Global Structure, Non-Invertible PQ Symmetry, and the DFSZ Domain Wall Problem
Gongjun Choi, Sungwoo Hong, and Seth Koren · 2026
Read Global Structure, Non-Invertible PQ Symmetry, and the DFSZ Domain Wall Problem by Gongjun Choi, Sungwoo Hong, and Seth Koren (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26867.txt.
Introduction
Choi and co-authors revisit the domain wall problem of the DFSZ axion model. They show that the global structure of the symmetry group shapes the problem itself. In some quark flavor models, a non-invertible chiral symmetry keeps the domain walls stable. Small instantons can break that symmetry and resolve the problem. The authors also sketch gravitational wave signals from wall collapse. The work stresses that global structure matters in realistic particle models.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gongjun Choi, Sungwoo Hong, and Seth Koren |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 104335 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26867
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Global Structure, Non-Invertible PQ Symmetry, and the DFSZ Domain Wall Problem Gongjun Choi, Sungwoo Hong, and Seth Koren Abstract In recent years it has become increasingly clear that the previously overlooked “global structure” of symmetry groups can encode significant theoretical structure and, more importantly, have substantial phenomenological implications. With this in mind we re-examine the DFSZ axion, which suffers from a domain wall problem due to the Standard Model generation structure. We show that global structure ( G EW × U ( 1 ) PQ ) / ℤ 2 (G_{\rm EW}\times U(1)_{\rm PQ})/\mathbb{Z}_{2} acting between the Peccei–Quinn symmetry and the electroweak gauge group plays a crucial role in determining the precise nature of the domain wall problem, which has important implications in both cubic and quartic DFSZ. We then demonstrate that the stability of the domain walls is enforced by a non-invertible chiral symmetry in quark flavor Z ′ Z^{\prime} models which have additional global structure ( S U ( 3 ) C × G F ) / ℤ 3 (SU(3)_{C}\times G_{F})/\mathbb{Z}_{3} acting between the color and the gauged quark flavor group. The strategy of Non-invertible Naturalness then leads us to UV theories that resolve the domain wall problem through small-instanton-induced breaking of non-invertible symmetries. Finally, we sketch potential gravitational wave signatures arising from the annihilation of axion domain walls. Our work illustrates the importance of considerations of global structure in realistic models of particle physics. 1 Introduction 1.1 Global Structure of Symmetry Groups in Particle Physics As particle physicists we usually think about small perturbations of quantum fields. After all, the particles of a theory are determined by such a perturbative analysis, which probes only the local structure of the field space. However, the physics of a theory is not fully characterized by perturbations around the vacuum, and the global structure of symmetry groups as well as the topology of field space can have important implications for phenomenology. Hence to fully understand theories of particle physics, it is necessary to determine how models with different global structures can be distinguished both theoretically and experimentally. Here ‘global structure’ generally refers roughly to differences between symmetry groups which agree locally, but in this work we will consider only the differences between physics with symmetry group G and with symmetry group a quotient G/\Gamma , where \Gamma is a subgroup of the center of G . Importantly, this issue of global structure occurs in the Standard Model, where there are four possibilities for the gauge group G_{\rm SM}=\left(SU(3)_{C}\times SU(2)_{L}\times U(1)_{Y}\right)/\Gamma,\quad\Gamma=\{1,\mathbb{Z}_{2},\mathbb{Z}_{3},\mathbb{Z}_{6}\} (1) each consistent with all observed physics as they share the same Lie algebra 93 ; 124 . This issue has garnered recent attention, in part due to the new technology and insights from the program of Generalized Global Symmetries 70 —which provides a gauge invariant characterization of the difference between these theories as they possess different global one-form symmetries. Connected to the different magnetic one-form symmetries, one physical difference is found in the spectrum of fractional instantons, which modifies the quantization conditions for axion couplings 114 ; 41 ; 49 . Connected to the different electric one-form symmetries, the representation theory of the groups differs in the possible existence of fractionally charged particles 8 ; 99 ; 100 . Intriguingly the topological responses of the theory can differ as well 92 ; 128 , though the phenomenology in this direction is less well-explored. Systematic group theory methods to determine all possible discrete ambiguities, including both the global structure and topological sector, in spontaneously broken gauge theory, such as the Standard Model and Grand Unified Theories, will be presented elsewhere 73 ; 74 . Aside from the Standard Model, there has been little investigation of issues of global structure in particle physics. Axion theories seem ripe for such issues to play important roles—as a compact scalar, the axion is the lower-form analog of a gauge field; its potential arises from instanton effects; its cosmology depends on the spectrum of cosmic strings and domain walls. In this work, we will consider the DFSZ model 67 ; 141 , which is the canonical invisible axion model where the axion lives in fields which interact with the SM fermions. This model remains viable, but suffers from the domain wall problem (see next section) due to its close connection to the SM structure. In our analysis of this theory, the global structure of the symmetry groups and the topology of field space will have multiple important lessons for us. • When identifying the axion mode as a direction in field space, it is necessary to remember that the space of global symmetries exists as an abstract manifold and the axion direction cannot depend on a choice of basis, which is often confused in the literature. (See Section 2.1 ) • The cubic DFSZ model has overlooked \mathbb{Z}_{2} global structure shared between the electroweak gauge group and the Peccei-Quinn symmetry, which impacts the spectrum of cosmic strings and domain walls. In particular this model has a \mathbb{Z}_{3} domain wall problem rather than a \mathbb{Z}_{6} domain wall problem, as has often been claimed. (See Section 2.3 ) • If we gauge a subgroup of the approximate quark flavor symmetry of the SM which has shared global structure with SU(3)_{C} , then due to the existence of fractional instantons the \mathbb{Z}_{3} subgroup of Peccei-Quinn symmetry is converted into a non-invertible symmetry. The strategy of non-invertible naturalness then leads us to an elegant solution to the domain wall problem. (See Section 2.4 ) • The quartic DFSZ model legitimately has a \mathbb{Z}_{6} domain wall problem, but if we embed this in a left-right model there is again \mathbb{Z}_{2} global structure shared between the electroweak gauge group and the Peccei-Quinn symmetry. Now the domain wall problem is reduced to \mathbb{Z}_{3} , which can again become non-invertible and the domain wall problem can be fully resolved. (See Section 3 ) That this simple, canonical BSM theory has such rich issues of global structure suggests that it is worth re-examining many ideas about BSM physics with these concepts in mind. 1.2 The Domain Wall Problem The domain wall problem may occur whenever a discrete symmetry is spontaneously broken, and in particular plagues many well-motivated models of axions where the Peccei-Quinn symmetry is tied to the non-trivial structure of the Standard Model. We will get into the subtleties of this problem below, but in brief a Peccei-Quinn symmetry with a non-minimal anomaly coefficient \mathcal{A}>1 yields an axion potential with \mathcal{A} minima and one expects it to have N_{\rm DW}=\mathcal{A} distinct domain walls. For N_{\rm DW}>1 this results in the formation of a stable string-domain wall network. This occurs when the axion becomes massive and starts rolling down its potential which happens for m\simeq H , and different patches of spacetime can choose different, uncorrelated vacua. Domain wall network energy density, once it enters the scaling regime, is known to redshift slowly as \rho_{\rm DW}\propto t^{-1} , which corresponds to \rho_{\rm DW}\propto a^{-2} in RD or \rho_{\rm DW}\propto a^{-3/2} in MD. This in turn implies that any stable domain wall network eventually dominate the energy budget of the universe, in contrast with observed cosmology. One commonly discussed resolution is to assume a