Who Checks the Checker? Enhancing Component-level Architectural SEU Fault Tolerance for End-to-End SoC Protection
Michael Rogenmoser 1 , Philippe Sauter 1 , Chen Wu 1 , Angelo Garofalo 1 2 , Luca Benini 1 2 · 2026
Read Who Checks the Checker? Enhancing Component-level Architectural SEU Fault Tolerance for End-to-End SoC Protection by Michael Rogenmoser 1 , Philippe Sauter 1 , Chen Wu 1 , Angelo Garofalo 1 2 , Luca Benini 1 2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26637.txt.
Introduction
Rogenmoser and co-authors close the gaps in fault protection for chips exposed to radiation. Guarding cores and memories alone leaves voting logic and interconnects as single points of failure. Their plan overlaps several component-level defences so the whole system-on-chip stays covered end to end. They show the design on a RISC-V microcontroller, tested by simulation-based fault injection. The chip tolerates over 99.9% of injected upsets in both RTL and netlist form. It also cuts implementation overhead by 22% versus one global scheme.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael Rogenmoser 1 , Philippe Sauter 1 , Chen Wu 1 , Angelo Garofalo 1 2 , Luca Benini 1 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35477 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26637
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Who Checks the Checker? Enhancing Component-level Architectural SEU Fault Tolerance for End-to-End SoC Protection Thanks: This work has received funding from the Swiss State Secretariat for Education, Research, and Innovation (SERI) under the SwissChips initiative. Michael Rogenmoser 1 , Philippe Sauter 1 , Chen Wu 1 , Angelo Garofalo 1 2 , Luca Benini 1 2 Abstract Single-event upset (SEU) fault tolerance for systems-on-chip (SoCs) in radiation-heavy environments is often addressed by architectural fault-tolerance approaches protecting individual SoC components (e.g., cores, memories) in isolation. However, the protection of voting logic and interconnections among components is also critical, as these become single points of failure in the design. We investigate combining multiple fault-tolerance approaches targeting individual SoC components, including interconnect and voting logic to ensure end-to-end SoC -level architectural SEU fault tolerance, while minimizing implementation area overheads. Enforcing an overlap between the protection methods ensures hardening of the whole design without gaps, while curtailing overheads. We demonstrate our approach on a RISC-V microcontroller SoC . SEU fault-tolerance is assessed with simulation-based fault injection. Overheads are assessed with full physical implementation. Tolerance to over 99.9 % 99.9\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} of faults in both RTL and implemented netlist is demonstrated. Furthermore, the design exhibits 22 % 22\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} lower implementation overhead compared to a single global fault-tolerance method, such as fine-grained triplication. I Introduction Fault tolerance of integrated circuits and systems-on-chip (SoCs) is of crucial importance for systems operating in radiation-heavy or safety-critical environments. Space [ 9 ] , high-energy physics detectors [ 2 ] , avionics [ 7 ] , and functional-safety automotive systems [ 3 ] increasingly deploy complex safe microcontroller-class SoCs that must continue operating correctly even under single-event upsets (SEUs) and single-event transients (SETs) . In many of these domains, even a single undetected or uncorrected error is unacceptable, as silent data corruption can compromise mission objectives, safety guarantees, or system-wide dependability requirements. On the other hand, the area overhead of fault tolerance is always a concern as it implies a significant cost increase. Commercial designs targeting space applications, such as the NOEL-V SoC [ 1 ] , often rely on radiation-hardened technologies to achieve fault-tolerance, accompanied by architectural solutions such as error correction codes (ECC) . While these technologies can reduce the likelihood of SEUs in the design, they do not prevent them completely. Further, they add area, timing, and power overhead, and are not always available, especially for modern technology nodes. As an alternative, fault-tolerance can be addressed at the architectural level. Fine-grained triplication of the entire SoC design [ 2 , 23 ] is a classic approach in high-energy physics, leveraging tools such as Triple Modular Redundancy Generator (TMRG) [ 11 ] , which triplicates the entire design and adds voters throughout. While these solutions avoid depending on radiation-hardened technologies, they come at a very high cost, showing a 4.8\text{\,}\times 6.9\text{\,}\times area increase [ 2 ] compared to the baseline, unprotected, SoC . To reduce the