New directions in the study of prime ideals in rational, nilpotent Iwasawa algebras
Adam Jones, William Woods · 2026
Read New directions in the study of prime ideals in rational, nilpotent Iwasawa algebras by Adam Jones, William Woods (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26626.txt.
Introduction
Jones and Woods advance the study of prime ideals in Iwasawa algebras of nilpotent p-adic Lie groups. A standing conjecture says every prime ideal in these completed group algebras has a canonical standard form. The authors verify the conjecture for several new classes of nilpotent groups. The classes cover groups tied to the positive subalgebra of almost all classical and exceptional types. Type C stands out as the curious exception their methods do not reach.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Adam Jones, William Woods |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74649 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26626
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
New directions in the study of prime ideals in rational, nilpotent Iwasawa algebras Adam Jones, William Woods Abstract Let G G be a nilpotent p p -valuable (compact p p -adic Lie) group. There is an ongoing investigation into the prime ideals of its completed group algebra ( Iwasawa algebra ) ℤ p [ [ G ] ] \mathbb{Z}_{p}[[G]] , and there remains an open conjecture that they can all be proved to have a canonical standard form. We very this conjecture for several new classes of nilpotent groups, including those corresponding to the positive subalgebra of almost all classical and exceptional types, curiously excluding those of type C C . † † 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification : 22E35, 22E27, 20C07, 16W70, 16W80, 17B22 1 Introduction Fix a prime p . and let G be a p -valuable group in the sense of [ 10 ] (see Definition 2.5 below). This is a torsion-free, pro- p group, isomorphic (as a topological group) to a closed subgroup of some \mathrm{GL}_{n}(\mathbb{Z}_{p}) consisting of upper-triangular matrices congruent to the identity mod p (if p>2 ) or mod 4 (if p=2 ). Let R be a commutative pseudocompact ring. The completed group algebra (also known to number theorists as the Iwasawa algebra ) of G over R is defined as R[[G]]=\varprojlim_{U}R[G/U], where R[G/U] is the ordinary group algebra of the (finite, discrete) group G/U with coefficients in R , as U runs over the set of open normal subgroups of G . Now fix a finite extension of fields K/\mathbb{Q}_{p} , with ring of integers \mathcal{O} , uniformiser \pi , and residue field k=\mathcal{O}/\pi . There is an ongoing investigation into the prime ideals of \mathcal{O}G:=\mathcal{O}[[G]] , especially when \mathcal{O}=\mathbb{Z}_{p} , beginning with the paper [ 1 ] , and advanced in several subsequent articles, including [ 3 ] , [ 4 ] , [ 7 ] , [ 9 ] , [ 2 ] and [ 12 ] . We say that a prime ideal P of \mathcal{O}G is standard if we can find a closed normal subgroup H of G such that G^{*}:=G/H is p -valuable and the image of P under the surjection \mathcal{O}G\to\mathcal{O}G^{*} is centrally generated. We say that P is virtually standard if P\cap\mathcal{O}U is standard for some open subgroup U of G [ 9 , Definition 1.1] . The main conjecture in the study of prime ideals in Iwasawa algebras (see e.g. [ 9 , Conjecture 1.2] ) roughly states that all prime ideals in \mathcal{O}G are virtually standard. This is now known for large classes of prime ideals in various groups, but in general it remains open. To simplify the conjecture, fix a prime ideal P of \mathcal{O}G and set P^{\dagger}=\ker(G\to\mathcal{O}G^{\times}\to(\mathcal{O}G/P)^{\times}), a closed normal subgroup of G : then P contains the augmentation ideal \varepsilon=(P^{\dagger}-1)\mathcal{O}G , so we can pass to the quotient P^{*}=P/\varepsilon\subseteq\mathcal{O}G/\varepsilon\cong\mathcal{O}G^{*}, where G^{*}=G/P^{\dagger} . Then P^{*} is a prime ideal of \mathcal{O}G^{*} , and now