Axion EFT in the BMHV Scheme: Flavor Currents, Evanescent Operators and Ward Identities
Deepanshu Bisht, Sabyasachi Chakraborty, and Atanu Samanta · 2026
Read Axion EFT in the BMHV Scheme: Flavor Currents, Evanescent Operators and Ward Identities by Deepanshu Bisht, Sabyasachi Chakraborty, and Atanu Samanta (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26880.txt.
Introduction
Bisht and co-authors work out axion effective field theory in the BMHV renormalization scheme. That scheme treats the gamma-five matrix in a way that breaks naive Ward identities. Evanescent operators appear and feed into the identity violations. The authors derive bare and renormalized identities for chiral flavor currents. Diagram checks confirm the identities up to two loops in the strong coupling. They also find the finite renormalization that restores the four-dimensional identities. The result gives a consistent base for multi-loop axion calculations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Deepanshu Bisht, Sabyasachi Chakraborty, and Atanu Samanta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 79850 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26880
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Axion EFT in the BMHV Scheme: Flavor Currents, Evanescent Operators and Ward Identities Deepanshu Bisht, Sabyasachi Chakraborty, and Atanu Samanta Abstract We present a systematic analysis of axion effective field theory within the Breitenlohner–Maison–’t Hooft–Veltman (BMHV) scheme, focusing on the renormalization of fermionic dimension-five operators and the associated chiral flavor currents. In this framework, the non-anticommuting nature of γ 5 \gamma_{5} in d ≠ 4 d\neq 4 dimensions leads to violations of naive Ward identities through the emergence of evanescent operators. We derive the bare and renormalized Ward identities for chiral currents, explicitly identifying the equation-of-motion and evanescent operator contributions. Using diagrammatic calculations, we verify the validity of these identities up to two-loop order 𝒪 ( α s 2 ) \mathcal{O}(\alpha_{s}^{2}) , including both pole and finite terms. We demonstrate how evanescent operators mix into physical operators and determine the finite renormalization required to restore four-dimensional Ward identities, recovering the expected structure of axial current renormalization and the anomaly. Our results provide a consistent and transparent framework for multi-loop computations in axion EFT and highlight the essential role of evanescent operators in maintaining scheme consistency. 1 Introduction It is a well-established principle that any scheme dependence arising in quantum field theory calculations must cancel in physical observables. This includes, for example, the dependence on the renormalization-scheme, associated with the choice of counterterms used to subtract ultraviolet divergences, as well as the dependence of the gauge, which must disappear from all measurable quantities. In this sense, regularization-scheme dependence is no exception. Among the available methods, dimensional regularization is particularly popular due to its powerful theoretical properties and its practicality in multi-loop computations. However, dimensional regularization itself admits several a priori non-equivalent prescriptions. With the steadily increasing precision of modern high-energy experiments, it has become essential to scrutinize the robustness of theoretical predictions obtained within specific dimensional-regularization schemes. In particular, one must verify that the physical observables and amplitudes computed in different schemes agree to any fixed order in perturbation theory. The most commonly used regularization prescription is Naive Dimensional Regularization (NDR) Chanowitz:1979zu , in which both the Dirac algebra and the spacetime metric are continued to d=4-2\epsilon dimensions. Although this approach is computationally convenient, the extension of the chiral matrix \gamma_{5} to d\neq 4 dimensions is inherently ambiguous Martin:1999cc (see Appendix C for more details). In contrast, the Breitenlohner–Maison–’t Hooft–Veltman (BMHV) scheme tHooft:1972tcz ; Breitenlohner:1975hg ; Breitenlohner:1976te ; Breitenlohner:1977hr provides a mathematically consistent framework by explicitly splitting the Dirac algebra into a four-dimensional subspace (represented by tilde ) and an evanescent \epsilon -dimensional component such as \gamma^{\mu}=\widetilde{\gamma}^{\mu}+\widehat{\gamma}^{\mu}\;,\quad g^{\mu\nu}=\widetilde{g}^{\mu\nu}+\widehat{g}^{\mu\nu}\;,\quad p^{\mu}=\widetilde{p}^{\mu}+\widehat{p}^{\mu}\;, (1) see Appendix A for more details on the algebra and relevant identities of the BMHV scheme. This construction ensures consistency to all orders in perturbation theory. Nevertheless, the BMHV scheme introduces additional technical complications: in particular, the explicit separation of dimensions leads to the breaking of Ward/Slavnov–Taylor identities. These violations must be compensated for by the introduction of suitable finite counterterms in order to restore the symmetries of the theory and obtain physically meaningful results. In recent