The perturbative method for quantum correlations
Sacha Cerf, Harold Ollivier · 2026
Read The perturbative method for quantum correlations by Sacha Cerf, Harold Ollivier (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26875.txt.
Introduction
Cerf and Ollivier introduce a perturbative method for studying quantum correlations. The set of quantum correlations collects all outcome statistics that separated parties can share. Their method uses Lie theory for the unitary group to track small changes in quantum strategies. Near classical points, a Bell operator splits into smaller blocks they call subset games. This shows the quantum set has a flat boundary near classical points. It also points to new proof routes for open problems on correlation sets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sacha Cerf, Harold Ollivier |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73189 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26875
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The perturbative method for quantum correlations Sacha Cerf, Harold Ollivier Abstract The set 𝒬 \mathcal{Q} of quantum correlations is the collection of all possible probability distributions on measurement outcomes achievable by space-like separated parties sharing a quantum state. Since the original work of Tsirelson 32 , this set has mainly been studied through the means algebraic and convex geometry techniques. We introduce a perturbative method using Lie-theoretic tools for the unitary group to analyze the response of the evaluations of Bell functionals under infinitesimal unitary perturbations of quantum strategies. Our main result shows that, near classical deterministic points, an ( n , 2 , d ) (n,2,d) Bell operator decomposes into a direct sum of ( k , 2 , d − 1 ) (k,2,d-1) Bell operators which we call subset games . We then derive three key insights: (1) in the ( n , 2 , 2 ) (n,2,2) case, if p 0 p_{0} is classically optimal, it remains locally optimal even among 2-dimensional quantum strategies, implying in turn that the boundary of 𝒬 \mathcal{Q} is flat around classical deterministic points; (2) it suggests a proof strategy for Gisin’s open problem on correlations in 𝒬 ( D ) \mathcal{Q}(D) unattainable by projective strategies of the same dimension; and (3) it establishes that the Ansatz dimension is a critical resource for learning in distributed scenarios, even when the optimal solution admits a low-dimensional representation. I Introduction Quantum correlations and nonlocality The set of quantum correlations \mathcal{Q} lies at the core of the study of quantum nonlocality. It is defined as the collection of measurement statistics—represented as high-dimensional vectors—achievable by space-like separated parties sharing a quantum state. First formalized by Tsirelson 32 , it is strictly larger than its classical counterpart \mathcal{L} of statistics explainable by local hidden variable models 5 , demonstrating a quantum advantage in the correlations achievable by entangled parties. The comparative study of \mathcal{Q} and \mathcal{L} is mainly conducted through the means of violations of Bell inequalities , which are linear inequalities satisfied by every point in \mathcal{L} . The strict inclusion \mathcal{L}\subsetneq\mathcal{Q} is a foundational result which enabled an experimental proof of the existence of entanglement and the nonlocal nature of quantum mechanics 3 . Although a full characterization of \mathcal{Q} has been proven to be impossible due to the complexity-theoretic result \textrm{MIP}^{*}=\textrm{RE} 18 , its understanding remains a central challenge in quantum foundations. Nonlocal games A nonlocal game is an interactive protocol between a referee and a group of players. The referee sends each player a question, the players respond without communicating between them, and the referee decides whether they win based on the received answers. The game is called nonlocal if the players can achieve a higher winning probability than what classical physics allows. They do it using an entangled quantum state, and deciding their answer using a measurement depending on the question. The zoology of nonlocal games provides a rich framework to explore the quantum-classical divide in correlations. For instance: – The CHSH game 7 is the simplest Bell non-locality scenario, involving two parties, two measurement settings, and two outcomes. It demonstrates that quantum mechanics allows for correlations that violate classical bounds, with a maximal violation known as the Tsirelson bound. – Multipartite games, such as the GHZ game 15 , involve three or more parties and reveal stronger forms of non-locality. These games are essential for understanding the scalability of quantum advantage in multi-party settings. – Graph-based games extend the framework to more complex interaction structures, where parties are arranged according to a graph, and correlations are constrained by the graph’s topology. These games are particularly relevant for studying quantum networks and distributed quantum computing 26 ; 31 . Previous work Since Tsirelson’s seminal work 32 , the study of nonlocality has primarily relied on convex geometric and algebraic methods 22 ; 20 ; 14 , as well as hierarchies of semidefinite programs derived from operator algebras 25 ; 34 ; 27 ; 21 . Indeed, optimization of nonlocal strategies has been succesfully using SDP hierarchies to accomplish this task 25 ; 21 ; 30 . A new line of research on this topic is emerging by importing variational methods developed in the context of hybrid quantum-classical optimization 23 ; 6 and quantum machine learning 28 ; 29 . The idea is to use variational methods to learn optimal nonlocal strategies. Early results 12 ; 19 are encouraging and point toward the relevance of learning frameworks to probe the structure of \mathcal{Q} , especially around local deterministic points. Indeed, learning puts an emphasis on the need to better understand the geometric structure of the set of quantum correlations \mathcal{Q} . This is because the ability to learn is tied to the dynamical behavior of quantum strategies under perturbations. Yet, this topic has received very little attention until now. To our knowledge, this question has been raised only in 20 , which introduces a trigonometric parametrization of the extremal points that enables differentiation, but while being limited to the bipartite scenario. Proposed approach and results In this paper, we propose a perturbative method using Lie-theoretic tools on the unitary group. We analyze the response of the evaluation of a Bell functional under infinitesimal unitary perturbations of a quantum strategy. This dynamical perspective allows us to simplify the optimization problem around specific points of interest, namely the local deterministic correlations which form the vertices of the local polytope \mathcal{L} . Our approach yields three primary contributions: 1. A dimension reduction theorem showing that the second-order variation of the evaluation of a Bell functional around a deterministic point in the (n,2,d) scenario is governed by effective subset games with reduced output dimension ( d-1 ). 2. A proof that in the (n,2,2) scenario, the boundary of \mathcal{Q} is flat around every local deterministic point, meaning—in a specific way stated later—that there is no quantum extremal point in their immediate neighborhood. To our knowledge, this is the first mathematical statement on the geometry of the multipartite quantum set. 3. A proposed pathway to resolve an open problem formulated by Gisin on the existence, for a maximum allowed local dimension, of quantum correlations requiring non-projective POVMs that maximally violate some Bell inequality 13 (see question 10). This question is fundamental for quantum theory: it asks if POVMs, objects that naturally arise in the mathematical axiomatic of measurements, generalizing PVMs, are in a sense relevant for quantum nonlocality. It has been answered positively under the restriction that the parties share a Bell state 33 . Exhibiting a (n,2,d) Bell operator for which all the subset game operators at the classical optimum p_{0} are negative, but p_{0} is not a local optimum in \mathcal{Q}(d) —which could be achieved using the perturbative machinery we propose—would prove the existence of such correlations, with no constraint on the shared state. Our findings also position again nonlocal games as a compelling toy model for studying quantum variational learning (see 12 ), revealing fundamental limitations even in seemingly simple scenarios. Specifically, in the (n,2,2) setting—where qubit strategies are known to suffice for maximizing any Bell functional—we demonstrate that efficient learning via variational quantum models using qubits is hard, particularly when initialized from the