we have (P^{*})^{\dagger}=1 , so to prove P is standard, we only need to prove that P^{*} is centrally generated. Note: The resulting group G^{*} may no longer be p -valuable, as it may no longer be torsion-free. However, there is a finite normal subgroup F^{*}\leq G^{*} such that the quotient G^{*}/F^{*} is p -valuable, and P^{*}\cap\mathcal{O}F^{*} is the intersection of a G -orbit of prime ideals of \mathcal{O}F^{*}\cong\mathcal{O}[F^{*}] , the (ordinary) group algebra of F^{*} . Hence it is considered relatively harmless to assume that F^{*}=1 , or equivalently to assume without loss of generality from the start that P^{\dagger}=1 . We say that a prime ideal P of \mathcal{O}G is faithful if P^{\dagger}=1 . Then setting Z=Z(G) as the centre of G , then our main conjecture can be restated as follows. Conjecture A. If P is a faithful prime ideal of \mathcal{O}G , then P=(P\cap\mathcal{O}Z)\mathcal{O}G . There are two natural cases to consider here. 1. If \pi\in P , we may quotient out by (\pi) and pass to kG:=k[[G]]\cong\mathcal{O}G/(\pi) . This version of Conjecture A was asked as [ 1 , Question O] , and has since been proven true for G nilpotent [ 4 , Theorem 8.4] , and for G of the form \mathbb{Z}_{p}^{d}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{p} [ 7 , Theorem 1.4] . 2. If \pi\not\in P , we may invert \pi and pass to KG:=K\otimes_{\mathcal{O}}\mathcal{O}G=\mathcal{O}G[\frac{1}{\pi}] . Conjecture A is known for prime ideals of infinite codimension when G is semisimple of type A or D [ 12 , Theorem 3] , [ 11 , Theorem 2] , or for primitive ideals when G is nilpotent [ 9 , Theorem A] . (Warning: KG is not the same as K[[G]] . For example, if we take \mathbb{Z}_{p}[[x]] and invert p , we do not get \mathbb{Q}_{p}[[x]] .) In this paper, we restrict to case 2, about which much less is known. We will also assume that G is a nilpotent group, and we want to build on the results from [ 9 ] and try to prove Conjecture A for all prime ideals, rather than just primitive ones. In § 3 , we will recall a certain characteristic abelian subgroup A(G) of G , originally constructed in [ 9 , §3.5] , containing the centre Z . When approaching the conjecture for general prime results, the strongest result to date is: Theorem. [ 9 , Theorem B] Setting A:=A(G) , if P is a faithful prime ideal of KG , then P=(P\cap KA)KG . Of course, if A(G)=Z , then Conjecture A follows immediately from this theorem. There are cases when this is true, for example when G has nilpotency class 2, but it is sadly false in the vast majority of cases of interest. Indeed, whenever the second centre Z_{2}(G) is abelian (which is the case for all nilpotent groups arising as positive root subgroups) then A(G) is strictly larger than the centre. Moreover, the construction of A(G) relies on an iterative procedure (which can be of arbitrary finite length), and so it can be time-consuming to compute. In this note, we will define a smaller subgroup B(G) of G , with Z\subseteq B(G)\subseteq A(G) . This subgroup is much more explicitly constructed, and can often be computed more easily. Our main result is very similar: Theorem 1. (Theorem 3.10 ) Setting B:=B(G) , if P is a faithful prime ideal of KG , then P=(P\cap KB)KG .∎ Needless to say, how much of an improvement this result is depends entirely on how much smaller than A(G) the subgroup B(G) actually is. There are several cases when B(G)=A(G) (including of course all the cases when A(G)=Z ), so this result constitutes no improvement in this setting. However, in § 4 , we will explore a number of examples of groups G for which we can prove that B(G) is a proper subgroup of A(G) , and in several of them we even have that B(G)=Z . Using our main theorem this is enough to prove Conjecture A for these groups, and in particular for the majority of those groups that arise from Lie theory: Theorem 2. (Corollary 4.9 ) If G is nilpotent and Lie (G) is the positive root subalgebra of a split-semisimple \mathbb{Q}_{p}