years, conceptual ingredients necessary for the consistent application of the BMHV scheme have received a great deal of attention. For example, a systematic analysis of the BMHV scheme in the context of renormalizable chiral gauge theories was presented recently in Belusca-Maito:2023wah . The main motivation for that work was the conceptual importance of employing a consistent and robust dimensional regularization framework. Within this approach, the Slavnov Taylor identities are imposed to determine the finite counterterms required to restore gauge symmetry order by order in perturbation theory. In a related study, Ref. Cornella:2022hkc derived the one-loop finite counterterms of the Standard Model in the BMHV scheme using the background field method. In addition, a systematic discussion of evanescent operators in effective field theory (EFT) was provided in Fuentes-Martin:2022vvu . Together, these works establish the conceptual ingredients necessary for applying the BMHV scheme in modern applications. Although the emphasis is primarily on formal aspects, further developments are required to facilitate their use in concrete phenomenological calculations. In the recent past, given the widespread use of effective field theories in phenomenological studies involving Standard Model (SM) or Beyond-the-standard model (BSM) frameworks, it is important to employ a robust and self-consistent regularization scheme, such as the BMHV, in practical EFT calculations. This also provides a natural framework for a systematic analysis of the scheme dependence. Indeed, much of the early literature on SM processes and weak decays relevant for low-energy collider phenomenology pursued similar objectives Buras:1989xd ; Buras:1992zv . These studies focused on effective dimension-six operators and their loop corrections. In this context, evanescent operators were first identified and incorporated into practical EFT computations. Their appearance was associated with the breakdown of Fierz identities, which are no longer valid in dimensionally regularized theories away from four dimensions. The inclusion of evanescent operators was shown, for example, to affect the anomalous dimensions of physical operators starting at the two-loop level. The general relations between the scheme-dependent quantities were then derived and verified diagrammatically, ultimately obtaining reliable, scheme-independent physical results Ciuchini:1993ks ; Ciuchini:1993vr . More recent work has emphasized the systematic identification and treatment of Fierz-related evanescent operators in effective theories such as SMEFT and LEFT Fuentes-Martin:2022vvu ; Naterop:2023dek ; Naterop:2025lzc , often employing functional techniques Fuentes-Martin:2023ljp . On the other hand, in renormalizable settings where dimensional regularization was used in deep-inelastic scattering, it was recognized that a robust treatment of \gamma_{5} is needed to renormalize fermion currents. The foundational work by Collins Collins:1984xc provided a transparent understanding by demonstrating that BMHV breaks current Ward identities through explicit tree-level evanescent operators living in the \epsilon -dimensional subspace. By computing one-loop \mathcal{O}(\alpha_{s}) insertions of the evanescent operators into matrix elements with external fermions, an extra finite renormalization of the \overline{\text{MS}} -renormalized currents is obtained and the four-dimensional renormalized Ward identities are restored in BMHV. With one-loop finite renormalized current, Bos:1992nd soon explicitly verified the Ward identity (WI) at two-loop \mathcal{O}(\alpha_{s}^{2}) using matrix elements with gluon final states. In a classic study Larin:1993tq , Larin computed finite renormalization of the currents up to \mathcal{O}(\alpha_{s}^{3}) with gluon final states in a \gamma_{5} prescription by imposing finite renormalized currents to satisfy renormalized four-dimensional Ward identities. This method has been developed up to \mathcal{O}(\alpha_{s}^{5}) Chen:2022lun , although thus far they have been applied primarily to Standard Model perturbative calculations or lattice QCD studies Martinelli:1994ty ; Bhattacharya:2015rsa . A possible application of the BMHV scheme arises in the study of axions and axion-like particles (ALP), which also have attracted considerable interest due to their potential to resolve the strong- CP problem tHooft:1976rip , their role as viable candidates for cold dark matter Preskill:1982cy ; Dine:1982ah ; Abbott:1982af , their potential relevance to matter-antimatter asymmetry Co:2019wyp ; Chakraborty:2021fkp , and implications for the hierarchy problem Graham:2015cka ; Hook:2016mqo ; Trifinopoulos:2022tfx . Moreover, recent searches at flavor factories have renewed interest in moderately heavy axions with masses m_{a}\sim\mathcal{O}(\text{GeV}) Bauer:2017ris ; Bauer:2021mvw ; Chakraborty:2021wda ; Bertholet:2021hjl ; Bisht:2024hbs . Although existing studies have largely relied on the NDR scheme to determine renormalization group evolution (RGEs) and Wilson coefficients through matching at the electroweak scale, in this work, we employ for the first time in the axion context, the