psi_{g}\right>\in\wedge^{4}W^{*}. The stabilizer of \Phi under the {\mathrm{GL}}(W) action on \wedge^{4}W^{*} agrees with {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) and (up to a sign) we can recover \psi_{g} and g from the associated Cayley form. The exterior algebra \wedge^{\bullet}W^{*} decomposes into the following {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -representations \displaystyle\wedge^{0}W^{*}\cong\wedge^{0}_{1},\hskip 28.45274pt\wedge^{1}W^{*}\cong\wedge^{1}_{\Phi,8} \displaystyle\,\hskip 28.45274pt\wedge^{2}W^{*}\cong\wedge^{2}_{\Phi,21}\oplus\wedge^{2}_{\Phi,7},\hskip 28.45274pt\wedge^{3}W^{*}\cong\wedge^{3}_{\Phi,8}\oplus\wedge^{3}_{\Phi,48} and \displaystyle\wedge^{4}W^{*}\cong\wedge^{4}_{\Phi,1}\oplus\wedge^{4}_{\Phi,7}\oplus\wedge^{4}_{\Phi,27}\oplus\wedge^{4}_{\Phi,35} indexed by their dimension, such that \wedge^{k}_{\Phi,\rho}\cong\wedge^{k^{\prime}}_{\Phi,\rho} and moreover \wedge^{k}W^{*}\cong\wedge^{8-k}W^{*} . The Cayley form is an example of a (linear) calibration and satisfies the calibration equality \displaystyle|P|^{2}=\Phi(P)^{2}+|\pi_{\psi_{g}^{\perp}}({\mathrm{cl}}_{g}(P))\psi_{g}|^{2} for all oriented four planes P . Such a four plane will be referred to as a Cayley plane if \displaystyle\Phi(P)=1\hskip 28.45274pt\text{or equivalently}\hskip 28.45274pt\pi_{\psi_{g}^{\perp}}({\mathrm{cl}}_{g}(P))\psi_{g}=0. Remark 2.1 . In particular, a four plane P is Cayley if and only if P^{\perp} is Cayley and the stabilizer of a Cayley plane decomposition of W\cong P\oplus P^{\perp} is isomorphic to {\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{\top}{\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{+}{\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{\perp}\cong({\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{\top}\times{\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{+}\times{\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{\perp})/\mathbb{Z}_{2} . Here, the factor {\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{\top}{\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{+} acts as {\mathrm{SO}}(P) and {\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{+}{\mathrm{Sp}}(1)_{\perp} as {\mathrm{SO}}(P^{\perp}) . Let X be a spinnable Riemannian 8 -manifold. We identify the bundle \displaystyle{\mathrm{Cay}}_{+}(X)\coloneqq{\mathrm{Fr}}_{+}(X)/{\mathrm{Spin}}(7) with a (codimension 27) subbundle of four forms \wedge^{4}T^{*}X . Any smooth section, referred to as a Cayley form on X , yields a {\mathrm{Spin}}(7)\hookrightarrow{\mathrm{SO}}(8) -reduction \displaystyle{\mathrm{Fr}}(X,\Phi)\hookrightarrow{\mathrm{Fr}}_{+}(X,g_{\Phi}) of the normed oriented frame bundle of associated to the Riemannian metric (X,g_{\Phi}) , by pulling back the bundle {\mathrm{Fr}}_{+}(X)\rightarrow{\mathrm{Cay}}_{+}(X) . If \Phi is parallel with respect to the Levi-Civita connection \nabla^{g_{\Phi}} , then by the holonomy principle {\mathrm{Hol}}(g_{\Phi})\subset{\mathrm{Spin}}(7) . The holonomy group {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) appears in the Berger-list 5 of possible holonomy groups, together with the group G_{2} , the two exceptional classes. Their existence has been proven locally 6 and later in the compact case 20 . Theorem 2.2 . 20 Let (X,\Phi) be a torsion-free {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -manifold. Then it is full-holonomy {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) , i.e. {\mathrm{Hol}}(g_{\Phi})={\mathrm{Spin}}(7) if and only \displaystyle\pi_{1}(X)=1\hskip 28.45274pt\text{and}\hskip 28.45274pt\hat{A}(X)=1. Both imply that b^{1}(X)=b^{1}_{\Phi,8}(X) and b^{2}_{\Phi,7}(X)=0 . In this case, the \Phi -intersection pairing \displaystyle\left<\bullet,\bullet\right>_{\Phi}\colon{\mathrm{H}}^{2}(X;\mathbb{R})^{\otimes 2}\rightarrow\mathbb{R},\,(\alpha\otimes\beta)\mapsto\left<\alpha\cup\beta\cup\Phi\right> is negative-definite. Fernández 14 proved that the property of being parallel with the respect to itself is equivalent to the four form being closed. Consequently, torsion free {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -structures are examples of calibrated structures in the sense of 19 . An embedded four dimensional submanifold \iota\colon C\hookrightarrow(X,\Phi) is called calibrated, or Cayley submanifold , if \iota^{*}\Phi={\mathrm{vol}}_{\iota^{*}g}\hskip 28.45274pt\text{or equivalently}\hskip 28.45274pt{\mathrm{cl}}_{g}({\mathrm{vol}}_{\iota^{*}g})\iota^{*}\psi=\iota^{*}\psi. Moreover, the calibration property implies that Cayley submanifolds are always volume minimizing in their respective homology classes. The deformation theory of Cayley submanifolds is elliptic ( 27 , Section 6) and the virtual dimension of their moduli space equals v\dim(\mathcal{C}ay(C,X,\Phi))=\frac{\sigma(C)+\chi(C)}{2}-\iota_{*}[C]\cdot\iota_{*}[C] . Definition 2.3 . Let (X,\Phi) be a torsion-free {\mathrm{Spin}}(7) -manifold, assume that there exists a smooth map \pi\colon X\rightarrow B to a compact four manifold such that the fibers \iota_{b}\colon\pi^{-1}(b)\hookrightarrow X are all Cayley submanifolds. Then we refer to (X,\Phi,\pi) as a Cayley fibration . 3 Restricting the Topological Type of Smooth Cayley