area overhead, numerous architectural fault-tolerance approaches have been proposed to protect individual SoC components (e.g., cores, memories) with component-specific approaches. A common technique is lockstepped processor cores execution [ 10 , 21 , 18 , 12 , 15 ] , which enables error detection at the cores’ boundary through checking or voting mechanisms. Other methods [ 20 , 17 ] protect critical units within the processor cores, in an effort to further decrease overhead with respect to full-core lockstep. Additional work [ 22 ] adds triple modular redundancy (TMR) to flip-flops (FFs) in the design, along with dedicated lockstepping of the processor and fault monitors, but still fails to address SETs in combinational logic connecting the TMR FFs . Yet all these approaches introduce a new vulnerability: the voters and checking logic themselves, which remain unprotected. While small in area, these components become critical points of failure. To address this issue, the voters may require an implementation based on radiation-hardened gates and libraries [ 13 ] . Unfortunately, such gates and libraries are not always available, especially when targeting advanced technologies. Furthermore, the combination of component-level architectural fault tolerance techniques is rarely examined in terms of how they interact when applied together to protect an entire SoC . Prior work [ 16 ] evaluating a SoC protected with ECC memory and triple-core lockstep (TCLS) processor cores clearly shows that, especially in extreme environments, only applying such techniques is insufficient, as the remaining vulnerable components at the boundaries and outside the protected regions have a significant residual impact on end-to-end SoC -level reliability. The necessity to properly protect peripherals is also highlighted in [ 4 ] , yet it is often left as a minor concern. These observations strongly motivate the need for end-to-end methods and their evaluation that ensure that all components, including voting, encoding, and interconnect logic, are protected while minimizing area overheads. To address these challenges, we propose targeted protection methods for each subsystem in a SoC , with a novel overlapping protection approach . Overlap, where the checking logic of one domain using method A is included within the connected protection domain using method B, enforces that the boundary logic between protection domains, including voters and ECC decoders/encoders, is never left exposed, ensuring that errors in the checking logic itself are detected and corrected. We demonstrate our approach on croc , a compact RISC-V microcontroller unit (MCU) SoC , and show through simulation-based fault injection that overlapping protection defines a new Pareto-optimal point in the reliability–area design space, achieving over 99.9\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} fault coverage while reducing area by 22\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} compared to full triplication. The contributions of the paper are: • A novel architectural fault-tolerance overlapping method to ensure detection and correction even for the checkers and voters at the boundary of protected components (without resorting to rad-hard gates). • A complete fault-tolerant RISC-V-based MCU SoC using dedicated architectural fault tolerance methods for each component, and exploiting overlapping protection, to achieve full end-to-end fault-tolerance. • Analysis of the timing and area impacts of incrementally adding protection methods. • A comprehensive validation of the proposed architecture demonstrating tolerance to faults throughout the design and in typically vulnerable voters, using both register transfer level (RTL) and synthesized netlist for fault injection simulation. II Background II-A The croc Microcontroller unit The croc MCU design [ 19 ] is a simple, open-source 1 1 1 https://github.com/pulp-platform/croc SoC . As illustrated in Figure 1a , it features a single 32-bit 2-stage RISC-V core with separate instruction fetch and data interfaces supporting the Open Bus Interface (OBI) protocol. Connected through an OBI interconnect, two static random-access memory (SRAM) banks offer separated data and instruction memory for a total of 16\text{\,}\mathrm{KiB} of memory. The SoC also features a timer module, as well as UART and GPIO peripherals for input/output (IO) . Finally, to enable proper programming and basic functionality, the SoC exposes a JTAG interface with a RISC-V debug module, as well as some dedicated control registers for programming and boot. II-B Fault & Protection Model: Single Events are Corrected In this paper, we focus on all transient single faults ( SEUs & SETs ) and the accumulation thereof [ 6 ] . Observing at a logic-level, the primary expected effects are SEUs , bit-flips in state-saving elements such